How we prove a calcium bisglycinate lot is the chelate
Calcium bisglycinate cannot be identified from its calcium figure. Calcium citrate tetrahydrate reports about 21.1% calcium, calcium sulfate dihydrate and dicalcium phosphate dihydrate about 23.3%, and the bisglycinate itself about 21.3% — all inside or beside the catalog window. The identity case is built in layers: appearance and solubility, calcium by EDTA, glycine by infrared spectrum and reaction, a calculated calcium-to-glycine ratio, and a phase screen for the common calcium salts and free glycine. The layers have to agree.
A calcium assay can only name the element; the ligand, its ratio and the crystalline phases are what identify the chelate.
Five layers of proof
| Check | Method | Evidence | Blind spot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appearance and solubility | Visual; water | White powder, sparingly soluble, near-neutral 5% suspension | Any white calcium powder can look the same |
| Calcium | Complexometric EDTA | 18.5–23.0% calcium | Citrate, sulfate and phosphate sit in the same window |
| Glycine | Infrared spectrum and glycine reaction | Glycine is present | A blend with added glycine also passes |
| Ligand ratio | Glycine by HPLC; calcium by EDTA; calculated | A calcium-to-glycine ratio near 1:2 | Needs a quantitative glycine assay and a free-glycine figure |
| Phase screen | XRD and FTIR | Crystalline carbonate, citrate, sulfate, phosphate or free glycine; coordination | Needs reference standards and a stated detection limit |
Run the layers in that order. Calcium narrows the field; glycine shows the ligand is present; the ratio shows how much is there; the phase screen looks for the crystalline substitutes a blend can hide. A contaminant screen sits beside them and does not replace any of the five.
The calcium-to-glycine ratio
The anhydrous formula has a mass of 188.20, made up of one calcium, two glycine ligands and no water. A pure 1:2 chelate carries 21.3% calcium and 79.8% glycine, which is a molar ratio of 2.00 glycine per calcium. The ratio comes from arithmetic on the two assays, and no calcium result can supply it.
Work it on a 100 g basis. A lot reporting 20.5% calcium and 76.0% glycine gives 0.5115 mol calcium and 1.0124 mol glycine, a ratio of 1.98. A lot at 21.0% calcium and 70.0% glycine gives 1.78; it still passes a calcium-only specification, but it is not the same chelate.
Total glycine includes free glycine. In that example, at 3% free glycine the bound glycine is 73.0%, and the ratio on the bound figure is lower than on the total. Ask for the free-glycine result beside the total and state which figure the ratio uses. The catalog certificate identifies glycine by reaction and infrared spectrum; a quantitative glycine assay and a free-glycine figure are separate lines to agree when the ratio is a release criterion.
The catalog window of 18.5–23.0% is wider than the 21.3% stoichiometric figure. At 23.0% calcium with 79.8% glycine the ratio would be 1.85, not 2.00, so a high calcium result is not automatically a better chelate. The ratio checks the form; calcium checks the element.
XRD, FTIR and the phase screen
X-ray diffraction reads the crystalline phases in the powder. Calcite, the common crystal form of calcium carbonate, shows its principal reflection at about 29.4° two-theta; lime and portlandite have their own sets; calcium citrate, calcium sulfate as gypsum and dicalcium phosphate have identifiable patterns; free glycine has polymorphs with distinct reflections. A scan that reports “no crystalline impurity detected” should state the detection limit, because a statement without a limit describes the method, not the sample.
Infrared spectroscopy reads the coordination. The carboxylate stretching bands of glycine shift when the carboxylate binds a metal, and the N–H region changes with the salt form. The lot spectrum should match a reference standard of the same hydrate and grade, not a library printout. XRD finds phases; FTIR reads the bonding; the ratio reads the proportion. None of the three replaces the others.
The XRD method note sets out the sample preparation and the detection-limit question, and the FTIR note explains the limits of a spectrum comparison.
The substitutes that fit the calcium window
| Material | Approximate calcium | What the calcium figure does | What exposes it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calcium carbonate | 40% | Lifts calcium; a small addition moves the result | Effervescence in acid; calcite by XRD; no glycine |
| Calcium citrate tetrahydrate | 21.1% | Matches the chelate almost exactly | Citrate reaction and IR; citrate by XRD; no glycine |
| Calcium sulfate dihydrate | 23.3% | Matches the top of the window | Sulfate test; gypsum by XRD; no glycine |
| Dicalcium phosphate dihydrate | 23.3% | Matches the top of the window | Phosphorus test; phosphate by XRD; no glycine |
| Calcium oxide or hydroxide | 71% or 54% | Lifts calcium and pH | Alkaline slurry; lime or portlandite by XRD |
| Added glycine | 0% | No effect on calcium; makes glycine tests positive | Free glycine; ratio; glycine by XRD |
The blend route is the hardest case. Calcium carbonate or citrate can be mixed with free glycine so that calcium and the glycine reaction are both positive, and the blend can be tuned to a ratio near 2.00. The free-glycine result, the phase screen and the absence of the chelate's coordination in FTIR are what expose it.
How to write the specification
- “Calcium bisglycinate, C4H8CaN2O4, CAS 136-26-5.”
- “Calcium 18.5–23.0% by complexometric EDTA, reported on the material as sold.”
- “Identification by infrared spectrum and glycine reaction, conforms to reference.”
- “Loss on drying ≤5.0%; pH 6.0–8.0 (5% suspension); ≥95% through 80 mesh; bulk density 0.50–0.80 g/mL.”
- “Glycine by HPLC and free glycine on request; calculated calcium-to-glycine molar ratio reported with the lot.”
- “XRD and FTIR phase screen: no crystalline calcium carbonate, calcium citrate, calcium sulfate, dicalcium phosphate or free glycine detected; detection limit reported.”
- “No added calcium salt or glycine at any stage; heavy metals and microbiology as per the catalog.”
A specification that names only calcium, mesh and a glycine reaction describes a calcium powder with glycine in it. The ratio, the free-glycine figure and the phase screen make it specific to the chelate.
Five questions for the supplier
- What is the calcium result, the method and the basis: as sold or dried?
- Is glycine identified by infrared spectrum and reaction, and can you report glycine by HPLC and free glycine?
- What is the calculated calcium-to-glycine molar ratio for this lot, and which glycine figure was used?
- Is there an XRD and FTIR phase screen for carbonate, citrate, sulfate, phosphate and free glycine, and what is its stated detection limit?
- Is any calcium salt or glycine added at any stage, and what batch record supports the answer?
Those five answers are the specification; a calcium percentage is not. The certificate lines are on the COA page, the salt choice on the salt comparison page, the fill arithmetic on the bisglycinate versus citrate page, and the catalog specification on the product hub.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation