Calcium bisglycinate or citrate: choosing a calcium salt
Calcium bisglycinate and calcium citrate tetrahydrate carry almost the same amount of elemental calcium, about 21%, so a 200 mg label claim needs a similar mass of either salt. The choice is not a calcium-load decision: it turns on the ingredient name on the label, the ligand, the water the powder brings, the dosage form and the file the buyer has to hold. This page compares the two salts and sets out what changes when a formula switches from one to the other.
At about 21% calcium each, the two salts need almost the same fill weight; what changes is the ingredient name, the ligand and the evidence behind it.
Why the comparison starts with the label
The question usually comes from a citrate formula and a request to drop in the bisglycinate. The calcium figure says it nearly can. The rest of the specification says it cannot, because the declared ingredient, the identity test, the loss on drying and the bulk density all change.
Both salts are used in capsules, tablets, powder sticks and gummies. Neither is the high-calcium option: calcium carbonate carries about 40% calcium, and a formula that needs the smallest possible dose mass is a different discussion. Between the bisglycinate and the citrate, the calcium difference is small enough that the label and the process should decide.
The two salts side by side
| Item | Calcium bisglycinate | Calcium citrate tetrahydrate |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | C4H8CaN2O4 | C12H10Ca3O14·4H2O |
| CAS number | 136-26-5 | 813-94-5 |
| Calcium, catalog range | 18.5–23.0% (EDTA) | 21.0–22.0% (EDTA) |
| Calcium, stoichiometric | 21.3% | 21.1% |
| Salt mass for 200 mg calcium | 870–1,081 mg | 909–952 mg |
| Loss on drying | ≤5.0% | ≤13.0% |
| Bulk density | 0.50–0.80 g/mL | 0.60–0.95 g/mL |
| Identity test | Infrared spectrum and glycine reaction | Citrate reaction and infrared spectrum |
The calcium figures are catalog ranges; the batch COA confirms the result for a particular lot. The salt mass column is arithmetic from the ends of each range. A citrate lot at 22.0% needs 909 mg for a 200 mg claim, while a bisglycinate lot at 18.5% needs 1,081 mg, about 19% more powder for the same label figure.
Powder, water and flow
Both catalog grades are 80-mesh powders with granulated and milled options. The bisglycinate bulk density is 0.50–0.80 g/mL; the citrate is 0.60–0.95 g/mL. The citrate therefore tends to fill a smaller volume for the same mass, which can matter when a capsule size or a stick-pack volume is already fixed. Density varies with the lot and the grade, so confirm it on the batch COA.
The water load is the larger difference. Calcium citrate tetrahydrate carries about 12.6% water in the crystal, which is why its loss-on-drying limit is 13.0%. The bisglycinate limit is 5.0%. In a low-moisture tablet or a gummy, that difference changes the water activity of the matrix and the drying step, even though both powders are sold as dry solids.
Solubility is similar in direction: both are sparingly soluble in water, and a 5% bisglycinate suspension is close to neutral at pH 6.0–8.0. A drink mix made with either salt is a dispersion rather than a clear solution, and sediment on standing is a physical observation, not an assay failure.
What the dosage form needs
At about 21% calcium, 200 mg of calcium needs roughly 0.9–1.0 g of either salt. A 500 mg capsule fill of the salt carries about 105 mg calcium, so a 200 mg claim means two capsules; a 1,000 mg tablet fill carries about 210 mg. A 500 mg stick claim needs about 2.4 g of salt, which is a formula and package decision before it is a salt decision.
Capsules care about bulk density and flow; tablets care about compressibility, granulation and tooling; sticks care about dispersion and sedimentation; gummies care about water activity, pH and heat. The salt choice should follow the dosage form, not the other way round. A granulated grade can solve a flow problem that a milled grade creates, and both salts offer a granulated option.
How to write the specification after a switch
When a formula switches, the specification has to switch with it. Name the salt and the CAS number; state the calcium range and the EDTA method; keep the identity test that belongs to the salt; carry loss on drying, mesh and bulk density; and add the contaminant and microbiological limits that the market requires.
- “Calcium bisglycinate, C4H8CaN2O4, CAS 136-26-5; calcium 18.5–23.0% by complexometric EDTA.”
- “Identification by infrared spectrum and glycine reaction, conforms to reference.”
- “Loss on drying ≤5.0%; pH 6.0–8.0 (5% suspension); ≥95% through 80 mesh; bulk density 0.50–0.80 g/mL.”
- “Calcium citrate tetrahydrate, C12H10Ca3O14·4H2O, CAS 813-94-5; calcium 21.0–22.0% by complexometric EDTA.”
- “Citrate identification by reaction and infrared spectrum, conforms to reference; loss on drying ≤13.0%.”
A label that says calcium citrate needs a citrate identity result; a bisglycinate certificate cannot support it. The reverse is also true: a citrate certificate does not show glycine, so it cannot support a chelate label. The declared name and the certificate have to match.
When the switch is not the answer
Stay with the citrate when the existing label, supplier and tablet tooling are built around it and the only argument for switching is the calcium figure. At about 21% each, the switch gains little in fill weight, and it requires a new specification, a new identity test and a new label.
Choose the bisglycinate when the label needs the chelate and the file can support the glycine identity and the calcium-to-glycine ratio. Choose neither when the real need is the highest calcium load per gram; that is the carbonate comparison, not this one. The switch changes the certificate, the specification and the label, and those three changes should be planned together.
The catalog specification is published on the calcium bisglycinate product page. The certificate lines are read on the COA page, the fill-weight arithmetic is on the bisglycinate versus citrate page, and the identity tests are on the identity page. The citrate specification is on the calcium citrate product page.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation