Soy vs sunflower phosphatidylserine: allergen, profile and label
Soy and sunflower phosphatidylserine are the same phospholipid class made from different lecithins. The source changes the allergen declaration, the fatty-acid and sterol fingerprint and the EU regulatory route; it does not change the PS assay. Choose the source before the grade, because the label is built on it.
Soy and sunflower PS can both meet a 50% assay while carrying different allergens, fatty acids and regulatory routes.
Two lecithins, one phospholipid class
Commercial PS is made by converting the phospholipids in lecithin, and lecithin comes from a plant source. Soy lecithin is a by-product of soybean oil refining; sunflower lecithin comes from sunflower oil. Both contain phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine, the starting materials for the conversion that attaches serine. The conversion and purification decide the PS content; the lecithin decides the fatty acids, sterols and minor components.
Either source is commercially produced at 20%, 50% or 70% PS; the catalog grade is the soy-derived 50% powder. The percentage is a concentration, not a source marker: 50% soy and 50% sunflower powders can share an assay range and still be different materials. The source belongs on the certificate and the label.
The allergen question
Soy is a major food allergen in the EU, the US and the UK. In the EU, soybeans and products thereof are on Annex II to Regulation 1169/2011, and soy lecithin is not one of the exempted highly refined oils. In the US, soy is a major allergen under FALCPA, and the refined-oil exemption does not automatically cover a lecithin-derived ingredient. The UK retains the same list. A soy-derived PS therefore needs a soy declaration unless the allergen file proves an exemption, and the file needs a documented protein analysis.
Soy protein can carry through the lecithin and the conversion. The protein level in refined lecithin is low, and the PS powder is not a protein ingredient, but low is not zero. Ask for the soy protein data and the detection limit behind it, and read a “soy-free” statement on a soy-derived lot as a documentation failure until the data supports it.
Sunflower is not on the EU Annex II list, the US major-allergen list or the UK list. That makes a sunflower PS easier to label for a soy-allergic consumer, but it is not allergen-free in a general sense: sunflower seed protein can still be an allergen for some individuals, and the ingredient should be named.
| Market | Soy-derived PS | Sunflower-derived PS | Label action |
|---|---|---|---|
| EU | Soy is on Annex II | Not on Annex II | Declare soy and emphasise it; name sunflower as an ingredient |
| US | Soy is a major allergen under FALCPA | Not a major allergen | “Contains: soy” on a soy product; name sunflower |
| UK | Retained Annex II list | Not on the list | Same as the EU approach |
The fatty-acid and sterol profile
Both lecithins are linoleic-rich, so the PS from either source is dominated by linoleic acid. The difference is in the minor fatty acids. Soy lecithin carries a measurable linolenic fraction; sunflower lecithin is low in linolenic acid and comparatively higher in oleic acid. Linolenic acid has three double bonds and oxidises more readily, so a soy PS can be more prone to oxidation under the same handling — one factor among several, not a verdict on either source.
The sterol pattern is a second fingerprint. Soy lecithin and sunflower lecithin have different sterol ratios, and the pattern survives the phospholipid conversion well enough to help a laboratory check the source. The phospholipid class ratios also differ: the balance of PC, PE, PI and PA around the PS peak is not identical between the two sources. None of these profiles is a specification on its own, but together they make a source substitution visible.
| Marker | Soy PS | Sunflower PS | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dominant fatty acid | Linoleic-rich | Linoleic-rich | Similar PS chemistry; not a source marker alone |
| Linolenic acid | Measurable fraction | Low | Oxidation tendency, flavour, stability |
| Sterol pattern | Soy lecithin pattern | Sunflower lecithin pattern | Source verification and adulteration checks |
| Phospholipid classes | PC, PE, PI, PA balance | Different balance | Profile comparison, not only the PS figure |
| Allergen | Soy declaration | No soy declaration | Label and market access |
Regulatory route and label
In the EU, the Union list in Regulation (EU) 2017/2470 contains a route for phosphatidylserine from soya phospholipids, with the labelling designation “Soya phosphatidylserine” and a maximum of 3 g per day of PS in food supplements at this review. Other phospholipid routes have their own entries. A sunflower PS is not automatically covered by the soya entry, so the supplier has to identify the entry the sunflower material relies on.
In the US, PS has GRAS notices for soy, sunflower and fish sources, and the dietary-ingredient route is the usual one for a supplement. GRAS status is specific to the source and the use; a soy notice is not evidence for a sunflower powder. The label names the ingredient and carries the allergen statement that the source requires.
In the UK, the retained framework applies and the GB novel-food register is the reference. Northern Ireland applies the EU regime. In all three markets the label should name the source, declare the allergen that applies and use the designation that belongs to the route; the compliance page sets out the full file.
When to choose which
Choose soy when the EU soya route is the one the project has checked, the supply and specification are established, and the label can carry a soy declaration. Choose sunflower when a soy-free label is a real requirement, when the customer's allergen policy excludes soy, or when the lower linolenic fraction suits a long shelf life — provided the route and supply are confirmed.
Do not regard the source as a marketing preference that can be changed at the last minute. A source switch changes the allergen statement, the label designation, the certificate, the stability profile and possibly the regulatory route. It is a change-control event, not a substitution. If the project is still comparing sources, keep both specifications open until the market and the label are fixed.
The grade page covers the 20/50/70 decision, the identity page explains how the source is verified, and the phosphatidylserine hub carries the catalog specification.
How to write the source into the specification
Write the source into the product name: “Phosphatidylserine (soy-derived), 50% powder” or “Phosphatidylserine (sunflower-derived), 50% powder.” Then add the PS range and method, the phospholipid profile, the peroxide and acid values, the loss on drying, the mesh and the allergen statement. The certificate should repeat the source and the lot code, and the allergen statement should be specific to that lot rather than a generic company statement.
If the source is soy and the customer needs a soy-free claim, the answer is a different material, not a different certificate. If the source is sunflower, say so on the label and keep the soy statement off it — but only after the line has been checked for soy cross-contact. The COA page lists the certificate lines, and the HPLC method note explains the separation behind the PS figure.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation