Where L-lysine HCl is permitted, and what the file must show
On this page
- Three markets, three instruments
- The European Union: an amino acid outside the positive lists
- The United States: a dietary ingredient and a GRAS food substance
- The United Kingdom: retained rules, with Northern Ireland apart
- Contaminants: specification against law
- Claims and the label name
- What the file must contain
- A short review checklist
L-lysine hydrochloride is permitted as a food supplement ingredient in the EU, US and UK, but each market answers four questions separately: whether the form is permitted, which contaminant limits apply, what the label says and what may be claimed. In the EU an amino acid sits outside the harmonised vitamin and mineral lists, so general food law and member-state rules decide; the US regulates it as a dietary ingredient; the UK applies the retained framework.
Permission, contaminant limits, label wording and claims are four separate checks, and the file has to answer each one for the market.
Three markets, three instruments
The routes are not interchangeable, and a label that is correct in one market can fail in the next.
| Market | Main instruments | What they settle |
|---|---|---|
| European Union | Regulation (EC) No 178/2002; Directive 2002/46/EC; Regulation (EU) 2023/915; Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011; Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 | Food use, supplement labelling, contaminant limits, claims |
| United States | FD&C Act section 201(ff); 21 CFR 111; 21 CFR 101.36; 21 CFR 582.5411 | Dietary ingredient status, cGMP, Supplement Facts, GRAS food use |
| United Kingdom | Retained food law; Food Supplements (England) Regulations 2003; Food Information Regulations 2014; GB claims register | GB food use, labelling, limits, claims; Northern Ireland follows the EU |
Sourcing reference, not legal advice.
The European Union: an amino acid outside the positive lists
Annexes I and II to Directive 2002/46/EC list the vitamins and minerals permitted in food supplements and the forms in which they may be used. L-lysine is neither a vitamin nor a mineral, and the hydrochloride is not in those annexes. Permission and any level for an amino acid come from general food law and from the member state where the product is sold. Member states may set a maximum, require notification or restrict a form.
The novel food question is separate. L-lysine has a documented food history before 15 May 1997; the file should document it rather than assume it. Labelling follows Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, and L-lysine has no Nutrient Reference Value, so no percentage of an NRV can be shown. The ingredient list should name the hydrochloride, not “L-lysine” alone.
The United States: a dietary ingredient and a GRAS food substance
In the US, L-lysine is a dietary ingredient under section 201(ff) of the FD&C Act. A pre-1994 marketing history is normally the basis; the supplier's file should say which. For food use, lysine is also generally recognized as safe under 21 CFR 582.5411, which covers L- and DL-forms and does not distinguish the salt from the base.
Under 21 CFR 111 the manufacturer must test the identity of each component on receipt. The Supplement Facts panel is set by 21 CFR 101.36: it declares “L-lysine (as L-lysine hydrochloride)” and the amount is the lysine figure, not the salt figure. Lysine has no Daily Value, so no percentage is shown. A structure/function statement is possible with substantiation and the DSHEA disclaimer in 21 CFR 101.93; a disease claim is not.
The United Kingdom: retained rules, with Northern Ireland apart
The Food Supplements (England) Regulations 2003 set permitted vitamins and minerals in Schedules 1 and 2. Amino acids are not in those schedules, so L-lysine hydrochloride follows general food law in Great Britain, with the retained food information and novel food frameworks. The Food Information Regulations 2014 apply the labelling rules, and the GB claims register lists the permitted wording. Northern Ireland continues to apply the EU rules under the Windsor Framework.
Contaminants: specification against law
Three heavy-metal limits coincide with a legal maximum for food supplements. A limit at the maximum leaves nothing for analytical uncertainty.
| Parameter | Catalog limit | EU and GB position, as of this review | US position |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lead (Pb) | ≤3 mg/kg | 3.0 mg/kg maximum; the catalog sits at the line | No federal limit; Proposition 65 exposure model |
| Cadmium (Cd) | ≤1 mg/kg | 1.0 mg/kg maximum; the catalog sits at the line | No federal limit; specification limit |
| Mercury (Hg) | ≤0.1 mg/kg | 0.10 mg/kg maximum; the catalog sits at the line | No federal limit; specification limit |
| Arsenic (As) | ≤2 mg/kg | No harmonised maximum for supplements; the line is contractual | No federal limit; specification limit |
The limits apply to the finished supplement: a compliant powder can still exceed one if the daily dose is high or other ingredients add metals. In the US there is no federal lead maximum; California's Proposition 65 assesses exposure per daily dose, with a maximum allowable dose level of 0.5 µg/day for lead and a no-significant-risk level of 15 µg/day.
Claims and the label name
In the EU and the UK, health claims are governed by Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 and its retained equivalents, and a claim must appear in the register before use. As of this review the EU register carries no authorised health claim for L-lysine, and the GB register should be checked for the same wording. A compositional statement such as “L-lysine hydrochloride 500 mg per capsule” must match the specification and the certificate.
In the US the structure/function route is open with the disclaimer and rests on substantiation held by the brand owner; it does not extend to a disease, and the wording does not carry into the EU or UK register. If the drum is the hydrochloride, the EU ingredient list and the US parenthetical should say so. A label that says only “L-lysine” while the drum is the salt overstates the lysine by about 20% of the salt weight. The grades page and the hydrochloride-versus-base page work through that arithmetic.
What the file must contain
- A batch certificate that names the method and basis for each result, with the lot code matching the pack.
- The versioned specification, naming the hydrochloride, the assay basis and the mesh.
- A contaminant report with lead, cadmium, mercury and arsenic results against the limits above.
- A safety data sheet and an allergen statement for the material and the pack.
- A site and country-of-origin statement naming the actual producer.
- An EU novel food statement documenting the pre-1997 use, and a US dietary ingredient statement.
- A food-contact declaration for the pouch and liner, and a stability summary with the assigned shelf life.
- Any halal or kosher certificate the destination requires.
A short review checklist
- Name the market, and for the EU the member state of sale.
- Confirm that the specification, certificate and label name the hydrochloride.
- Check the destination's level rule and notification requirement, not only the EU position.
- Compare each contaminant limit with the legal maximum and write down the margin.
- Check the label arithmetic: salt weight, lysine weight and chloride.
- Test claim wording against the EU or GB register, or US substantiation.
- Keep specification, certificate and label on one version and lot code.
The framework for each market is on the EU regulatory page, the US page and the UK page. The release tests are on the COA page; the identity evidence is on the identity page; the product page carries the catalog specification. Annex II and heavy metals are defined in the glossary, and the site's position is set out in the editorial policy.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation