How we prove a choline bitartrate lot is the bitartrate
A choline figure alone does not prove choline bitartrate. The proof is a combination: an IR spectrum that matches the bitartrate reference, a tartrate identification test, a titration that measures choline, and an HPLC result for choline. The titration and the HPLC both measure the cation; the IR and the tartrate test identify the anion. The catalog carries IR, titration and HPLC; a supplier who reports only choline has shown the nutrient, not the salt.
The titration and HPLC measure choline; the IR and the tartrate test prove the bitartrate.
Four layers, four questions
Identity is not one test: each layer adds a different check, and an assay-only supplier has answered the narrowest one.
| Layer | Test | Question it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Document | Name, CAS 87-67-2, formula C9H19NO7 | Is the file about the right substance? |
| Spectral | IR against a choline bitartrate reference | Does the whole molecule match? |
| Titrimetric | Titration of choline, as bitartrate | How much choline is present? |
| Chromatographic | HPLC for choline | Is the peak pure, and how much? |
The titration and HPLC both measure the choline cation; they are independent methods, not independent analytes. The anion is proven by IR and, where wanted, the tartrate precipitation test: potassium chloride added to a sample solution gives a white precipitate of potassium bitartrate. A chloride lot responds to the titration and HPLC and fails the IR and tartrate test. A neutral diluent lowers both choline figures. Loss on drying, pH, particle size, metals and microbiology are consistency checks, not identity tests.
The two choline figures should agree
The titration reports choline bitartrate, using 253.25 g/mol; the HPLC reports choline directly. Convert the titration to choline (assay × 104.17/253.25) and compare it with the HPLC figure. A true lot gives about 41.1% by both routes, inside the catalog windows.
A gap is a method signal, not an anion test. Titration high relative to HPLC points to another titratable base or an endpoint problem; HPLC high relative to titration points to a co-eluting peak. A neutral diluent lowers both. A chloride substitution raises both, but the assay as bitartrate rises faster and usually breaks 100.5% before the choline window; a small spike can stay inside both, so the chloride test is the direct check.
Both results must be on the same basis. The catalog assay is as-is and the choline figure should say its basis; if one is dried, convert before comparing. The comparison is a consistency check, not proof: only the IR and tartrate test answer the anion question.
IR is the release identity
The catalog identification is IR against a reference. The spectrum should show the tartrate carboxylate and trimethylammonium bands; a choline chloride spectrum lacks the tartrate carboxylate and does not match. A blend with lactose, dextrose or another crystalline diluent shows extra bands. The certificate should name the reference material and the sample preparation, not only “conforms”.
A tartrate precipitation test is a useful chemical confirmation. Potassium chloride added to a sample solution gives a white precipitate of potassium bitartrate; a chloride salt does not. The test is qualitative but specific to the tartrate anion and cheap to run beside the IR.
Water broadens the hydroxyl region and can hide differences, so dry the sample before the scan and report how. IR is not a potency method: a spectrum can match while the assay is low, and an assay can pass while the spectrum is wrong.
The crystal check
Choline bitartrate is crystalline; an X-ray diffraction pattern is a fingerprint of that crystal. It detects a second crystalline phase and crystalline diluents such as lactose or dextrose. It does not measure choline, and it is a poor detector of an amorphous filler, which scatters broadly rather than in sharp peaks.
Peak position is the identity information; peak width is not. A milled 80 mesh lot has smaller crystallites than a 40 mesh lot, so its peaks are broader, but the positions stay the same. Extra peaks at new positions mean a different solid, not a different particle size. Ask for the reference pattern.
The substitutions that turn up
| Substitution | What the buyer sees | What catches it |
|---|---|---|
| Choline chloride | HPLC choline high; titration high, often above 100.5% as bitartrate; pH closer to neutral | Chloride test, IR, tartrate test, assay upper limit |
| Another choline salt (citrate, alpha-GPC, citicoline) | HPLC choline passes; titration may pass or fail; different IR; tartrate test negative | IR, tartrate test, HPLC profile; phosphorus where present |
| Neutral diluent (lactose, dextrose, maltodextrin, silica) | Both choline figures low; loss on drying or ash may move; extra IR bands | Assay with choline, IR, XRD, ash |
| Excess tartaric acid | Both choline figures low; pH lower; strong tartrate IR | Assay, pH, IR, tartrate test |
| Free choline | Both choline figures high; pH higher; assay may exceed 100.5% | Assay, pH, IR, tartrate test |
The first two rows are salt substitutions, caught by chloride, IR and tartrate tests. Dilution lowers both choline figures. Excess acid and free choline are process issues. A certificate that reports only choline misses all but the dilution; one that reports only the titration misses the chloride.
Writing the proof into the specification
A workable line: “Choline bitartrate, CAS 87-67-2, 96.5–100.5% as-is by titration, choline 40.5–41.5% by HPLC, IR against a choline bitartrate reference, loss on drying ≤1.0%, pH 3.0–4.5 (5%), ≥95% through 40 mesh, Pb ≤3, As ≤2, Cd ≤1 and Hg ≤0.1 mg/kg, APC ≤1,000 cfu/g, yeast and mould ≤100 cfu/g, E. coli and Salmonella absent.”
Add a chloride limit if the buyer needs to show the material is chloride-free; the catalog specification does not carry one. Add the tartrate test for a chemical confirmation of the anion. Name the titrant and endpoint, the HPLC column and detector, and the IR reference. A specification that says “choline 41%” can be met by a choline chloride blend; “assay 98%” without the salt or basis is not a grade.
The release panel is on the COA page, the grade decision on the grade page and the direct comparison on bitartrate vs chloride. The methods are described in the FTIR method note and the HPLC method note; the catalog limits sit on the choline bitartrate product page.
Five questions for a supplier
First, which reference standard or monograph released the IR, and can the comparison be shown? Second, what were the titration and HPLC choline results for this lot, and do they agree? Third, was the titration calculated on the as-is or the dried basis, and what was the loss on drying? Fourth, is there a chloride test or limit, and has a tartrate identification test been run? Fifth, who manufactured the lot, and does the lot code match pack and retained sample?
A supplier who answers all five has shown the salt; one who answers only choline has shown the nutrient. The release tests are on the COA page, the grade decision on the grade page, and the terms in the specification glossary entry.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation