Where choline bitartrate is permitted, and what the file must show
Choline bitartrate appears in supplements in the EU, US and UK, but the legal route differs. The US regulates it as a dietary ingredient under DSHEA. The EU and UK do not list choline among the harmonised vitamins and minerals, so national rules for other substances decide the route. In all three, the file has to show the named salt, the choline per portion, the contaminant results, the label and the claim basis.
The permission is for the market and the form; the certificate is for the lot; the label and the claim are separate files.
Four checks, four documents
The checks are the legal route and named form (choline bitartrate, CAS 87-67-2, not “choline”), the contaminant result against the destination limit, the label with the salt name and choline figure, and the claim with its own authorisation and evidence.
They fail independently: a lot can pass every metal limit and still be mislabelled. The file should let a reviewer reach each conclusion separately.
European Union
Directive 2002/46/EC harmonises the vitamins and minerals permitted in food supplements and their forms. Choline is not in Annex I, so it is not a harmonised vitamin or mineral form. Other substances are possible, but the EU has no harmonised positive list; the destination Member State's rules and notification requirements decide.
Contaminants sit in Regulation (EU) 2023/915: at sale a supplement must stay within 3.0 mg/kg lead, 1.0 mg/kg cadmium and 0.10 mg/kg mercury. Arsenic is not harmonised, so a Member State may apply its own figure; the catalog limit of ≤2 mg/kg is contractual, not an EU limit.
Labelling follows Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 and the Directive's supplement particulars. The ingredient list names choline bitartrate, and the label should declare choline per portion. There is no EU NRV for choline in Annex XIII, so no percentage can be calculated. Claims fall under Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 and the list in Regulation (EU) No 432/2012. The choline entries carry a condition of at least 82.5 mg of choline per 100 g, 100 mL or portion; only the authorised wording may be used.
United States
Choline bitartrate is a dietary ingredient under DSHEA. The file should state the basis — pre-1994 history, a GRAS conclusion or a new dietary ingredient notification at least 75 days before marketing — and keep the evidence.
21 CFR 101.36 sets the Supplement Facts panel. Where choline is declared, the Daily Value is 550 mg for adults and children four years and older, and the source line names the salt, for example “Choline (as choline bitartrate) 100 mg 18% DV”; that name has to match the certificate. 21 CFR 111 requires identity testing of each component, so the buyer's own receipt test is part of the file.
California's Proposition 65 sets exposure thresholds many buyers work to; a mg/kg figure alone does not answer the question, because the daily dose has to be modelled. A structure/function statement must be substantiated and carries the DSHEA disclaimer; a disease claim is not available.
United Kingdom
The Food Supplements (England) Regulations 2003 set out the permitted vitamins, minerals and forms in Schedules 1 and 2. Choline is not in those schedules, so the UK route is the other-substance route under general food law and national rules. Wales and Scotland have parallel instruments; Northern Ireland follows the EU lists under the Windsor Framework.
Great Britain retained Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006 as assimilated law rather than adopting Regulation (EU) 2023/915. The limits carried over at lead 3.0 mg/kg, cadmium 1.0 mg/kg and mercury 0.10 mg/kg, with no harmonised arsenic limit. The current text on legislation.gov.uk is the reference.
Labelling follows the Food Information Regulations 2014 and the 2003 supplement particulars, including the UK address of the operator. There is no UK NRV for choline, so no percentage applies. The GB claims register carries the choline entries with the same 82.5 mg per portion condition; a wording not on the register cannot be used.
The contaminant table
| Element | Catalog limit on the powder | EU supplement limit | UK supplement limit | US federal position |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lead (Pb) | ≤3 mg/kg | 3.0 mg/kg | 3.0 mg/kg | No federal maximum; Prop 65 may apply |
| Arsenic (As) | ≤2 mg/kg | Not harmonised; Member State rules may apply | Not harmonised; national rules may apply | No federal maximum |
| Cadmium (Cd) | ≤1 mg/kg | 1.0 mg/kg | 1.0 mg/kg | No federal maximum |
| Mercury (Hg) | ≤0.1 mg/kg | 0.10 mg/kg | 0.10 mg/kg | No federal maximum |
Material and product limits differ. The catalog column applies to the powder as shipped; the regulation applies to the supplement as sold, after dilution into doses. A powder that meets the material limit will normally meet the product limit, but the calculation has to be kept, because a high-dose single-ingredient capsule barely dilutes the powder.
The claim boundary
Permission to use the ingredient is not permission to make a claim. In the EU and UK, only authorised wording may be used, and the choline entries carry the 82.5 mg per portion condition; a product below that figure cannot use them. The claim is about choline, not the salt. In the US, a structure/function statement needs substantiation and the DSHEA disclaimer; a disease claim is not permitted.
No market in this review offers a disease-related claim for a choline supplement. The ingredient page is not claim substantiation, and a certificate does not support a claim by itself. The claim file should hold the exact wording, the register entry, the choline-per-portion calculation and the evidence.
The document pack
- Batch COA with IR, titration as-is, choline by HPLC, loss on drying, pH, particle size, metals and microbiology.
- Specification and technical data sheet naming the salt, the CAS number, the assay basis and the choline method.
- Safety data sheet with the standard sixteen sections.
- Contaminant report against the destination limits, including the arsenic decision.
- Nutrition worksheet showing choline per portion, the US % of the 550 mg Daily Value, and the absence of an EU or UK NRV.
- Claim file with the exact wording, the register entry, the 82.5 mg calculation and the substantiation.
- Allergen, GMO, irradiation and country-of-origin statements, plus the manufacturing flow.
- Novel-food status statement where required, and national notification evidence where required.
The checks before a shipment
- The certificate names choline bitartrate, CAS 87-67-2, not “choline”.
- The label ingredient line names the same salt as the certificate.
- The choline figure per portion is calculated as choline, not as the salt weight.
- The US label uses the 550 mg Daily Value; the EU and UK labels carry no NRV percentage.
- The contaminant results are compared with the product as sold, and the arsenic position is documented.
- The claim wording is on the register, the 82.5 mg condition is met, and no disease claim is present.
- The EU destination's national route and notification are checked; the UK check covers GB and Northern Ireland separately.
- The buyer holds its own identity test, and the lot code matches the certificate, pack and retained sample.
The instruments are described on the EU, US and UK regulatory pages. The release tests are on the COA page, and the catalog limits on the product page.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation