Choline bitartrate or chloride: choosing a grade
Choline bitartrate and choline chloride are two salts of the same nutrient, not two grades of one powder. The catalog bitartrate carries 40.5–41.5% choline and 96.5–100.5% salt by titration; the chloride carries about 74.6% choline at theoretical. The bitartrate is a crystalline, acidic solid at 40 mesh; the chloride is deliquescent and often handled as a solution. The dosage form and the label decide; a switch changes the weight per dose, water pick-up, assay and ingredient line.
The salt decides how much powder delivers a given choline figure, and the label has to name the salt that was used.
Choline is a nutrient name, not an ingredient name
Choline is the cation; it is supplied as a salt. Bitartrate, chloride, citrate, alpha-GPC and citicoline are different ingredients with different choline fractions and handling. A brief that says “choline 300 mg” has not chosen a raw material: the label line, the scale weight and the certificate depend on the salt.
If the label says choline bitartrate, the powder must be that salt; a chloride lot cannot be substituted. This page compares the two choices without ranking them, because the answer depends on the matrix and the label.
The two salts side by side
| Property | Choline bitartrate | Choline chloride |
|---|---|---|
| CAS · formula · molecular weight | 87-67-2 · C9H19NO7 · 253.25 | 67-48-1 · C5H14ClNO · 139.62 |
| Choline, theoretical | 41.1% | 74.6% |
| Choline, catalog | 40.5–41.5% (HPLC) | Not in this catalog |
| Salt assay | 96.5–100.5% as-is (titration) | Not in this catalog |
| Appearance | White crystalline powder | Solid or solution |
| pH (5% solution) | 3.0–4.5 | Closer to neutral |
| Water pick-up | Hygroscopic | Deliquescent |
| Typical use | Capsules, tablets, dry blends | Liquids, solutions, protected dry blends |
| Label source line | Choline (as choline bitartrate) | Choline (as choline chloride) |
One gram of bitartrate carries about 411 mg of choline; one gram of chloride about 746 mg. The catalog bitartrate window is built around 41.1%; the chloride's 74.6% is theoretical, and the supplier's grade will have its own window. Do not apply the bitartrate window to the chloride.
Water, pH and the powder in the room
Choline bitartrate is hygroscopic. The release limit for loss on drying is ≤1.0%; an open pack takes up water, cakes and falls in as-is assay even though the dry material is unchanged. Choline chloride is deliquescent: it can take up enough water to dissolve, which is why it is often supplied as a solution. Both need a sealed pack; the chloride more.
The bitartrate gives a 5% solution at pH 3.0–4.5, acidic from the hydrogen tartrate; the chloride is closer to neutral. In a blend with carbonate or bicarbonate, the bitartrate reacts and can release carbon dioxide; the chloride fits an effervescent system better, but its water pick-up remains. The acid load and taste differ by format.
Both salts are freely soluble; the bitartrate gives an acidic solution, the chloride a near-neutral one. In a liquid, the chloride's higher choline per gram means less powder, but the chloride ion and taste come with it. The bitartrate catalog grade is 40 mesh, with 80 mesh or granulation on request; finer powder cakes faster.
Matching the salt to the dosage form
Capsules and tablets. The bitartrate is the usual dry choice: crystalline 40 mesh powder, loss on drying ≤1.0%, acidic but workable. The chloride carries more choline per milligram, but a deliquescent powder is sticky on a press; if used, control humidity and seal the pack.
Sticks and drink mixes. The bitartrate dissolves freely but makes an acidic, tart drink. The chloride is closer to neutral and delivers more choline per gram, but picks up water; the foil barrier decides the label date.
Liquids. The chloride is the practical choice where the formula can carry the chloride and the taste. The bitartrate adds acidity and tartrate to a system that may not want either.
Gummies, chewables and effervescent systems. Test both in the matrix: the bitartrate lowers pH and adds tartrate; the chloride adds chloride and is hygroscopic. In an effervescent tablet the bitartrate reacts with the carbonate, so start with the chloride and handle water pick-up in the pack.
What the label must say
The ingredient line names the salt; the nutrient line names choline. “Choline (as choline bitartrate) 100 mg” means 100 mg of choline, not salt; the salt weight behind it is about 243 mg. “Choline bitartrate 500 mg” declares the salt, which carries about 206 mg of choline. Decide which figure the label uses and match the certificate.
In the United States, where choline is declared, the Supplement Facts panel uses a Daily Value of 550 mg for adults and children four years and older. In the EU and UK there is no choline NRV, so no percentage can be calculated; the label should declare choline per portion and name the salt. The EU and UK claim registers attach a minimum of 82.5 mg of choline per portion to the authorised choline claims; check the current wording, and do not use a claim because the ingredient is permitted.
The arithmetic: choline mg = salt mg × 0.411 for the bitartrate, or × 0.746 for the chloride. For the label worksheet, use the measured choline from the COA, not the theoretical fraction.
What changes when the salt changes
| Change | Bitartrate to chloride | Chloride to bitartrate |
|---|---|---|
| Weight for the same choline | ×0.55 | ×1.82 |
| Capsule or fill | Smaller fill, or a lower dose | Larger fill, or a lower dose |
| pH and taste | Less acidic, less tart | More acidic, tart |
| Water pick-up | Higher; deliquescent | Lower; still hygroscopic |
| Assay method | Bitartrate calculation does not transfer; use the chloride method | Bitartrate calculation applies |
| Label and stability file | New salt name, choline figure and pack data | New salt name, choline figure and pack data |
A switch is a formulation change, not a purchasing substitution: scale weight, capsule size, pH, water pick-up, assay method, label and stability file all change. Customer notification and a new specification are part of it.
Writing the grade into the specification
Start with the salt and the CAS number. For the bitartrate: “Choline bitartrate, CAS 87-67-2, 96.5–100.5% as-is by titration, choline 40.5–41.5% by HPLC, IR against a reference, loss on drying ≤1.0%, pH 3.0–4.5 in 5% solution, ≥95% through 40 mesh, and the catalog heavy-metal and microbiology panels.”
For the chloride: “Choline chloride, CAS 67-48-1, choline by HPLC or ion chromatography, water, pH and chloride within the agreed limits.” Do not copy the bitartrate limits across; the two salts have different assay methods, water behaviour and label names.
Add a chloride limit if the buyer needs to show the bitartrate is chloride-free; the catalog specification does not carry one. State the assay basis, the choline method and the IR reference. A specification that says “choline” without the salt is not a grade.
The catalog limits are on the choline bitartrate product page. The direct comparison is on bitartrate vs chloride, the release panel on the COA page, and the market rules on the compliance page.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation