Choline bitartrate vs chloride: choline content, hygroscopicity and the label
The two salts deliver different choline per gram: choline bitartrate is 40.5–41.5% choline in the catalog specification; choline chloride is about 74.6% at theoretical. The bitartrate is a crystalline, acidic solid; the chloride is deliquescent and often handled as a solution. A switch changes the weight per dose, water pick-up, assay method and label line, so it is a formulation change, not a purchasing substitution.
Per gram of choline, the bitartrate needs about 1.8 times the weight of the chloride, and the label has to say which salt supplied it.
Two salts, one nutrient
Choline is a cation; the salt is the counter-ion. Choline bitartrate is CAS 87-67-2, C9H19NO7, molecular weight 253.25. Choline chloride is CAS 67-48-1, C5H14ClNO, molecular weight 139.62. The catalog bitartrate is a white crystalline powder at 40 mesh, with loss on drying ≤1.0%, pH 3.0–4.5 in 5% solution, choline 40.5–41.5% by HPLC and assay 96.5–100.5% as-is by titration.
The chloride is a different specification, and this catalog does not list it. Do not apply the bitartrate's moisture, pH or choline windows to the chloride: its water behaviour is worse, its pH is closer to neutral, and its choline figure is set by the supplier's grade. The nutrient name is choline; the ingredient names are the salts. A label that says only “choline” leaves the source unresolved.
The conversion, and why the capsule changes
The theoretical fractions are arithmetic: 104.17 ÷ 253.25 = 41.1% for the bitartrate, and 104.17 ÷ 139.62 = 74.6% for the chloride. At those figures, 100 mg of choline needs about 243 mg of bitartrate or 134 mg of chloride; 500 mg needs about 1,216 mg or 670 mg. Use the measured choline from the COA for the label, not the theoretical fraction.
| Salt weight | Choline from choline bitartrate | Choline from choline chloride |
|---|---|---|
| 250 mg | ≈103 mg | ≈186 mg |
| 500 mg | ≈206 mg | ≈373 mg |
| 1,000 mg | ≈411 mg | ≈746 mg |
For the same choline, chloride to bitartrate multiplies the weight by about 1.82; bitartrate to chloride multiplies it by about 0.55. A 500 mg bitartrate capsule carries about 206 mg of choline; the same fill of chloride would carry about 373 mg, but bulk density and deliquescence differ, so fill weight is not the only change. A 250 mg bitartrate capsule carries about 103 mg; to match it with chloride takes about 138 mg.
The label makes the same point. “Choline bitartrate 500 mg” declares 500 mg of salt, about 206 mg of choline. “Choline 500 mg (as choline bitartrate)” declares 500 mg of choline, which needs about 1,216 mg of salt. Both can be true, but they are not interchangeable.
Hygroscopicity is not the same on both sides
Choline bitartrate is hygroscopic. The release limit for loss on drying is ≤1.0%; an open pack takes up water, cakes and falls in as-is assay even though the dry material is unchanged. Choline chloride is deliquescent: it can take up enough water to dissolve, which is why it is often supplied as a solution. For a dry blend, the chloride is harder to handle; for a liquid, the water is already in the formula.
The pH difference matters in the matrix. The bitartrate gives a 5% solution at pH 3.0–4.5 and reacts with carbonate or bicarbonate in an effervescent system. The chloride is closer to neutral and fits there, but its water pick-up remains. The bitartrate grade is 40 mesh, with 80 mesh or granulation on request; finer powder cakes faster. The bitartrate needs a foil barrier, the chloride a tighter barrier or a liquid pack; do not assume the same shelf life.
Which dosage form fits which salt
Capsules and tablets. The bitartrate is the dry choice: crystalline, 40 mesh, acidic but workable. The chloride is deliquescent and sticky on a press; if it is used, control the room humidity and seal the pack.
Sticks and drink mixes. The bitartrate dissolves freely but makes an acidic, tart drink. The chloride is closer to neutral and delivers more choline per gram, but picks up water; the foil barrier decides the label date.
Liquids. The chloride is the practical choice: more choline per gram, a near-neutral solution and no tartrate. The chloride ion and the taste come with it. The bitartrate adds acidity and tartrate to a system that may not want either.
Gummies, chewables and effervescent systems. Test both in the matrix. The bitartrate lowers pH and adds tartrate; the chloride adds chloride and is hygroscopic. In an effervescent tablet the bitartrate reacts with the carbonate, so start with the chloride and handle water pick-up in the pack.
The label, the claim and the market
The ingredient line names the salt, the nutrient line names choline: “Choline (as choline bitartrate)” or “Choline (as choline chloride)”. The label salt must match the certificate. In the United States, where choline is declared, the Supplement Facts panel uses a Daily Value of 550 mg for adults and children four years and older; 100 mg is 18% of that value, and the source line names the salt.
In the EU and UK there is no choline NRV, so no percentage can be calculated. The label should declare choline per portion and name the salt. The EU and UK claim registers carry choline entries with a minimum of 82.5 mg of choline per portion; check the current wording, and do not use a claim because the ingredient is permitted. The claim is about choline, not the salt.
The label arithmetic is the scale arithmetic: choline mg = salt mg × 0.411 for the bitartrate, or × 0.746 for the chloride. If the label declares both the salt weight and the choline figure, both must be true and clearly distinguished; the salt weight must not be presented as the choline amount. No market in this review offers a disease-related claim for a choline supplement.
When to choose which
Choose the bitartrate for a dry capsule or tablet, where the 40 mesh crystalline powder fits the process, the acid and tart note are acceptable, and the label must name choline bitartrate.
Choose the chloride for a liquid or syrup, where a near-neutral pH matters, the higher choline per gram reduces the dose weight, the chloride ion is acceptable and the pack controls moisture. In a dry blend, use it only with a protected pack and a label that names choline chloride.
Do not choose on the choline percentage alone: the salt changes the dose weight, water pick-up, assay method and label, and a switch needs a new specification, stability data, label and customer notification. If the formula cannot tolerate acid, choose the chloride; if the pack cannot exclude water, the bitartrate is easier but not immune; if the label must say bitartrate, only the bitartrate will do.
The catalog limits are on the choline bitartrate product page, the wider grade comparison on the grade page, the release panel on the COA page, the water behaviour on the stability page and the market rules on the compliance page.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation