02.1 10% vs pure

Beta-carotene 10% powder vs pure crystal: carrier, colour and label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Beta-Carotene

On this page
  1. The two materials side by side
  2. The carrier is most of the powder
  3. The 10:1 ratio and the assay basis
  4. Colour strength and what the matrix does
  5. What the label has to say
  6. When to choose which

A 10% cold-water-dispersible powder and a pure beta-carotene crystal are not two strengths of the same ingredient. The powder contains about 10–11 g of beta-carotene per 100 g, with the rest made up by carrier, antioxidant and moisture; the crystal is at least 96% colouring matter and does not disperse in water. The choice changes the mass on the scale, the colour in the matrix and the name on the label.

In one line

The 10% powder is a preparation and the crystal is the colouring matter: the carrier, the colour strength and the label change with the grade.

The two materials side by side

Beta-carotene 10% CWD powder against the pure crystal
Property10% CWD powderPure crystal
Beta-carotene content10.0–11.0%≥96% colouring matter
CarrierPresent and declaredNone
Water dispersionDisperses in cold waterDoes not disperse
Oil solubilityNot designed as an oil concentrateSoluble in oils and organic solvents
AppearanceOrange-red to red powderDark red to violet crystalline solid
Mass for 10 mg beta-caroteneAbout 91–100 mgAbout 10.4 mg at 96%
Label declarationPreparation with a carrierColouring matter without a carrier

The table is a specification comparison, not a ranking. The crystal is not a stronger version of the powder; it is a different physical form with a different use. The powder is not a diluted crystal; it is an engineered dispersion that makes a lipophilic pigment behave in water.

The carrier is most of the powder

In the 10% powder, roughly nine parts of the mass are carrier, antioxidant and moisture for every one part of beta-carotene. The carrier divides the carotenoid into fine particles, keeps them from clumping, lets the powder wet out in cold water and protects the pigment surface from oxygen. The antioxidant, usually a tocopherol or ascorbyl palmitate, slows the oxidation that would otherwise fade the colour.

Common carriers are modified food starch, gum arabic, gelatin and alginate. They are not interchangeable: they differ in allergen status, in whether they are acceptable to a vegetarian or halal specification, in their film-forming behaviour and in how they release the carotenoid in the mouth or the gut. A carrier change is a specification change, not a purchasing detail.

The crystal has no carrier to declare, but it also has no protection built in. It needs an oil phase, an antioxidant and an opaque pack to be stable in use. The absence of a carrier is an advantage only when the formulation already supplies those things.

The 10:1 ratio and the assay basis

The 10% figure is a ratio, not a purity grade. One hundred grams of powder contains 10–11 g of beta-carotene; one gram contains 100–110 mg; one milligram of powder contains about 0.1 mg of beta-carotene. The crystal at 96% contains 960 mg per gram. Converting between the two is a division by the carotenoid content, and the result is the mass that has to be weighed.

The comparison only works when both assays are on the same basis. The 10% figure is normally reported on the powder as supplied. The 96% figure is reported on the colouring matter, and the EU purity criterion is written on that basis. A 10% result on a dried basis and a 10% result as supplied are not the same powder when the loss on drying differs.

There is a second ratio behind the label: the amount of beta-carotene that counts as vitamin A. In the EU, 1 µg of retinol equivalent is 6 µg of all-trans beta-carotene; in the US, 1 µg RAE is 12 µg of dietary beta-carotene, or 2 µg of beta-carotene in oil from a supplement. Those factors are applied to the carotenoid mass, not to the powder mass. Using the powder weight in the conversion overstates the vitamin A by a factor of about ten.

Colour strength and what the matrix does

The 10% powder disperses in water to an orange, cloudy liquid. The cloud is the dispersed carotenoid and carrier; it is what gives a beverage or a stick pack its colour. The crystal dissolved in oil gives a clear orange solution instead. Neither is more “natural” than the other; the difference is physical.

Colour strength follows the carotenoid content. Replacing 100 mg of the 10% powder with 10.4 mg of the 96% crystal delivers the same beta-carotene, but only if the crystal is fully dissolved and the powder was fully dispersed. In practice the two are not interchangeable in a water-based matrix: the crystal will not dissolve, and the powder may not dissolve in oil.

Beta-carotene fades. Light, oxygen, heat and metal ions bleach the colour, and the rate depends on the matrix and the pack. A dye can match the initial shade but not the spectrum or the fading behaviour. Colour matching should be done in the finished matrix, under the finished pack, not on a powder sample in a dish.

What the label has to say

In the EU, beta-carotene used as a colour is the additive E160a(ii), and the ingredient list declares it in the colour class, for example “colour: beta-carotene” or “colour: E160a(ii)”. Used as a source of vitamin A, it is a nutrient, and the nutrition declaration uses retinol equivalents with the 6:1 conversion. The carrier in the 10% powder is part of the preparation and has to be declared when it remains in the finished food; the crystal brings no carrier.

In the United States, the colour additive route is 21 CFR 73.95 and the nutrient route is the GRAS affirmation at 21 CFR 184.1245. A dietary supplement declares beta-carotene in the Supplement Facts panel in mcg RAE, and may state the share of vitamin A that comes from beta-carotene; the conversion depends on the matrix. The same powder can be a colour in one product and a nutrient in another; the label follows the use, not the supplier's description.

“Beta-carotene 10%” is a specification, not a label name. The label names beta-carotene and declares the preparation's carrier if it is present. A label that says only “10% beta-carotene” has described the concentrate, not the finished product.

When to choose which

Choose the 10% CWD powder for capsules, tablets, stick packs, dry mixes and beverages where a uniform orange colour and a water dispersion are wanted. It is the practical way to deliver a small dose of a lipophilic pigment into a water-based product, and the carrier is declared. The catalog form here is the 10% powder.

Choose the pure crystal when the formulation is oil-based, when a clear oil colour is wanted, or when the carrier mass or the carrier's allergen status is unacceptable. It is not a drop-in for the powder: the dose mass falls by about a factor of ten, the dispersion step disappears, and the label loses the carrier declaration.

Switching either way needs a new specification, a new dose calculation, a colour match in the matrix, a stability check and a label review. The product hub carries the catalog specification; the grades page places this comparison in the wider range; the vitamin A page covers the nutrient conversion; the methods library describes the UV/Vis assay; the quality page covers release.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation