Magnesium malate vs citrate: magnesium content, water and the label
The malate and the citrate are both magnesium salts, but a label that switches from one to the other changes the weight of powder behind the same milligram of magnesium. Magnesium malate carries 11.3–11.8% magnesium in a hydrated powder; anhydrous magnesium citrate carries 14.5–16.4%. That is about a third more malate powder for the same dose, before the hydrate of the citrate is even named.
The same 100 mg of magnesium needs about 870 mg of malate powder but about 650 mg of anhydrous citrate, and the label has to name which salt and which hydrate were weighed.
Two salts, two magnesium figures
Magnesium malate is the magnesium salt of DL-malic acid. The catalogue formula is C₄H₁₀MgO₈, the molar mass is about 210.4 g/mol, and magnesium is about 11.6% of the molecule. The specification range is 11.3–11.8% by complexometric EDTA, measured on the powder as it is packed.
Magnesium citrate is a different salt with a different formula, C₁₂H₁₀Mg₃O₁₄, and three magnesium ions for every two citrate ions. The anhydrous salt has a molar mass of about 451 g/mol and a theoretical magnesium fraction of about 16.2%; the catalogue range is 14.5–16.4%. The nonahydrate carries about 11.9% magnesium, which is close to the malate figure.
That last number is why the comparison has to name the citrate hydrate. “Malate versus citrate” is not one comparison. Against the anhydrous salt the salt weight moves by about a third; against the nonahydrate it barely moves at all.
Water is mass, not a rounding error
The malate carries 22.0–26.5% water by Karl Fischer. The water is part of the crystal, and it is the reason the magnesium figure is 11.5% rather than the 15.5% of the anhydrous salt. The anhydrous citrate carries almost no water, with a loss on drying of ≤2.0%. The citrate nonahydrate carries about 26% water and lands near the malate on both water and magnesium.
Water is mass that is not magnesium. A powder with a quarter of its weight in water needs more powder per milligram of the metal, and a label that counts the salt weight rather than the elemental weight will overstate what the capsule delivers. The water figure and the magnesium figure have to come from the same lot and the same certificate.
There is a specification check inside this point. The hydrate name and the water range have to tell the same story. If a supplier's name and water result point to different hydrates, ask for the batch record and settle it before the specification is signed.
The arithmetic per dose
| Salt | Magnesium | Salt per 100 mg Mg | Water |
|---|---|---|---|
| Magnesium malate | 11.3–11.8% | 847–885 mg (about 870 mg) | 22.0–26.5% by Karl Fischer |
| Magnesium citrate, anhydrous | 14.5–16.4% | 610–690 mg (about 650 mg) | ≤2.0% loss on drying |
| Magnesium citrate, nonahydrate | About 11.9% | About 840 mg | About 26% |
Read the same table from the other direction. A 1,000 mg scoop of malate delivers 113–118 mg magnesium; a 1,000 mg scoop of anhydrous citrate delivers 145–164 mg. The citrate is the richer source of the metal per gram, and the malate is the bulkier one.
Capsule fill follows the arithmetic. A size 0 capsule holds roughly 350–600 mg of a powder across these densities, so a 100 mg magnesium dose from the malate is a two-capsule fill before excipients, while the anhydrous citrate may fit a single larger capsule or two smaller ones. These are calculations from the specification, not batch results.
What the label has to change
In the European Union, Annex II of Directive 2002/46/EC names the permitted magnesium source, and the ingredient list has to use that name. Magnesium malate and magnesium citrate are separate entries, and a switch from one to the other is a change to the ingredient list even if the elemental magnesium stays the same. The nutrition declaration states magnesium in milligrams and as a percentage of the 375 mg reference intake for adults.
The arithmetic is visible on the label. A 1,000 mg malate dose at 11.5% delivers about 115 mg magnesium, or about 31% of the reference intake. A 1,000 mg anhydrous citrate dose at 15.5% delivers about 155 mg, or about 41%. If the brand keeps the same salt weight and changes the salt, the elemental figure and the percentage both move. If the brand keeps the same elemental figure, the salt weight and the capsule fill move instead.
On a US label, the Supplement Facts box gives elemental magnesium against a 420 mg Daily Value for adults and children aged four and over; the ingredient list gives the salt. The same 115 mg is about 27% of the Daily Value; the 155 mg is about 37%. The hydrate name belongs in the ingredient list where the market requires it, and the certificate has to match the name that is printed.
When each salt fits
The malate fits when the label names malate, when the capsule or stick has room for the larger powder weight, and when the hydrated powder’s flow and taste have been trialled in the matrix. It also fits a suspension or a hot-process format better than a clear cold drink, because the salt is only sparingly soluble in cold water.
The anhydrous citrate fits when the magnesium per gram has to be higher, when the fill weight is the constraint, or when a clear solution is the format. The nonahydrate is a different proposition again: it carries water and magnesium close to the malate, so a supplier who quotes “citrate” without the hydrate has not quoted a comparable material.
Neither salt is a drop-in substitute for the other in a validated formula. The fill weight, the water, the taste, the label and the stability file all move together, and the certificate has to name the new salt before any of them can be signed off.
What a switch has to rewrite
- The salt and the hydrate in the specification and on the label.
- The magnesium range and the method, on an as-is basis.
- The water limit and the method: Karl Fischer for the malate, loss on drying for the anhydrous citrate.
- The mesh, the bulk density and the capsule fill weight.
- The identity tests and the reference spectra.
- The stability study, in the new pack and the new matrix.
The malate specification is on the product hub; the wider salt comparison is on the grade page; the tests that prove the malate are on the identity page; the label rules are on the compliance page. The comparison salt is on the magnesium citrate hub, and the assay method is described in the EDTA titration entry.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation