Magnesium malate or citrate: choosing a magnesium salt
Magnesium malate and magnesium citrate are both permitted magnesium sources, but they are different salts with different formula masses, different water and different weights per milligram of magnesium. The malate line here is a hydrated DL-malate at 11.3–11.8% magnesium; the citrate line is the anhydrous salt at 14.5–16.4%. The choice is settled by the dose, the dosage form and the label before it is settled by the name on the quotation.
Malate and citrate differ in magnesium per gram and in water, so the same milligram dose of magnesium needs a different weight of each salt.
Why the salt is a separate decision
The label names the salt, and the nutrition panel declares the elemental magnesium. Those are two different statements. A formulator who fixes the elemental magnesium first and chooses the salt afterwards has left the fill weight, the ingredient list and the certificate to be worked out at the end, which is the wrong order.
The salt also carries its own hydrate. Magnesium malate is supplied as a hydrated powder with 22.0–26.5% water by Karl Fischer. Magnesium citrate can be anhydrous or a nonahydrate form, and the two citrate grades carry very different magnesium figures. “Citrate” on its own is not a specification, and neither is “malate” without the hydrate.
Once the salt is fixed, the grade inside that salt is the next decision: the standard 80 mesh powder, a granulated version for flow, or a milled 100 mesh for a finer mouthfeel. The grade changes the process, not the label.
The two salts side by side
| Property | Magnesium malate | Magnesium citrate, anhydrous |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | C₄H₁₀MgO₈ | C₁₂H₁₀Mg₃O₁₄ |
| CAS | 869-06-7 | 3344-18-1 |
| Magnesium | 11.3–11.8% (complexometric EDTA) | 14.5–16.4% (complexometric EDTA) |
| Water | 22.0–26.5% (Karl Fischer) | ≤2.0% (loss on drying) |
| pH (5% suspension) | 4.0–7.0 | 5.0–8.0 |
| Particle size | ≥95% through 80 mesh | ≥95% through 40 mesh |
| Bulk density | 0.50–0.85 g/mL | 0.50–0.80 g/mL |
| Solubility in water | Sparingly soluble; soluble in hot water | Soluble |
The table is a catalogue comparison. A real lot sits somewhere inside its range, and the certificate for that lot is the only document that says where.
What the water and the powder do
The malate carries roughly a quarter of its mass as water. That water is part of the crystal, not a contaminant, but it is still mass that is not magnesium. The anhydrous citrate carries almost none, which is why a gram of citrate delivers more magnesium than a gram of malate. If the citrate is bought as the nonahydrate, the picture changes again: that grade carries about 26% water and about 11.9% magnesium, so it lands close to the malate on both counts.
Bulk density and particle size decide how the powder runs. The malate standard is 80 mesh and 0.50–0.85 g/mL; the citrate standard is 40 mesh and 0.50–0.80 g/mL. A capsule line that fills by volume will see the difference as a fill-weight change even before the magnesium figures are compared. A granulated malate flows more freely but may bring a binder that must appear on the label; a 100 mesh malate is finer and can dust more.
Solubility separates the two in the stick pack and the drink mix. The citrate dissolves readily; the malate is sparingly soluble in cold water and soluble in hot water, so a clear cold drink is an easier fit for the citrate, while a suspension or a hot-process format suits the malate. Taste is a matrix question: the malate brings a malic acid note and the citrate a citric one, and either can be masked or can dominate depending on the flavour system.
What the dosage form allows
A 100 mg magnesium dose needs about 870 mg of malate powder at 11.5%, or about 650 mg of anhydrous citrate at 15.5%. A size 0 capsule holds roughly 350–600 mg of a powder across these densities, so the malate dose is a two-capsule fill before excipients, while the citrate may fit a single larger capsule or two smaller ones. That arithmetic, not a preference, is what decides whether a one-capsule claim is possible.
In a stick pack or a drink mix, the citrate has the solubility advantage and the malate has the suspension advantage. In a gummy or a chew, the water activity and the sugar system dominate, and the malate’s own water has to be counted in the water budget. In a tablet, the 80 mesh malate and the 40 mesh citrate both compress, but the flow and the fill weight differ, and a granulated grade may be needed to keep weight variation inside the limit.
The dosage form can make one salt impractical even when both are permitted and both can declare the same elemental magnesium figure. That is a process finding, not a regulatory one.
What to write into the specification
- The salt and the hydrate: “magnesium DL-malate dihydrate” or “magnesium citrate, anhydrous”.
- The magnesium range and the method: “11.3–11.8% by complexometric EDTA” or “14.5–16.4% by complexometric EDTA”.
- The water: “22.0–26.5% by Karl Fischer” or “loss on drying ≤2.0%”.
- The identity: “malate reaction and IR conform” or “citrate reaction and IR conform”.
- The physical grade: mesh, bulk density, granulated or milled.
- The negative clauses: no added magnesium oxide, no added citrate or malic acid, no carrier unless declared.
Switching salt is a new specification, not a line edit. It brings a new certificate, a new fill weight, a new label, a new stability file and usually a new supplier file. The label arithmetic is worked through on the malate versus citrate page.
When not to switch
Do not switch if the current salt is already validated in the finished product and the label is set. Do not switch to solve a flow problem before the mesh and the bulk density have been checked: the problem may be the grade, not the salt. Do not switch on a quotation alone; the powder weight per dose, the water and the label all move together. And do not switch without a stability study on the new salt in the new pack.
If the label already names magnesium malate, the citrate is a different product, even if the elemental magnesium figure is the same. If the label names only “magnesium” and the ingredient list is still open, the comparison is worth making before the first batch rather than after.
The catalogue line for the comparison salt is on the magnesium citrate hub. The identity tests for each salt are on the malate identity page, the label rules are on the compliance page, and the malate specification itself is on the product page.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation