How we prove a magnesium citrate lot is the citrate
Identity is proved in layers, not by a single number. The magnesium comes from an EDTA titration, the citrate from a precipitation reaction and an infrared spectrum, the water from loss on drying or Karl Fischer, and the crystal form from X-ray diffraction. A magnesium figure on its own is consistent with the citrate, the oxide and the carbonate alike, which is why the layers have to agree on the same lot.
A magnesium figure cannot prove the salt; the citrate, the 3:2 ratio and the water have to agree on the same lot.
Four layers, four methods
Start with the metal. A complexometric titration with EDTA at about pH 10 measures magnesium and nothing else. It answers “how much magnesium” and leaves “on what” open, which is exactly the question the next layer has to close.
The second layer is the anion. The citrate reaction precipitates calcium citrate from a neutral solution of the salt, and the infrared spectrum is compared with a reference: the carboxylate bands near 1600 and 1400 cm⁻¹ belong to the citrate, and the broad band near 3400 cm⁻¹ belongs to water. A citrate that is present but not associated with the magnesium would still pass the reaction, so the identity result has to be read together with the assay and the ratio.
The third layer is the water. Loss on drying at 105 °C separates the anhydrous grade from the nonahydrate at a glance, because the hydrate carries about 26% water and the anhydrous salt carries less than 2%. Karl Fischer is the more direct measurement when the hydrate state is the disputed point.
The fourth layer is the crystal. X-ray diffraction shows which crystalline phases are present, and it is the layer that finds a second magnesium source sitting in the same drum. The four layers together are the identity; any one of them alone is a data point.
The 3:2 ratio
Magnesium citrate is Mg₃(C₆H₅O₇)₂: three magnesium ions for every two citrate ions, because magnesium is divalent and citrate is trivalent. The molar mass of the anhydrous salt is about 451 g/mol, of which magnesium is 72.9 g/mol, or 16.2%, and citrate is about 378 g/mol, or 84%.
That fixed ratio is the check to run first. If a certificate reports 16% magnesium, the citrate should account for roughly 83% of the mass; a lot reporting 16% magnesium and 70% citrate has about 14% of something else in the drum. If the citrate figure runs high relative to the magnesium, the likely addition is citric acid, which raises the anion without raising the metal.
The ratio also explains why a magnesium figure above 16.4% cannot be this salt. Magnesium oxide carries 60.3% magnesium and magnesium carbonate about 28.8%, so a small addition of either lifts the assay quickly. The catalogue range leaves very little headroom: less than 1% magnesium oxide would carry a lot from 16.2% to the top of the range, and about 2% carbonate would do the same. The upper limit is therefore a useful ceiling, not an arbitrary one.
What the crystal and the spectrum add
X-ray diffraction detects crystalline phases. Magnesium oxide has a distinct pattern, and a report that says “no crystalline magnesium oxide detected” is only meaningful when it also states the detection limit and the sample preparation. A diffraction pattern can also separate the anhydrous salt from a hydrate, because the two pack differently in the lattice.
Infrared spectroscopy works at the bond level rather than the lattice level. The carboxylate bands of the citrate, their separation and their shape, and the water band give a fingerprint that can be compared with a reference spectrum of a known lot. The FTIR method page and the XRD method page describe what each technique can and cannot see.
Neither technique measures purity. A sample can be phase-pure citrate and still carry a heavy-metal load, which is why the contaminant panel sits beside the identity tests rather than instead of them.
The routes worth testing
The first route is magnesium oxide, the smallest addition that lifts the magnesium figure. It is caught by the arithmetic above, by the citrate-to-magnesium ratio and by diffraction. A material that passes the assay and fails the ratio is not the salt.
The second route is magnesium carbonate, which lifts the magnesium less aggressively and brings carbonate with it. An acid test that releases carbon dioxide, a loss-on-drying figure that does not match either hydrate, and a diffraction pattern are the checks.
The third route is citric acid, added to lift the citrate signal or to dilute an over-strength lot. It lowers the magnesium figure while raising the citrate one, so the ratio moves in the opposite direction, and the powder becomes more acidic than the 5.0–8.0 pH range of the salt.
The fourth route is not an adulteration at all but a documentation failure: a nonahydrate sold against an anhydrous line. The magnesium figure will be near 11.9%, the loss on drying near 26%, and the certificate will be internally consistent — with a specification it does not meet.
How to write the specification
- “Magnesium citrate, anhydrous, 14.5–16.4% Mg by complexometric EDTA titration.”
- “Citrate identity by reaction and infrared spectrum; reference standard named on the certificate.”
- “Loss on drying ≤2.0% at 105 °C; water by Karl Fischer on request.”
- “XRD screen for crystalline magnesium oxide, detection limit stated.”
- “No added magnesium oxide, magnesium carbonate or citric acid.”
The negative statements are as important as the positive ones. A specification that sets a magnesium range and says nothing about added minerals has not excluded them, and a supplier cannot be held to a prohibition that was never written down.
Five questions for a supplier
- Which hydrate is this lot, and what is the loss on drying or the water figure?
- What is the citrate figure on the same lot as the magnesium figure, and by which method?
- Which reference did the citrate identity conform to?
- Is there an XRD report, and what detection limit does it state?
- Was any magnesium oxide, magnesium carbonate or citric acid added after the reaction?
A supplier who answers all five is describing a material you can specify. One who answers only the magnesium figure is quoting a number. Where each answer sits on the certificate is set out on the COA page; the hydrate decision is on the grade page; the catalogue line these questions test is on the product hub.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation