02.1 Chloride vs sulfate

Magnesium chloride vs magnesium sulfate: solubility, chloride and the pack

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Magnesium Chloride

On this page
  1. Two salts, two counter-ions
  2. Solubility and the solution
  3. The chloride load and the label
  4. The pack: deliquescence against a stable hydrate
  5. When to choose which
  6. What to write into the specification

Magnesium chloride hexahydrate and magnesium sulfate heptahydrate are both white, water-soluble magnesium salts, and at equal magnesium dose both bring a counter-ion load of a few hundred milligrams. The difference that matters in a plant is the chloride: it makes the salt deliquescent at ordinary humidity and aggressive to stainless steel, while the sulfate is stable in a normal pack. The two are not interchangeable on the label, in the hopper or in the warehouse.

In one line

The two salts dissolve easily, but the chloride makes magnesium chloride deliquescent, so its pack and its process contact differ from the sulfate's.

Two salts, two counter-ions

Both materials are hydrates of a magnesium salt, and both are sold as white solids. The similarity ends at the anion. Magnesium chloride hexahydrate is MgCl2·6H2O, CAS 7791-18-6; magnesium sulfate heptahydrate is MgSO4·7H2O, CAS 10034-99-8. The molar masses differ by about 43 g/mol, and the magnesium figures differ by about two percentage points.

Magnesium chloride hexahydrate against magnesium sulfate heptahydrate
PropertyMagnesium chloride hexahydrateMagnesium sulfate heptahydrate
CAS number7791-18-610034-99-8
FormulaMgCl2·6H2OMgSO4·7H2O
Molar mass203.30 g/mol246.47 g/mol
Magnesium11.96%9.86%
Counter-ion34.88% chloride38.97% sulfate
Water of crystallisation53.17%51.17%
Solubility in waterVery solubleFreely soluble
Behaviour in airDeliquescent above about 33% relative humidityNot deliquescent; can lose water in dry air

The table is a starting point, not a specification. The hydrate state has to be named either way, because the anhydrous forms carry roughly twice the magnesium per gram and behave differently in a pack.

Solubility and the solution

Both salts dissolve readily, which is why both appear in sticks, drink mixes and liquid formats. The chloride dissolves to a higher concentration at room temperature, and its solubility changes less as the water warms; the sulfate's solubility climbs more steeply with temperature. For a concentrated stock, that difference can decide whether the formula is practical without warming or a larger volume.

The chloride also gives a saltier taste at the same magnesium dose, while the sulfate is more purely bitter. Taste is a formulation problem, not a specification line, but it is the reason two products with the same magnesium figure can taste different. A switch from one salt to the other usually needs a taste panel and a masking change, not only a new certificate.

Solubility is not the same as stability. A clear solution of either salt can grow microorganisms, and a chloride solution attacks stainless steel in a way a sulfate solution does not. The stability page takes the solution questions further.

The chloride load and the label

At equal magnesium dose, both counter-ion loads are in the hundreds of milligrams. A 100 mg magnesium dose needs about 836 mg of the chloride hexahydrate, which brings about 292 mg of chloride, or about 1,014 mg of the sulfate heptahydrate, which brings about 395 mg of sulfate. The chloride load is lighter by mass, but it is a different ion with a different taste and a different effect on the equipment.

Chloride is the anion that makes a magnesium solution aggressive to stainless steel. It pits 304 parts, and 316L is more resistant but not immune at high concentration and temperature. A sulfate solution is milder on the same equipment, so a plant that switches salts has to review the contact materials, the hold times and the cleaning regime as well as the label.

The label names the salt, not only the magnesium. The EU ingredient list says magnesium chloride or magnesium sulfate, and the nutrition declaration gives the elemental magnesium. Chloride and sulfate are not separate mandatory lines in the nutrition declaration, so the counter-ion appears through the ingredient name and the taste rather than through a number. A formula that changes the anion without changing the ingredient list is mislabelled even when the magnesium figure is unchanged.

The pack: deliquescence against a stable hydrate

This is the difference that decides the warehouse. Magnesium chloride hexahydrate is deliquescent above roughly one-third relative humidity, so at ordinary ambient humidity it draws water until it forms a saturated solution on its surface. The sulfate heptahydrate is not deliquescent at ordinary humidity, and in very dry air it can lose part of its water instead. The two need different packs for the same shelf life.

The chloride needs a foil laminate with a heat seal for the 1 kg pouch and a sealed inner liner for the 25 kg drum. A clear film or a paper sack is not a barrier for this salt. The sulfate is more forgiving: a lined drum or a bag with a moderate moisture barrier is usually enough, provided the store is dry and the liner is closed. A pack study for one salt does not transfer to the other.

The test that shows the difference is weight gain. Weigh the sealed pack over the storage period as well as testing the powder: a chloride pouch that gains water is failing at the barrier, while a sulfate pack can gain or lose a little water without the powder dissolving. The MOQ page lists the standard chloride packs.

When to choose which

Choose the chloride when the magnesium figure per gram matters, when a salty taste fits the formula, or when a concentrated solution is wanted. It carries about 21% more magnesium per gram than the sulfate heptahydrate, and it dissolves to a higher concentration. Accept the deliquescence and the chloride attack as part of the choice, and specify the pack and the contact materials accordingly.

Choose the sulfate when a more forgiving pack, a milder effect on stainless steel or a bitter rather than salty taste fits the project. It carries less magnesium per gram, so the fill or the serving is larger for the same dose. Neither salt is universally better; the formula, the pack and the plant decide.

If the objection to the chloride is the chloride itself, the lactate is the other highly soluble magnesium salt in the range: it carries 8.5–9.5% magnesium, gives a neutral solution and avoids both the deliquescence and the chloride load. The magnesium lactate page sets out its specification. The citrate is the less soluble option, described on the magnesium citrate page.

What to write into the specification

  • “Magnesium chloride hexahydrate, CAS 7791-18-6, MgCl2·6H2O.”
  • “Magnesium 11.5–12.5%; water 45.0–55.0% by Karl Fischer.”
  • “Chloride reported against the theoretical 34.9%; sulfate and bromide reported where the source is brine.”
  • “Assay ≥99.0% by complexometric titration, with the basis stated.”
  • “Pack: 1 kg foil pouch or 25 kg lined drum; store sealed and dry.”
  • “No substitution of the sulfate, the lactate or the anhydrous salt without a written change control.”

The catalog line is on the magnesium chloride product page; the hydrate forms are compared on the grade page; the EDTA titration is described in the method note; the release workflow is on the quality page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation