L-Carnitine base vs tartrate: which form fits the capsule
For the same declared amount of carnitine, the base is the lightest option and the tartrate is about 47% heavier: 500 mg of carnitine is 500 mg of base or 733 mg of the 2:1 tartrate. The base is also the more hygroscopic of the two, so it demands a dry filling room and a pack that stays sealed, while the tartrate flows and tolerates a normal dose room. The choice for a capsule is therefore a trade between the fill weight the shell can take and the water control the plant can hold.
The tartrate costs about 47% more powder per gram of carnitine and returns a free-flowing, less hygroscopic fill; the base gives the smallest capsule and takes the water risk.
The mass conversion, before anything else
The label declares carnitine, the drum contains a salt, and the two figures are not the same number. The tartrate is a 2:1 salt of carnitine and tartaric acid: two carnitine units at 161.20 g/mol plus one tartaric acid at 150.09 g/mol give 472.49 g/mol, of which 322.40 g is carnitine, or 68.2%. Dividing by that fraction converts a carnitine figure into a tartrate weight.
| Carnitine declared | L-carnitine base | L-carnitine L-tartrate |
|---|---|---|
| 100 mg | 100 mg | 147 mg |
| 250 mg | 250 mg | 367 mg |
| 500 mg | 500 mg | 733 mg |
| 1,000 mg | 1,000 mg | 1,466 mg |
The conversion is stoichiometry, not a certificate result. The certificate still has to report the carnitine it measured, because a blend of carnitine and tartaric acid can be made to weigh the same as the salt without being one.
Water behaviour in the shell
The base is hygroscopic. It takes up water from the air, softens, and cakes in an open pack; in a capsule it can pull water from the shell, and the shell can become brittle or tacky as the water moves. A sticky fill also bridges in the hopper and sticks to the dosator, so the fill weight drifts while the powder on the bench still assays correctly. The tight water limit in the specification, loss on drying ≤0.5%, only holds if the pack and the room hold it too.
The tartrate is the calmer material. The counter-ion reduces the water uptake and the crystals flow, which is why a high-speed capsule line generally prefers it. The trade is mass: the same carnitine figure needs a bigger fill, and a shell that fills comfortably with 500 mg of base may not take 733 mg of tartrate, depending on the bulk density of the lot.
Acidity and what it touches
The base is a zwitterion and its solution sits close to neutral. The tartrate carries tartaric acid and its solution reads acidic. Inside a capsule the acid is mostly a question for the shell and any enteric coating; in a stick pack or a drink it is a taste decision. In a tablet it can affect the binder and the mouthfeel, and in a blend it can react with an acid-sensitive partner such as a carbonate.
Acidity is also a stability variable for anything else in the formula. If the only active is carnitine, the difference is mostly taste and compatibility. If the capsule carries a second ingredient, the tartrate's acid should be checked against it before the form is fixed.
Filling the capsule
Fill weight is set by volume and bulk density, not by the label. The catalog does not fix bulk density, so the practical route is to ask for the figure on the lot and to run a fill trial on the machine that will be used. A powder at 40 mesh flows differently from the same powder milled to 80 mesh, and a granulated grade flows differently again.
Two rules save a trial. First, size the shell for the tartrate's larger weight, not for the base's smaller one, and check that the capsule count per serving still matches the label. Second, test the base in the room where it will actually be filled: a dehumidified area changes the result, and a trial run in a dry laboratory does not predict a humid production hall.
What the label has to say
If the ingredient list says L-carnitine base, the declared quantity is carnitine. If it says L-carnitine L-tartrate, the figure is normally the salt, and a carnitine figure beside it needs its own conversion and its own basis. The same rule runs through the specification, the certificate and the panel: one name, one basis, one number.
A switch from base to tartrate is a label change, not a sourcing change. The ingredient name changes, the milligram figure may change, and the capsule count may change with it. A brand that keeps the old panel and the new powder has a mismatch that a label review will find, and the correction is more expensive after the print run.
When each form is the right one
Choose the base when the smallest possible capsule or tablet weight matters, when the label already says L-carnitine, and when the plant can hold a dry room and a sealed pack. Choose the tartrate when the line runs fast, when the room is ordinary, when the label can name the salt, and when the extra mass still fits the shell or the tablet. Choose neither by habit: the certificate does not show flow, caking or fill weight, and those are the properties that decide the run.
The forms are set out side by side on the grade page, and the water behaviour is followed through on the stability page. The release tests are on the COA page, the proof of configuration is on the identity page, and the packs and minimum are on the MOQ page. The product page carries the base specification.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation