Base, tartrate or acetyl: choosing an L-carnitine form
L-carnitine is supplied as the base, as the L-tartrate salt and as acetyl-L-carnitine, and the three are different label ingredients with different masses and different water behaviour. The base is the whole substance, the tartrate carries about 68% carnitine in a 2:1 salt, and acetyl-L-carnitine is a different molecule that carries about 79% carnitine by mass as the free base. The choice is set by the label name, the dose and the pack long before it is set by the assay.
The three forms carry different carnitine per gram, and the base's water uptake, not its assay, is what usually decides the fill.
The form is a label decision first
The carnitine cation is the same in the base and in the tartrate. What differs is the counter-ion and, with it, the mass of powder that has to be weighed for a given amount of carnitine. A product whose ingredient list says “L-carnitine” and whose powder is the tartrate has a labelling problem even when the carnitine figure matches the claim, because the label names one substance and the pack contains another.
Acetyl-L-carnitine is a further step away. It is an ester of carnitine, it is declared under its own name, and its assay is an assay of the ester rather than of carnitine. Treating the three as interchangeable because they share a parent molecule is the most common sourcing error in this category, and it is made at the label stage, not at the laboratory.
The three forms side by side
| Form | Carnitine per gram | Counter-ion | Water uptake | Solution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| L-carnitine base | 1.00 g (dry basis) | None; zwitterion | High | Near neutral |
| L-carnitine L-tartrate | 0.68 g | Tartaric acid, 2:1 | Moderate | Acidic |
| Acetyl-L-carnitine | 0.79 g as the free base; 0.67 g as the hydrochloride | None as the ester; hydrochloride common | Moderate to high | Acidic |
The 0.68 figure is stoichiometry, not a certificate result: two carnitine molecules at 161.20 g/mol plus one tartaric acid at 150.09 g/mol gives a salt of 472.49 g/mol, of which 322.40 g is carnitine. A certificate for the tartrate should still report the carnitine assay it actually measured, together with the identity of the counter-ion, because a blend of carnitine and tartaric acid can be made to weigh the same as the salt.
Water, flow and pH
The base is hygroscopic, and that single property drives most of the handling difference. It picks up water from the air, softens, and cakes in a pack that has been opened and closed without a seal. On a capsule machine the symptom is weight variation: the powder bridges in the hopper or sticks to the dosator, and the fill drifts while the assay on the bench still reads correctly. The tight loss-on-drying limit in the specification, ≤0.5%, is only achievable if the pack keeps the powder dry after the dryer.
The tartrate is the easier powder. The counter-ion reduces the water uptake, the crystals flow, and the material tolerates a dose room that the base would not. What it adds is acidity: a solution of the tartrate reads acidic, which matters in a stick pack or a drink where the taste is part of the product. Acetyl-L-carnitine sits between the two: the ester is hygroscopic, the hydrochloride is a common commercial form, and the salt name belongs on the label if the salt is what is used.
Particle size cuts across all three. The catalog powder is specified at ≥95% through 40 mesh; milling to 80 mesh is available on request for blends that need a finer, more uniform dispersion, and granulation is available where flow matters more than dissolution speed.
What the form does to the fill
Convert before you fill. A formula that declares 500 mg of carnitine needs 500 mg of the base, 733 mg of the tartrate (500 ÷ 0.682) or 631 mg of acetyl-L-carnitine free base (500 ÷ 0.793). The three weights do not fit the same capsule, and the difference is large enough to change the shell size, the number of capsules per serving or the tablet weight.
Capsules suit the base and the tartrate; the base needs a low-humidity dose room and a sealed pack, while the tartrate is more forgiving on a high-speed machine. Tablets suit the tartrate, which compacts and flows. Sticks and drink mixes suit any of the three, but the tartrate brings acidity and the base brings water uptake into a matrix that may already be hygroscopic. Liquids suit the base, which is freely soluble and close to neutral in solution, and they move the problem from water uptake to preservation and pH control.
What changes in the specification
A purchase specification is written for the named form, not for “carnitine”. For the base, the assay is carnitine on the anhydrous basis, the rotation proves the L configuration, and the water limit carries the handling risk. For the tartrate, add the counter-ion identity and a carnitine figure that is consistent with the 2:1 stoichiometry; a tartrate certificate that reports only “assay 99%” has not said 99% of what.
For acetyl-L-carnitine, the assay is for the ester, the label declares the ester, and the specification should say whether the material is the free base or the hydrochloride. The rotation still applies, because the acetyl form is chiral as well. Whichever form is bought, the certificate should name the form, the basis and the method on the same line as the number.
When not to switch
Do not switch forms to solve a fill problem without re-checking the label, the serving size and the stability of the finished pack. The tartrate is easier to run, but it changes the declared mass, the taste and the acid load of the formula; the base is the smallest weight per unit of carnitine, but it is the least forgiving in an open pack. A switch is a new specification, a new label and a new stability question, not a substitution at the weigh-out.
The release tests for each form are described on the COA page, and the water question is followed through on the stability page. The direct comparison for a capsule is on the base versus tartrate page, the proof of configuration is on the identity page, and the packs and minimum are on the MOQ page. The product page carries the base specification, and assay is defined in the glossary.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation