05 Compliance

Where L-carnitine is permitted, and what the file must show

Technical document 05 · Reviewed 2026-11-18 · L-Carnitine

On this page
  1. Three markets, three instruments
  2. The European Union
  3. The United States
  4. Contaminants: specification against law
  5. Claims and the edge of the label
  6. What the file must contain
  7. A short review checklist

L-carnitine is an established food ingredient in the European Union and a dietary ingredient in the United States, and the United Kingdom carries it under retained food law. Permission, dose and label wording are separate questions: the EU permits the substance but leaves the level to member states, the US permits it as a pre-DSHEA dietary ingredient, and the UK has kept the EU framework in Great Britain while Northern Ireland follows the EU regime. A file that answers only “is it allowed” is not yet a compliance file.

In one line

Permission is the easy part: the form, the national level rule and the label wording are what a market review actually has to settle.

Three markets, three instruments

One certificate can be sufficient in one market and incomplete in another. The table is a map, not a legal opinion: the text of each instrument and the national rule decide a specific product.

Which instrument controls what · L-carnitine
MarketMain instrumentsWhat they settle
European UnionDirective 2002/46/EC; Regulations 1169/2011, 1924/2006, 2015/2283 and 2023/915Supplement status, labelling, claims, novel food history and contaminants
United StatesFD&C Act as amended by DSHEA; 21 CFR 111 and 101.36Dietary ingredient status, cGMP, Supplement Facts panel
United KingdomFood Supplements Regulations 2003 and equivalents; retained novel food lawPermission and labelling in Great Britain; Northern Ireland follows the EU regime

In Great Britain the retained framework applies as of this review, but it is maintained by UK law, so changes can arrive on a different timetable. Northern Ireland is the exception: goods placed there follow EU rules under the Windsor Framework, so an EU-compliant file is the starting point and a GB-only file is not.

The European Union

L-carnitine has a documented history of use in food supplements before 15 May 1997 and is not treated as a novel food as of this review. That position should be documented, not assumed: if the history cannot be shown, the novel food question becomes the buyer's problem.

Directive 2002/46/EC harmonises vitamins and minerals, and carnitine is neither. It sits among the substances the Directive leaves to national rules, so a member state may set a maximum level, require notification or restrict a form. There is no EU-wide answer to “how much is allowed”; the answer is national and has to be checked for every destination before the label is printed.

Labelling follows Regulation 1169/2011 and the Directive, and the quantity per portion has to be stated. Carnitine has no Nutrient Reference Value in Annex XIII of 1169/2011, so a percentage of an NRV cannot be shown for it; a label that invents one has invented a figure.

The United States

L-carnitine was marketed as a dietary ingredient before 15 October 1994 and is not a new dietary ingredient as of this review. A different salt or a new form is a separate question, and the supplier should say which basis applies to the material being sold.

A supplement is made under the cGMP rules in 21 CFR 111 and labelled with a Supplement Facts panel under 21 CFR 101.36. Carnitine has no Daily Value, so the panel declares the amount per serving without a percentage. A structure or function statement is permitted with the DSHEA disclaimer in 21 CFR 101.93; a statement about a disease is not. A conventional food is a different filing, and a supplement dossier does not cover a beverage.

Contaminants: specification against law

The heavy-metal lines are specification terms, and some coincide with a legal maximum. Coincidence is not margin: a limit at the legal maximum leaves nothing for analytical uncertainty.

Catalog limits and the EU position for food supplements
ParameterCatalog limitEU legal position, as of this review
Lead (Pb)≤3 mg/kg3.0 mg/kg maximum under Regulation 2023/915; the catalog sits at the line
Cadmium (Cd)≤1 mg/kg1.0 mg/kg maximum for food supplements; the catalog sits at the limit
Mercury (Hg)≤0.1 mg/kg0.10 mg/kg maximum; the catalog sits at the line
Arsenic (As)≤2 mg/kgNo harmonised EU maximum for supplements; the line is contractual
MicrobiologyAPC, yeast and mould, absence testsNot a contaminants-regulation limit; process hygiene and the buyer's specification

In the US the position differs again, and California's Proposition 65 adds a warning threshold for lead and cadmium assessed per daily dose rather than per kilogram of powder. A lot can satisfy the specification and still raise a labelling question in one state.

Claims and the edge of the label

In the EU a health claim needs an authorisation under Regulation 1924/2006 and a place on the register. As of this review the register carries no authorised claim for L-carnitine, so a label that carries one needs the citation, and a paraphrase needs a lawyer rather than a copywriter.

In the US the structure or function route is open with the disclaimer, but it rests on substantiation held by the brand owner and does not extend to a disease. Compositional statements are a different category: “L-carnitine 500 mg per capsule” describes the product, not a health effect, so specification and label must agree on the figure and its basis.

This site makes no health claim for the ingredient; that decision belongs to the brand owner with the market's rules in front of them.

What the file must contain

  • A lot certificate with methods, bases and results, matching the lot code on the pack.
  • The versioned specification it was released against, naming form and mesh.
  • A safety data sheet, and an allergen statement covering the material and the pack.
  • A manufacturing site and country-of-origin statement naming the actual producer.
  • An EU novel food statement that shows the pre-1997 use, not only the conclusion.
  • A US dietary ingredient statement, or the notification for a form that is genuinely new.
  • A food-contact declaration for the pouch or liner, under the destination's framework.
  • A stability summary and the assigned shelf life for the pack, with any halal or kosher certificate the supplier holds.

A short review checklist

  • The form is named on the specification, the certificate and the label, and all three agree.
  • The destination's level rule has been checked, not assumed from the EU position.
  • The contaminant limits are compared with the legal maximum, and the margin is written down.
  • The label quantity states its basis: carnitine or the salt.
  • Any claim has a register entry in the EU, or substantiation and the disclaimer in the US.
  • The lot code runs through the certificate, the pack and the retained sample.
  • A change of form, source or site triggers a new specification and a new review.

The market instruments are summarised on the EU regulatory page, the US page and the UK page. The release tests are on the COA page, the pack is described on the stability page, and the product page carries the catalog specification. NRV and heavy metals are defined in the glossary, and the site's position is set out in the editorial policy.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation