How we prove a vitamin K2 MK-4 lot is menaquinone-4
A menaquinone-4 lot (CAS 863-61-6, C31H40O2) is identified by four agreeing lines: the document and lot chain, HPLC retention and UV spectrum against a menaquinone-4 standard, the menadione and related-substance profile, and the mass balance with loss on drying. The assay percentage is the headline; the menadione line is the one that separates a clean synthesis from a crude one, and a melting range is the simplest second check on the solid form.
A menaquinone-4 lot is proved by the chromatogram, the menadione limit, the melting range and the mass balance, not by the assay percentage alone.
The four identity layers
Naming the material correctly is not the same as proving it. The four layers below are separate questions, and each needs its own evidence. The first layer alone describes a document; it says nothing about the solid in the drum.
| Layer | Question | Evidence | What it proves |
|---|---|---|---|
| Document | Is the form and grade named? | CAS number, formula, grade, lot code | Paperwork only |
| Chromatography | Is the peak menaquinone-4? | HPLC retention, UV spectrum, reference standard | The molecule |
| Impurity | What was left from the synthesis? | Menadione and related substances | The quality of the route |
| Thermal and mass balance | Is it the crystalline solid, and do the numbers close? | Melting range or DSC; assay, loss on drying, impurities | Solid form and consistency |
Colour is not one of the layers. Yellow to orange-yellow covers a wide range, and a colour can be matched by a dye or by a different menaquinone. The stronger signals are the retention time, the UV spectrum, the menadione figure and the mass balance.
The ratios that matter: menadione, homologues and absorbance
The assay window is two-sided, 98.0–102.0%, and a result above the window is as much a question as one below it. A high result can point to a different reference standard, a different menaquinone, or a peak that the method integrated as one substance when it was two. The ratio to look at first is menadione to menaquinone-4. Menadione is the starting material in the synthetic route, so a residue is the expected impurity; report it as a percentage of the material or as a peak-area ratio, but say which, because the two numbers are not interchangeable.
The menaquinone series is the second ratio. MK-4 is the shortest of the commercial menaquinones, and on a reversed-phase column it elutes before MK-7 and the longer homologues. A standard mix separates them by side-chain length, and the relative retention against an internal standard is a useful check when a menaquinone-4 reference is not available. A line that reads “MK-4 ≥98%” and nothing else leaves the homologue profile open.
The third ratio is in the ultraviolet. The naphthoquinone chromophore gives a spectrum with several maxima, and the ratio of absorbances at two of them is a second dimension beyond retention time. The method should name the detection wavelength and report the spectrum; a retention time without a spectrum leaves half the identification unshown.
X-ray diffraction and the solid form
X-ray diffraction asks about the solid rather than the molecule: is the powder crystalline, and does the pattern match a reference? The 98% material is a crystalline powder, so a pattern is expected; a dilution on a carrier is dominated by the carrier, which is why XRD cannot confirm MK-4 in a 1% powder without a concentration step or a different method. XRD can also compare lots from two sources and catch an amorphous or a differently crystallised material.
It is not a routine release test. A melting range or a differential scanning calorimetry run is the simpler thermal check, and the isolated material's low melting range, reported around 35–38 °C, is characteristic enough to be useful. A warm sample, a mixture or a wet sample can broaden the range, so read the value with the sample history. Read a “match” statement only after seeing the reference pattern and the detection limit.
What adulteration looks like
| Route | What still passes | What catches it |
|---|---|---|
| Menadione added or left in | Assay and appearance | HPLC related substances; the menadione peak |
| Another menaquinone | A broad “vitamin K2” assay | Retention time, UV spectrum, LC-MS |
| Dilution with a carrier | A nominal grade name | Assay and mass balance; microscopy |
| Degraded or isomerised material | Total assay | Chromatogram, UV spectrum, impurity profile |
| Colourant | The yellow appearance | UV spectrum, HPLC |
Each route is built to land inside the assay window. The answer is to buy the window and its evidence as one package: assay, menadione, homologue profile, melting range and lot traceability. A supplier who can discuss all five is offering a specification; one who answers only the assay is offering a figure.
How to write the identity into the specification
- “Menaquinone-4 (MK-4), CAS 863-61-6, C31H40O2, isolated crystalline powder.”
- “Identity confirmed by HPLC retention time plus a UV spectrum against the menaquinone-4 standard.”
- “Assay 98.0–102.0% by HPLC, with the basis stated.”
- “Menadione at or below an agreed limit; related substances at or below an agreed limit.”
- “Loss on drying ≤0.5%; melting range reported; heavy metals and microbiology as listed.”
- “No other menaquinone added; grade and concentration named on the certificate.”
A negative statement carries weight only when the method could have found the substance, so name that method beside the statement. The specification should also say whether the assay is on the as-sold or the dried basis, and the menadione result should carry the method that produced it.
Five questions for the supplier
- Which menadione result belongs to this lot, and what method and limit produced it?
- Can the chromatogram and the UV spectrum come with the certificate, not just the assay number?
- What is the melting range for this lot, and how was it measured?
- What was screened for other menaquinones, at what limit, and did the panel include menadione?
- Is the material the isolated powder or a dilution, and is the carrier declared?
Those five answers together make an identity file. Each figure above has a place on the certificate, and the COA page maps it. The catalog ranges are on the product page, the concentration question on the grade page, and the homologue question on the MK-4 and MK-7 comparison. The methods library describes the separation and the quality page the release file.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation