02.1 P5P vs pyridoxine HCl

Pyridoxal 5-phosphate vs pyridoxine HCl: form, assay and label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Pyridoxal 5-Phosphate

On this page
  1. Two substances, three solids
  2. The assay basis is the difference that shows
  3. What each form is called on the label
  4. Potency per milligram and the weigh-out
  5. When to choose which
  6. What to write when you switch

Pyridoxal 5-phosphate and pyridoxine hydrochloride are different vitamin B6 sources, not two grades of one substance. P5P is the phosphorylated aldehyde, supplied as the free acid (247.14 g/mol) or the monohydrate (265.16 g/mol); pyridoxine hydrochloride is a chloride salt (205.64 g/mol) with 82.3% pyridoxine by mass. The P5P assay is by HPLC at 98.0–101.0% with water allowed up to 8.0%; the hydrochloride assay is a titration at 99.0–101.0% on the dried basis with water limited to 0.5%. The form also changes the label entry and the ingredient name.

In one line

The form decides the assay basis and the label: P5P is measured by HPLC with its hydrate water declared, the hydrochloride by titration on the dried basis, and the two sit under different entries.

Two substances, three solids

Pyridoxal 5-phosphate and pyridoxine hydrochloride compared
PropertyP5P free acidP5P monohydratePyridoxine HCl
CAS number54-47-741468-25-158-56-0
FormulaC8H10NO6PC8H10NO6P·H2OC8H11NO3·HCl
Molecular weight247.14265.16205.64
Counter-ionPhosphate esterPhosphate ester, one waterChloride, 16.9–17.6%
WaterAnhydrous6.8% theoretical≤0.5%
Vitamin B6 equivalent68.5%63.8%82.3%
Assay methodHPLCHPLCNon-aqueous titration
Assay window98.0–101.0%98.0–101.0%99.0–101.0%, dried basis

“P5P” without a hydrate is an incomplete name. The two P5P solids differ by 7.3% in mass; the hydrochloride is a third substance with a different counter-ion and label name. A certificate, a purchase order and a label that all say “vitamin B6” can still describe three materials.

The assay basis is the difference that shows

The P5P assay is a chromatographic separation, and the certificate has to state whether 98.0–101.0% is calculated on the material as weighed or on the dried solid. With water allowed up to 8.0%, the gap is large: a monohydrate lot at 99.0% on the dried solid and 6.8% water is about 92.3% as-is, while a 99.0% as-is figure is about 106.2% on the dried basis. The hydrochloride is different: its 99.0–101.0% window is on the dried basis and its water is capped at 0.5%, so the as-is figure moves by less than a point. A 99% result therefore does not mean the same thing on the two certificates.

The methods also answer different questions. HPLC separates P5P from pyridoxal, pyridoxine and pyridoxamine, so the peak area is a measure of the phosphate form. The hydrochloride assay is a titration of the base, read with the chloride line; a low chloride with a normal titration points to free base or another B6 form, not to pure hydrochloride. Neither method substitutes for the other, and a specification cannot cross between them with a new percentage.

What each form is called on the label

In the EU, Annex II of Directive 2002/46/EC lists vitamin B6 forms at 9(a) pyridoxine hydrochloride, 9(b) pyridoxine 5′-phosphate and 9(c) pyridoxal 5′-phosphate. Entry 9(b) is a different phosphate ester; P5P is 9(c). The two materials sit under different entries, so the source name has to match the form in the drum. The monohydrate is not named separately; the buyer's regulatory team confirms the hydrate and the finished product fall within the entry for the destination, against the current consolidated text.

The nutrition declaration is separate. It gives vitamin B6 in milligrams and as a percentage of the nutrient reference value, 1.4 mg in the EU and the UK and 1.7 mg as the US daily value. The vitamin B6 figure is calculated from the pyridoxine equivalent, not from the weight of the phosphate or the chloride. A product with both forms has to declare both, even though the panel shows one vitamin B6 total.

In the US, the Supplement Facts panel follows 21 CFR 101.36 and the ingredient list names the form, commonly pyridoxal 5′-phosphate for P5P and pyridoxine hydrochloride for the salt. The claim boundary does not move with the form: no disease claim is available, and a structure/function statement needs its disclaimer. The claim belongs to the finished product.

Potency per milligram and the weigh-out

A label claim is a vitamin B6 claim, so the mass of powder depends on the form. A 50 mg vitamin B6 claim needs about 73 mg of P5P free acid, 78 mg of the monohydrate, or 61 mg of pyridoxine hydrochloride. Put the other way, 100 mg of each powder declares about 68.5 mg, 63.8 mg and 82.3 mg of vitamin B6 respectively. These are label arithmetic, not a dose recommendation.

The hydrate adds a second step. To deliver 100 mg of P5P free acid, weigh 107.3 mg of the monohydrate, because 265.16 ÷ 247.14 = 1.0729. A switch from the free acid to the monohydrate at the same weigh-out reduces the P5P in the batch by 6.8% and the label claim with it. The assay percentage does not repair that error; it only describes the powder that was weighed.

An overage is set from the loss curve of the specific form in the specific matrix. A figure carried over from the hydrochloride is not evidence for P5P, or from the free acid for the monohydrate.

When to choose which

The hydrochloride is the simpler choice for a dry blend or a tablet when the artwork and the market file are already built on it. It dissolves freely, its assay is on a narrow dried basis, and its entry is 9(a). Those are file advantages, not a ranking of the two vitamin sources.

P5P fits a formula built around the phosphorylated form, and the monohydrate is the usual commercial solid. It is less soluble than the hydrochloride, its solution is acidic, and both the powder and the solution need protection from light. A liquid formula has to fix the pH in the acidic range and validate the hold; a dry blend has to account for the hydrate water in the weigh-out.

Neither form is a drop-in for the other. A switch changes the identity, the assay basis, the potency per milligram and the label entry, and it needs a written change control, a new specification and a label check before the first batch.

What to write when you switch

  • The chemical name, the hydrate form and the CAS number, written out in full.
  • The assay method and its basis: HPLC and as-is or dried for P5P; titration and dried basis for the hydrochloride.
  • The water limit and the measured loss on drying for the lot.
  • The label entry and the source name for each destination market.
  • The potency calculation from the pyridoxine moiety, with the weigh-out for the target claim.
  • The stability data for the new form in the new matrix and pack.

The P5P product hub carries the catalog specification; the vitamin B6 product page carries the hydrochloride file; the grades page covers the hydrate and mesh choice; the compliance page covers the entries and claims; the methods library describes the HPLC assay; the quality page describes the release workflow.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation