PABA vs its esters: the free acid and the cosmetic esters
Free PABA and the cosmetic esters differ at one functional group: the acid keeps its carboxylic acid, and the esters replace the acidic proton with an alkyl group. That single change moves the CAS number, the molecular weight, the water solubility, the ultraviolet maximum and the name that has to appear on a document. An ester is not a purer, finer or more soluble grade of PABA. It is another material with its own file.
An ester is a different molecule rather than a better grade, because the carboxyl group becomes an ester and the CAS number, the solubility and the label name change with it.
One acid, three esters and a naming trap
Esterification reacts the carboxyl group with an alcohol and removes the acidic proton; the amine on the ring stays where it is. The methyl ester, C8H9NO2 at 151.16, has CAS 619-45-4; the ethyl ester, C9H11NO2 at 165.19, has CAS 94-09-7. The free acid is C7H7NO2 at 137.14 and CAS 150-13-0.
The trade name “octyl PABA” is the trap. In commerce it usually means octyl dimethyl PABA, also called padimate O, CAS 21245-02-3, C17H27NO2 at 277.40. It carries two methyl groups on the amine as well as an ethylhexyl ester group, so it is not the simple octyl ester. A purchase order that says “octyl PABA” can be read two ways.
| Material | Formula | CAS number | Nitrogen |
|---|---|---|---|
| PABA free acid | C7H7NO2 | 150-13-0 | 10.21% |
| Methyl ester | C8H9NO2 | 619-45-4 | 9.27% |
| Ethyl ester | C9H11NO2 | 94-09-7 | 8.48% |
| Octyl dimethyl PABA | C17H27NO2 | 21245-02-3 | 5.05% |
The nitrogen column is a quick discriminator: each alkyl group adds mass without adding nitrogen, so the figure falls from 10.2% to 5.1% across the row. An assay result alone would not show it.
Solubility and the acid proton
The free acid dissolves to about 4.7 g/L in water at 20 °C, readily in ethanol, and much more readily in alkali, where the carboxyl group is deprotonated. The catalog records the consequence as the pH of a 1% suspension, 3.0–4.5. That acidity belongs to the acid and disappears with the proton.
An ester has no acidic proton, so a 1% suspension sits far closer to neutral, and the pH line in a free-acid specification has no meaning for it. The esters are also lipophilic: they partition into oils and alcohols and are essentially insoluble in water. A formulator who wants the material in an oil phase needs that lipophilicity; one who wants a clear aqueous concentrate needs the acid plus a base.
Handling follows the same split. The free acid dissolves in water with a base; the esters are handled in solvent or in the oil phase. A formula cannot be switched between them without rechecking the appearance and the pH.
Ultraviolet absorption and what it does not tell you
PABA absorbs strongly in the ultraviolet B region, with a maximum near 285 nm in the usual solvents, which is why it became a sunscreen active. The dimethyl ester shifts and broadens that absorption towards 310 nm, and the esters are the forms that survived in cosmetic practice. Absorption is a property of the molecule in solution; the protection a finished product gives is measured on the formula.
The cosmetic route reads the finished-product concentration, not the batch assay. Annex VI of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 caps 4-aminobenzoic acid at 5% of the cosmetic as this review reads it, and the dimethyl ester at 8%; in the United States, 21 CFR 352.10(a) lists aminobenzoic acid at up to 15% and padimate O at 1.4–8%. The buyer's regulatory team confirms the current text.
None of these figures is a supplement dose or a specification for the ingredient; they are ceilings for a different product category.
What the label has to say
A cosmetic ingredient list uses the international nomenclature name, so free PABA appears as PABA and the dimethyl ester appears as octyl dimethyl PABA or its equivalent. A supplement label works differently: it names the ingredient for the consumer, and for this material the name is para-aminobenzoic acid. The ester name on a supplement label declares a different substance, not a different grade of the same one.
The ethyl ester is also known as benzocaine, an international nonproprietary name for an anaesthetic, and that history follows the molecule into every market. The methyl ester is largely an intermediate that a finished label rarely names.
“Vitamin B10” is not a nutrient name that supports a declaration, and PABA has no nutrient reference value in the European Union or Daily Value in the United States. A label built on that phrase is building on a nickname.
Telling the acid from an ester in the laboratory
Infrared is the first screen. The free acid shows a broad carboxylic acid O–H, a carbonyl near 1,670 cm−1 and the two N–H stretches of a primary amine; the esters lose the acid O–H and move the carbonyl to a higher wavenumber near 1,710–1,720 cm−1. The fingerprint region then separates the methyl, ethyl and dimethyl esters from one another.
HPLC retention gives a second answer, provided the method is run against the relevant ester standards rather than only against a PABA standard. Nitrogen closes the case: 10.2% for the acid against 9.3%, 8.5% and 5.1% for the esters. A hydrolysis step followed by a headspace test for methanol, ethanol or ethylhexanol turns a suspicion into a specific alcohol.
The pH of a 1% suspension is the simplest check of all. A value near 3.5 supports the free acid; a value near neutral on a lot that is supposed to be the acid is a reason to stop and test rather than to adjust the formula.
Choosing, and what a switch costs
Choose the free acid for a capsule, a tablet, a powder blend or an aqueous concentrate where the label names para-aminobenzoic acid. Choose an ester only when the formula needs an oil-soluble ultraviolet filter and the cosmetic file covers that specific ester at its own ceiling. The two choices are made in different documents and reviewed by different people.
A switch in either direction is a change control: a new specification, a new analytical reference, a new label name and, for the ester, a different regulatory file. It is not a substitution at the weighing bench. The product hub carries the free-acid specification; the grade page places these materials in the range; the identity page gives the tests that separate them; the infrared method note explains the spectrum; the quality page describes the release workflow behind each lot.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation