Beta-carotene pure vs 10% CWD: assay basis, carrier and label
The pure crystal and the 10% cold-water-dispersible powder carry the same carotenoid at different concentrations and in different physical systems. The crystal is ≥97.0% by UV/Vis, has no carrier and does not disperse in water; the 10% powder is 10.0–11.0% with a declared carrier and antioxidant that make it wettable. The assay basis, the carrier and the label are what change when a formula switches.
The 10% powder is a preparation with a carrier, the pure crystal is the colouring matter: the assay basis, the mass on the scale and the label change with the grade.
The two articles side by side
| Property | Pure crystal | 10% CWD powder |
|---|---|---|
| Beta-carotene content | ≥97.0% | 10.0–11.0% |
| Carrier | None | Declared carrier plus antioxidant |
| Water dispersion | Not dispersible | Disperses in cold water |
| Oil solubility | Soluble in fats and organic solvents | Not designed as an oil concentrate |
| Appearance | Red to orange-red crystalline powder | Orange-red to red powder |
| Particle size | ≥95% through 80 mesh | ≥95% through 40 mesh |
| Mass for 10 mg beta-carotene | 10.3 mg at 97.0% | 91–100 mg |
The table is a specification comparison, not a ranking. The crystal is the colouring matter itself; the powder is an engineered dispersion that makes a fat-soluble pigment behave in water.
The assay basis: 97.0% and 10.0% mean different things
The crystal figure is close to a purity statement: 97.0% of the article is beta-carotene by UV/Vis, the balance being cis isomers, oxidation products, moisture and residual solvent. The 10% figure is a content statement: 10–11 g of beta-carotene in every 100 g of preparation, the rest deliberately added carrier and antioxidant.
The ratio between them is roughly nine to ten, not exactly ten, because the crystal assays at least 97.0% and the powder at 10.0–11.0%. A formulator who replaces 100 mg of powder with 10 mg of crystal has under-dosed by a few per cent; one who replaces it with 10.3 mg has matched the carotenoid mass.
The basis has to match too. The crystal has loss on drying ≤0.5%, so as-supplied and dried results differ by at most about half a percentage point; the 10% powder allows ≤5.0%, so its two figures can differ by several points. Comparing 10% as supplied with 97% on the dried basis mixes two denominators before any weighing.
The carrier is most of the powder
In the 10% powder, roughly nine parts of the mass are carrier, antioxidant and moisture for every one part of beta-carotene. The carrier divides the pigment into fine particles, keeps them from clumping, lets the powder wet out in cold water and shields the pigment surface from oxygen. The antioxidant, often a tocopherol or ascorbyl palmitate, slows the oxidation that would otherwise fade the colour.
Carriers are not interchangeable. Modified food starch, gum arabic, gelatin and alginate differ in allergen status, in whether they suit a vegetarian or halal specification, in film-forming behaviour and in how they release the carotenoid. A carrier change is a specification change, not a purchasing detail, and it can move the allergen statement and the label.
The crystal has no carrier to declare, but it also has no protection built in. It needs an oil phase and an antioxidant in the finished formula; the absence of a carrier is an advantage only where the formulation already supplies both. In a softgel the oil is the carrier, and the crystal dissolves into it.
Weighing, dust and dispersion
The crystal is weighed in milligrams, and a light, dusty, static-prone powder is harder to handle at that scale than a free-flowing dispersion. An 80 mesh crystal is finer than the 40 mesh powder, so it dusts more, clings to the scoop and stains the bench. Enclosed weighing, grounded equipment and a designated colour area are practical controls; the dust is a strong colorant, not a toxicity statement.
In oil the crystal goes in with heat and agitation, and the dissolution step belongs in the process instructions; in water it will not disperse, however long it is stirred. The 10% powder is the reverse: it wets out in cold water but is not an oil concentrate. Each grade has a matrix where it works; the failure elsewhere is physical before it is chemical.
Both articles fade. The crystal has no carrier film, so its surface is immediately available to oxygen; the powder has a carrier and an antioxidant, but the carrier takes up moisture and the antioxidant is consumed. Neither grade belongs in an open container on a bench.
What the label has to say
On an EU label, colour use is declared as E160a(ii) in the ingredient list, for example “colour: beta-carotene” or “colour: E160a(ii)”. Nutrient use moves the declaration into the nutrition panel, where retinol equivalents apply and the conversion is 6:1. A 10% powder also brings its carrier into the ingredient list when the carrier remains in the finished food; the crystal adds no carrier.
US rules split the same way: 21 CFR 73.95 for colour, the GRAS affirmation at 21 CFR 184.1245 for nutrient use. In a supplement, vitamin A from beta-carotene is declared in the Supplement Facts panel in mcg RAE, with an optional statement of the share of vitamin A it provides. One mcg RAE corresponds to 12 mcg of dietary beta-carotene, or 2 mcg of beta-carotene in oil from a supplement; a crystal that has not been dissolved in oil does not automatically qualify for the 2:1 figure.
“Beta-carotene 10%” and “beta-carotene pure” are specifications, not label names. The label names beta-carotene and declares the preparation's carrier when one is present; a label that says only “10% beta-carotene” has described the concentrate, not the finished product.
When to choose which
Choose the pure crystal when the formulation is oil-based, when a softgel fill or an oil blend can carry the carotenoid, or when the carrier mass and the carrier's allergen status are unacceptable. It is also the grade whose assay is closest to the colouring-matter figure in the additive specification. The catalog form here is the crystal.
Choose the 10% CWD powder for capsules, tablets, stick packs, dry mixes and beverages where a uniform orange dispersion in water is wanted and milligram-scale weighing is impractical. It is wrong for a clear oil, a softgel fill that is already oily, or a formula that cannot accept the carrier mass.
A switch in either direction is a new project: a fresh specification, dose calculation, colour match, stability check and label review. Start with the crystal specification on the pure product page, then compare it with the 10% CWD specification. The grades page sets both in the wider range; the vitamin A page explains the nutrient conversion; the methods library documents the UV/Vis assay; and release practice is on the quality page.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation