Pure urolithin A vs a pomegranate extract: dose, purity and the label
Pure urolithin A is a single substance at 98.0–102.0% by HPLC; a pomegranate extract is a mixture standardized to ellagitannins such as punicalagins, not to urolithin A. The two are not interchangeable by mass: 500 mg of extract is not 500 mg of urolithin A, and the label has to state which material is in the capsule. The choice follows the dose, the dosage form and the market file.
A pomegranate extract delivers pomegranate compounds, not a measured dose of urolithin A; the label has to say which one is in the capsule.
Two sources, two materials
Pure urolithin A is a synthetic single molecule: CAS 1143-70-0, C13H8O4, off-white to yellow powder, 40 mesh, assayed at 98.0–102.0% by HPLC. The catalog grade is this material. It has one active substance to declare, one assay to report and one impurity profile to review.
A pomegranate extract is a different object. It is made from the fruit or the peel and standardized to ellagitannins, usually punicalagins or ellagic acid. Urolithin A is a metabolite produced when ellagitannins are broken down, not a major constituent of the fruit. Unless an extract has been fermented or fortified, its urolithin A content is low or not measured, and the marker on the certificate is a punicalagin figure, not a urolithin A figure.
| Material | Standardization marker | Urolithin A content | Label unit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pure urolithin A | Urolithin A by HPLC | 98.0–102.0% | mg urolithin A |
| Pomegranate extract | Punicalagins or ellagic acid | Low or not measured; requires its own assay | mg extract and mg marker |
| Fermented or fortified extract | Urolithin A, if claimed | Stated %; requires its own method | mg extract and mg urolithin A |
The content conversion
The arithmetic is the same for both materials: mass × assay = the amount of the declared substance. A 100 mg portion of a 99% pure powder carries 99 mg of urolithin A. A 500 mg portion of a 20% urolithin A extract carries 100 mg, if the 20% is a measured urolithin A figure. The multiplication is only as good as the assay and the basis behind the percentage.
The trap is the punicalagin extract. A 500 mg portion standardized to 40% punicalagins carries 200 mg of punicalagins, not 200 mg of urolithin A. The gut microbiota converts ellagitannins into urolithins, but that conversion is not a 1:1 arithmetic step and cannot be used to declare a urolithin A amount in a supplement panel. If the label promises urolithin A, the material must be assayed for urolithin A, and the dose must be calculated from that result.
What purity means for each
For the pure grade, purity is the main peak by HPLC, backed by the related-substance profile, loss on drying, residual methanol and the metal panel. A 99% figure does not mean the absence of every impurity; it means the main peak accounts for 99% of the response the method can see. The COA page sets out the full panel.
For an extract, purity is a statement about the marker, not about the plant. A “98% extract” is a purified substance with an extract-derived impurity profile; a “40% punicalagin extract” is a mixture in which urolithin A may be absent. The grade name does not tell you which of these is in the drum. The assay method and the marker list do. The identity page explains how the tests separate the possibilities.
What the label can declare
In the EU, the ingredient list names the source. “Urolithin A” and “pomegranate extract” are different declarations, and a pomegranate extract cannot be presented as a measured amount of urolithin A. If the material is a novel food, the authorised name and conditions, where they exist, decide the wording. A carrier in a dilution belongs in the list as well.
In the US, the Supplement Facts panel declares urolithin A in milligrams, while the ingredient list names the extract or the powder and its standardization. A panel that declares urolithin A from a punicalagin-standardized extract is declaring a substance the material does not contain at that level. In both markets the test is the same: is the number in the panel the amount of the substance named in the ingredient list?
The regulatory question follows the substance
Pure urolithin A is regulated as a novel food in the EU and the UK; the application and register status has to be checked for the destination, and a pending application is not an authorisation. In the US, the basis is a GRAS notice, an NDI notification or a pre-DSHEA history for the exact material and use. The compliance page maps those routes.
A pomegranate extract may have a different history as a food, but the source does not settle the question. If the finished product claims urolithin A, the regulatory object is the substance being placed on the market and the claim on the label, not the fruit it came from. A supplier's statement that the extract is “natural” is not a permission for a urolithin A dose.
Matching the material to the brief
| If the requirement is | The material | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A precise urolithin A dose in a small capsule | Pure urolithin A | 98.0–102.0% leaves little room for a carrier |
| A pomegranate-polyphenol positioning | Pomegranate extract | The marker is punicalagin, not urolithin A |
| A urolithin A dose from a plant-derived material | Extract with a measured urolithin A figure | The assay, not the source, sets the dose |
| A single-substance regulatory file | Pure urolithin A | The substance and the specification match |
If the label promises urolithin A and the material is a punicalagin extract, the answer is to reformulate or to relabel; there is no arithmetic that closes the gap. Switching material is a revalidation: a new certificate, a new label, a new stability file and possibly a new regulatory route. The grade page places the choice in the wider range, the stability page covers the matrix, and the product hub carries the catalog specification.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation