02.1 Salt forms

SAMe salt forms: disulfate tosylate against butanedisulfonate

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · SAMe

On this page
  1. Two ways to stabilise the same molecule
  2. The salts side by side
  3. The assay basis is where the salts diverge
  4. Stability is measured per salt, not per name
  5. The label name and the market route
  6. Choosing between the two salts

SAMe disulfate tosylate and SAMe 1,4-butanedisulfonate are two salts of the same parent, and the difference is not cosmetic. The disulfate tosylate has a formula weight of 766.80 per SAMe unit and carries about 52.0% SAMe by mass; the butanedisulfonate has a formula weight of 725.80 and carries about 54.9%. A label, a dose and a certificate written for one salt do not transfer to the other without the conversion.

In one line

Both salts deliver the same SAMe, but they deliver different masses of it per gram and they carry different names onto the label.

Two ways to stabilise the same molecule

SAMe is a sulfonium zwitterion, and the free base is not a viable commercial solid: it takes up water and degrades. Salt formation gives a defined counter-ion, a reproducible formula weight and a solid that can be dried, milled and packed. The disulfate tosylate uses tosylate and sulfate; the butanedisulfonate uses 1,4-butanedisulfonate. Both leave the SAMe molecule unchanged.

The two salts have different commercial histories and are supported by separate specifications. The disulfate tosylate is the grade in this catalogue. The butanedisulfonate has been used as a medicinal substance in some markets, and it appears in supplement supply as well. Neither history makes one salt a generic substitute for the other; the identity, the mass and the market file are separate.

The salts side by side

Disulfate tosylate against butanedisulfonate
PropertyDisulfate tosylateButanedisulfonate
Salt CAS number97540-22-2101020-79-5
SAMe parentCAS 29908-03-0; C15H22N6O5S; 398.44Same parent
Formula weight per SAMe unit766.80725.80
SAMe contentAbout 52.0%About 54.9%
Counter-ionTosylate and sulfate1,4-Butanedisulfonate
Assay basis in this catalogue≥97.0% by HPLC, as the saltSeparate specification
Water and pH≤5.0%; pH 2.0–4.0 at 5%Set in its own specification
Label nameS-Adenosyl-L-methionine disulfate tosylateS-Adenosyl-L-methionine 1,4-butanedisulfonate

The table separates two materials that share a parent CAS number, 29908-03-0. The parent number identifies the SAMe molecule; it does not identify the salt. A purchase order that gives only the parent number has not specified what will be delivered.

The assay basis is where the salts diverge

Both assays are expressed as the salt, but the salts have different formula weights, so the same percentage means different amounts of SAMe. At a 97.0% assay, the disulfate tosylate delivers 0.97 × 0.5196 = 50.4% SAMe per gram of powder. The butanedisulfonate delivers 0.97 × 0.5490 = 53.3% under the same assumption. The gap is about three grams of SAMe per hundred grams of powder.

The practical consequence is a weigh-up difference. A formula that needs 400 mg of SAMe takes about 794 mg of a 97.0% disulfate tosylate powder, or about 751 mg of a 97.0% butanedisulfonate powder. Those figures are arithmetic, not a dose recommendation, and they assume the same assay; the actual certificate figure replaces 97.0% in the calculation.

The HPLC method adds its own variables. Detection is by UV; the adenine ring absorbs around 260 nm, and the certificate should state the wavelength used. The standard may be a salt or the free base. The certificate should say which standard was used and how the result was converted to the salt. A percentage without that statement cannot be compared across suppliers or across salts.

Stability is measured per salt, not per name

Both salts are hygroscopic and both are degradation-prone; the salt buys a defined solid, not immunity. Water uptake, pH and the rate of methylthioadenosine formation are properties of the actual salt and the actual pack. A stability study run on the disulfate tosylate does not cover the butanedisulfonate, and a study run on one pack does not cover another.

The disulfate tosylate is acidic in solution, pH 2.0–4.0 at 5%. The butanedisulfonate has its own pH and its own water limit, and a formulator should not assume the two behave the same in a beverage or a wet granulation. Heat, moisture and hold time are the variables to control on both sides; the response to them is measured, not inferred from the counter-ion.

The pack carries the same weight in the decision. A foil pouch and a fiber drum present different moisture barriers and different headspace, and the retest period belongs to the pack that will be opened. The stability page sets out the study design.

The label name and the market route

The label should name the salt, not only the parent. “S-Adenosyl-L-methionine disulfate tosylate” and “S-Adenosyl-L-methionine 1,4-butanedisulfonate” are different ingredient declarations, and a label that says only “SAMe” leaves the reviewer to infer which one was weighed. The declared quantity should be clear about whether it refers to the salt or to the SAMe parent.

The market route is a separate question. SAMe is regulated differently from an ordinary food ingredient in some markets, and the classification has not been uniform across countries. The buyer's regulatory team confirms the route for the destination and checks that the salt named on the label is the salt the file covers. This page does not claim an authorisation for either salt in any market.

Choosing between the two salts

Choose the disulfate tosylate when the specification, the label and the market file name it. That is the grade supplied here: ≥97.0% by HPLC as the salt, water ≤5.0%, pH 2.0–4.0 at 5%, with the heavy-metal and microbiology limits on the SAMe product page. Choose the butanedisulfonate only when its own specification and its own label are in place.

Do not switch salts to match a quotation, to chase a higher assay number, or to simplify a label conversion. A switch changes the salt CAS, the formula weight, the mass per serving, the counter-ion evidence and the regulatory citation at once. Write it as a change control with a new specification, a new certificate and a new label review.

The grades page sets this comparison beside the catalogue range; the identity page lists the counter-ion tests that identify the salt in a drum; the COA page shows where the assay basis sits. The NAD+ page is a parallel case of one parent name covering more than one sale form, the HPLC method note explains the separation, and the quality page sets out release and change control.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation