How we prove a PQQ lot is the free acid
The free acid is proved by a document that names the form, an HPLC/UV match to a PQQ reference, a sodium result that is low or not detected, and a mass balance that reconciles assay, moisture and impurities. None of those checks is sufficient alone. In particular, an assay percentage cannot tell the free acid from the disodium salt, because both contain the same quinone.
Identity is the agreement between the named form, the HPLC/UV match, a sodium figure at or near zero and a mass balance that closes.
Four separate checks
Identity is built from independent measurements, and each one answers a different question. Paperwork establishes what the supplier says the lot is; chromatography establishes the molecule; the counter-ion establishes the form; the mass balance establishes whether the numbers are consistent with an undiluted solid. An answer that stops at the first layer restates the label rather than testing the powder.
| Layer | Question | Test | What it proves |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paper | What does the supplier declare? | Name, CAS number, formula | A starting claim |
| HPLC/UV | Is the molecule PQQ? | Retention time and spectrum | The quinone, not the form |
| Sodium | Is a counter-ion present? | ICP-OES | Free acid versus salt |
| Balance | Is the solid diluted? | Assay, moisture, impurities | Arithmetic consistency |
The sodium ratio and the mass balance
The free acid has no sodium in its formula, so no sodium is expected from the molecule itself. In the disodium salt, two sodium atoms contribute 45.98 of the 374.17 g/mol formula weight, which is 12.29%. A certificate that shows about 12.3% sodium is describing the salt, not the free acid; an intermediate figure is what a blend of the two forms looks like. That is why the sodium result is a form test and not a purity test.
Mass balance is the second arithmetic check. On a dried basis the assay plus impurities should approach 100%, and the as-received assay should reflect the moisture: a solid at 99.0% dried with 0.5% moisture is 98.5% as received. A gap that is larger than the measured impurities suggests something unaccounted for, whether water, a carrier or a counter-ion.
Because sodium is outside the catalog release panel, it is ordered as an additional test. It is most useful for a new source, a disputed form, or a label that names the free acid while the certificate says only “PQQ”. Solution pH can support the picture but should not be treated as a quantitative check: concentration and residual acid move it.
X-ray diffraction and the solid form
Diffraction looks at the packing of the solid, not at the molecule in solution. A crystalline free-acid lot gives a pattern that can be compared with a reference; an amorphous diluent gives a broad halo instead. The technique can support a form claim or compare two sources, but it neither measures sodium nor replaces an assay.
A “matches reference” statement is only as useful as the reference and the detection limit behind it. Ask for the pattern, the reference material and the limit of detection. XRD is not a routine release test here; a certificate that mentions it without data has added a word, not evidence.
How a substitution shows up
| Substitution | What it does | Signal | Test |
|---|---|---|---|
| Disodium salt | Brings sodium; dissolves more readily | Sodium around 12.3% | ICP-OES, pH, solubility |
| Inert dilution | Pulls the assay below the floor | Assay low; balance gap | Assay, moisture |
| Related quinone | Similar colour, different retention | Extra peak; spectrum shift | HPLC/UV, high-resolution MS |
| Colourant | Imitates the visible colour | Visible colour, no spectral match | UV scan and HPLC |
| Water | Lowers the as-received assay | Moisture above the lot trend | Loss on drying |
Colour is easy to fake and hard to quantify. The red-orange to brown range is broad, and a dye can sit inside it. The sodium figure, the spectrum and the mass balance are the checks that are difficult to reproduce with a substitute. Appearance and assay alone would not catch the most likely substitution, because the counter-ion is what changes.
Specification lines that prove the form
- “Pyrroloquinoline quinone free acid, CAS 72909-34-3, C14H6N2O8.”
- “HPLC assay ≥98.0%, with the calculation basis stated.”
- “Loss on drying ≤1.0%, reported as a measured value.”
- “HPLC retention plus UV spectrum, with solvent and wavelength recorded.”
- “Sodium by ICP-OES reported; no counter-ion is expected.”
- “≥95% through 80 mesh, with the metal and micro panels as listed.”
- “Disodium salt and unrelated quinones below the agreed limits.”
Questions to put to the supplier
- What form does the certificate name, and which CAS number does it carry?
- Will you send the chromatogram and the UV spectrum, including the solvent and wavelength?
- What sodium figure did ICP-OES return, and which method was used?
- What is the measured moisture, and was the assay calculated as received or dried?
- If we disagree, will you re-test the retained sample jointly?
Those five answers, taken together, are an identity file; a percentage on its own is not. The product page carries the catalog figures, the COA page maps each figure to its certificate line, the grades page compares the free acid with the salt, and the disodium grades page describes the other side. The XRD method note explains the solid-state test.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation