PQQ disodium or free acid: choosing a salt form
PQQ is supplied as the disodium salt or as the free acid. The two have different CAS numbers, different molecular weights and different label names; the disodium salt carries about 12.3% sodium by mass, so a 98.0% disodium assay is roughly 86.5% free-acid equivalent. The choice changes solubility, the mass per serving and the regulatory citation, not only the word on the certificate.
The salt form is a specification decision: it changes the CAS number, the sodium content, the water solubility and the label name before it changes anything else.
Why PQQ comes in two forms
PQQ is a tricarboxylic acid. In the disodium salt, two of those acid protons are replaced by sodium ions; the free acid carries the protons instead. The disodium salt is the commercial supplement form because it dissolves more readily in water and is the form named in the main regulatory files. The free acid is the parent molecule, used as a reference standard and in systems where the sodium is not wanted.
The difference is not a coating or a dilution. It is a different chemical entity with its own CAS number, molecular weight and certificate. A purchase order that names “PQQ” without the form has not specified either one.
The two forms side by side
| Property | Disodium salt | Free acid |
|---|---|---|
| CAS number | 122628-50-6 | 72909-34-3 |
| Formula | C14H4N2Na2O8 | C14H6N2O8 |
| Molecular weight | 374.17 | 330.21 |
| Sodium content | About 12.3% by mass | None |
| Water solubility | Soluble; reddish-brown solution | Sparingly soluble |
| Typical supplement use | The commercial salt form | The parent molecule; not a drop-in |
| Label name | Pyrroloquinoline quinone disodium salt | Pyrroloquinoline quinone |
| EU novel-food entry | The authorised form | Not the form named in the entry |
The last row is the one that decides markets. The EU authorisation and the US dietary-ingredient route are written around the disodium salt, not around “PQQ” as a generic name, and the GB register has to be checked on its own terms. A free-acid certificate does not inherit that paperwork.
Solubility, solution colour and handling
The disodium salt dissolves in water and gives a reddish-brown solution. That colour is a useful visual check but not an identity test: the free acid and a diluted salt can both be reddish-brown. Solubility is not unlimited, and a concentrated stock may need pH adjustment, warming or sonication. The solution is light-sensitive, so a clear bottle on a bench is the wrong container for a hold.
The free acid is much less soluble in water. It is handled in organic solvent, as a fine suspension, or as a reference stock, and it is not interchangeable with the salt in an aqueous formula. Its solution pH is different, which changes both the appearance and the stability of the mix.
Both forms are solids that need protection from moisture, and both need protection from light. The disodium salt is specified here at loss on drying ≤5.0% and ≥95% through 40 mesh. The free acid has its own particle-size and moisture profile; a specification written for one form does not transfer to the other.
Dose arithmetic and the label
The conversion factor between the two forms is the ratio of molecular weights: 330.21 ÷ 374.17 = 0.8825. A label that declares 20 mg of PQQ as free acid needs 20 ÷ 0.8825 = 22.66 mg of the disodium salt. A label that declares 20 mg of PQQ disodium salt delivers 17.65 mg of free-acid equivalent. Neither number is a recommendation; they are the arithmetic that keeps the label and the weigh-up consistent.
The EU novel-food entry sets a maximum of 20 mg/day of PQQ disodium salt for food supplements, for adults excluding pregnant and lactating women. That is a regulatory ceiling, not a suggested intake. If a formula is built on the free acid but the market file covers the disodium salt, the label and the regulatory citation no longer match.
State the basis of the assay as well as the form. A 99.0% disodium assay on the anhydrous basis is not 99.0% of the powder as weighed, and it is not 99.0% free acid. The certificate, the specification and the label should use the same form, the same basis and the same conversion.
The dosage form follows the same logic. A capsule or tablet takes the solid salt at 40 mesh and a fill weight sized on the disodium mass. A stick pack or drink mix takes the salt because it dissolves; the free acid would leave a suspension. A capsule built on the free acid is possible, but the label, the mass and the market file all have to be rebuilt around it.
What to write into the specification
- “Pyrroloquinoline quinone disodium salt, CAS 122628-50-6, C14H4N2Na2O8.”
- “Assay 98.0–102.0% on the anhydrous basis by HPLC; loss on drying ≤5.0%.”
- “Identification by HPLC retention and UV spectrum; report the absorbance ratios.”
- “Sodium about 12.3% by ICP-OES, if the form is to be confirmed analytically.”
- “Particle size ≥95% through 40 mesh; heavy metals and microbiology as listed.”
- “Destination market and maximum use level confirmed before the order.”
We supply the disodium salt. The free acid is a different purchase with a different specification, and it should not be substituted without a written change control and a check of the destination market.
When the other form is the wrong choice
If the formula is aqueous, the disodium salt is the practical choice. If the label names the free acid, the disodium salt is not a drop-in, because the declared ingredient and the weighed ingredient would differ. If the market file covers only the disodium salt, a free-acid lot is outside that file even when the assay is higher.
The reverse is also true. A buyer who needs the free acid for a non-aqueous system should not accept the salt as “the same PQQ” and adjust the number afterwards. The form is part of the identity, not a unit conversion applied at the balance.
The product hub carries the catalog specification. The level-four comparison takes the solubility and label questions further; the COA page shows how the form is reported; the compliance page covers the market entries; the identity page gives the tests that separate the two forms.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation