01 COA & batch testing

What the COA for PQQ free acid actually contains

Technical document 01 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · PQQ Free Acid

On this page
  1. Reading the certificate line by line
  2. The assay basis and the moisture beside it
  3. The limit column and the result column
  4. What shifts from lot to lot
  5. When a third party should test
  6. Comparing two suppliers

A PQQ free-acid lot is released on an HPLC assay of at least 98.0%, a loss on drying of no more than 1.0%, an HPLC/UV identification and an 80 mesh particle size. The certificate is the document that shows those results for the pack in hand. It should also carry a sodium result, because the form named on the label is only a claim until the counter-ion is shown to be absent.

In one line

A free-acid certificate is complete only when the assay carries its basis, the moisture result sits beside it, and the sodium figure is reported at or near zero.

Reading the certificate line by line

Each line of the certificate should stand on its own: the parameter, the analytical method, the acceptance limit and the result for the lot. A report that prints “conforms” beside a method name but omits the number cannot be compared with a second supplier's report, and it cannot be audited later. The four fields are the minimum unit of evidence.

HPLC retention and UV absorbance establish the PQQ skeleton. They do not establish the salt form, because the free acid and the disodium salt share the same chromophore. A sodium determination is what turns the named form into a demonstrated one, and the catalog does not include it as a routine release test, so it has to be requested.

Release tests and the additional form check
ParameterMethodLimit or note
AppearanceVisualRed-orange to brown powder
IdentificationHPLC retention and UV spectrumConforms to the reference
AssayHPLC≥98.0%; the basis is stated
Loss on dryingGravimetric≤1.0%
Heavy metalsICP-MSPb ≤3 · As ≤2 · Cd ≤1 · Hg ≤0.1 mg/kg
MicrobiologyPlate count and absence testsAPC ≤1,000 cfu/g; yeast and mould ≤100 cfu/g; E. coli and Salmonella absent
Particle sizeSieve analysis≥95% through 80 mesh
Sodium (form check)ICP-OESReported; the free acid carries no counter-ion

The assay basis and the moisture beside it

The HPLC assay is quoted as ≥98.0%, and the figure needs a declared basis. If the laboratory reports on the material as received, moisture is already inside the number; if it reports on the dried material, the loss on drying has been removed. At a 1.0% moisture ceiling the gap is small, but a certificate that omits the basis can make a passing lot look failing: 98.0% on the dried basis at 0.9% moisture is 97.1% as received.

The moisture result is a line of its own. A lot released at 0.9% has almost no room before the 1.0% ceiling, so the storage condition and the seal become part of the release decision in practice. The certificate should print the measured value, not a statement that the limit was met.

UV identification carries conditions too. The spectrum of PQQ can shift with pH and solvent, so the certificate should say where the spectrum was obtained. A trace recorded on the sodium salt in water is not a valid comparison for the free acid dissolved in an organic solvent.

The limit column and the result column

The acceptance limit and the measured result answer different questions, so they belong in different columns. A result column that repeats the specification range has told the reader nothing about the lot. The page below is the minimum that makes a release decision possible from the certificate alone.

How each release result should be written
TestWhat the limit saysWhat the lot result looks like
HPLC assay≥98.0%, with the calculation basis namedA number, its basis and the method
Moisture≤1.0% by gravimetryA measured percentage
Metal panelA limit for each elementOne figure per element, in mg/kg
MicrobiologyCounts plus absenceThe count and the absence call for the lot
Mesh≥95% through 80 meshThe percentage that passed the sieve
SodiumNo catalog limit; report itA percentage and the method

For the metal panel, one figure per element is the only usable form; a combined total can conceal the element that is closest to its ceiling. The micro line should carry a count and a separate absence call. Sodium needs a number and a named method, because “absent” is not something a laboratory can sign. A certificate that offers only “passes specification” has left the reader to trust a conclusion instead of checking the numbers.

What shifts from lot to lot

Colour, assay and impurity profile track the fermentation and the isolation. Moisture tracks the dryer. The 80 mesh value tracks the mill and the sieve, and it can move without any change to the chemistry. A shade inside the red-orange to brown range is not, by itself, a reason to reject a lot.

Sodium is the most informative trend line on this product. If the route acidifies a sodium salt, the wash step decides how much sodium remains; a direct isolation route has a different control point but the same measurement. Small upward steps across lots deserve a process question even when each lot is inside its other limits.

Look at the direction of travel: assay falling toward 98.0%, moisture rising toward 1.0%, an extra peak in the chromatogram, or sodium creeping up. Keep the certificate lot code tied to the pack and to the retained sample, so the trend can be reconstructed.

When a third party should test

An outside laboratory is worth the time for a new source, an unfamiliar process, a first shipment to a regulated market, a disputed form, or a result that does not fit the trend. The panel should be chosen to answer the open question rather than to repeat the whole certificate.

For a free-acid lot, the minimum is HPLC with the UV spectrum, moisture, ICP-MS metals, microbiology and sodium by ICP-OES. Add XRD if the solid form is disputed and a solvent screen if the process uses one. The report should state the detection limit behind every “not detected” entry, because a method with a high limit can miss the contaminant that matters.

Retain the sample that was tested and identify the lot on the report. If a result is contested, the referee should receive the retained sample, the original certificate and the specification, and should be asked for the discriminating test, not another run of the same assay.

Comparing two suppliers

Seven fields are enough to expose a difference between two offers: form and CAS; assay and basis; HPLC/UV identity; moisture; sodium; contaminants and microbiology; pack and lot code. An apparent match on assay can hide a different form, a different basis or a different moisture ceiling.

The catalog specification sits on the PQQ free acid product page. The grades page compares the free acid with the disodium salt, and the identity page sets out the tests that separate the forms. The methods library describes the HPLC and ICP-OES work, the quality page covers release, and the disodium specification is on the PQQ salt page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation