Manganese gluconate vs manganese sulfate: elemental manganese and the fill
The two salts differ in the manganese they carry: manganese gluconate is specified at 11.5–12.5% manganese, the sulfate monohydrate at 31.5–33.0%. One milligram of manganese therefore takes about 8.1 mg of gluconate or about 3.1 mg of the monohydrate, a factor of roughly 2.6. That difference sets the fill weight, the blend and the label name before it sets anything about the powder.
The sulfate carries about 2.6 times the manganese of the gluconate per gram, so the same dose is a different fill weight, a different label name and a different water figure.
Two manganese salts, two identities
Manganese gluconate, CAS 6485-39-8, is the manganese salt of gluconic acid, C12H22MnO14, with a molar mass of about 445.2 g/mol. Manganese sulfate monohydrate, CAS 10034-96-5, is the inorganic salt MnSO4·H2O, with a molar mass of about 169.0 g/mol. Both deliver manganese in the same oxidation state; neither is a chelate. The gluconate is the larger molecule, and most of its mass is the gluconate anion rather than the metal.
| Property | Gluconate | Sulfate monohydrate |
|---|---|---|
| CAS number | 6485-39-8 | 10034-96-5 |
| Formula | C12H22MnO14 | MnSO4·H2O |
| Molar mass | About 445.2 g/mol | About 169.0 g/mol |
| Manganese | 11.5–12.5% | 31.5–33.0% |
| Salt per 1 mg manganese (theoretical) | About 8.1 mg | About 3.1 mg |
| Water | ≤1.0%, Karl Fischer | 10.0–12.0%, Karl Fischer |
| Appearance | White to pinkish powder | Pale pink powder |
| Solution | Freely soluble; neutral | Freely soluble; acidic |
| Label name | Manganese gluconate | Manganese sulfate |
The manganese figure and the dose arithmetic
The theoretical manganese content follows from the formula. For the gluconate it is 54.94 ÷ 445.2 = 12.34%; for the sulfate monohydrate it is 54.94 ÷ 169.0 = 32.50%. The catalog ranges sit around those values, and the sulfate's 10–12% water is part of the weighed powder, so its manganese figure is already expressed on the as-received basis.
At the catalog midpoints, a 2 mg manganese dose needs about 16.7 mg of gluconate or about 6.2 mg of the sulfate monohydrate. At 5 mg the masses are about 41.7 mg and 15.5 mg; at 10 mg they are about 83.3 mg and 31.0 mg. The arithmetic is not a dose recommendation; it is the step between the label figure and the weigh-up, and it has to use the lot certificate rather than the catalog midpoint.
The range matters as much as the midpoint. At 11.5% manganese the gluconate needs 8.7 mg per milligram of manganese; at 12.5% it needs 8.0 mg. Applying the assay gate narrows the usable window to about 12.1–12.5%, but even that window moves a fill by about 3%, enough to miss a capsule target set on the catalog midpoint. The sulfate's water belongs on the same certificate because it shifts the as-received manganese figure.
Solubility, solution and water
Both salts are freely soluble in water, so a drink mix or a stick pack can use either. The solutions are not equivalent. Manganese gluconate gives a neutral solution, while manganese sulfate gives an acidic one, and that difference moves the pH of the finished drink, the taste and the rate of oxidation. A formulator who switches the salt without rechecking the pH has changed the matrix, not only the ingredient.
Water on the certificate is the other difference. The gluconate is specified at no more than 1.0% by Karl Fischer; the sulfate monohydrate carries 10.0–12.0% water as part of its structure. The sulfate's water is not free moisture, but it is mass that carries no manganese, and it is the reason the sulfate's manganese figure is lower than the anhydrous salt's 36.4%. A specification that compares the two salts on a dried basis is comparing two different powders.
In solution both salts release manganese(II), and both are exposed to the same oxidation risk. Light, dissolved oxygen and heat are the variables to control in either case.
The fill weight and the blend
At a 2 mg manganese dose the salt is a small part of a normal capsule. In a 500 mg fill the gluconate is about 3.3% of the powder and the sulfate about 1.2%, so most of the capsule is carrier either way. The gluconate's larger mass is an advantage at that scale because it is easier to distribute evenly in a low-dose blend; the sulfate's smaller mass needs a more careful premix and a validated mixing time.
The arithmetic reverses for a high-dose product. A 500 mg capsule of gluconate carries about 60 mg of manganese, and the same fill of sulfate carries about 160 mg. A tablet or capsule that has to deliver a large manganese figure is therefore easier to build with the sulfate, while a low-dose product is easier to build with the gluconate. Neither salt fills a 2 mg capsule on its own; the carrier, the flow and the blend uniformity decide the formula.
Bulk density is lot-specific for both salts; the catalog fixes 40 mesh, but density still varies with the crystallisation and the mill. Ask for the measured density with the method.
What the label has to say
The label names the salt, not only the element. “Manganese gluconate” and “manganese sulfate” are different ingredients with different CAS numbers, and a Supplement Facts or ingredient list that says only “manganese” has left the source open. The elemental manganese figure is declared separately, and it comes from the lot certificate and the conversion, not from the salt name.
The market file follows the name. In the EU, the food-supplement framework lists mineral substances and the forms that may be used, and the buyer's regulatory team confirms that the named form and the current text cover the product. In the United States, the dietary ingredient is declared by its name, and the route is documented by the buyer. A switch from one salt to the other is a label change and a change-control event, not a purchasing decision.
A 100 mg portion of sulfate monohydrate carries about 32.5 mg of manganese; the same portion of gluconate carries about 12.3 mg. The two portions are not interchangeable, and the label should make clear which salt the figure refers to.
When to choose which
Choose the gluconate for a neutral solution, a low water figure and a low-dose blend where the larger salt mass helps distribution. Choose the sulfate monohydrate for a concentrated source, a high-dose product where the fill weight matters, or a process that can accept the acidic solution and the structural water. Choose neither when the label calls for a chelate; that is the manganese bisglycinate conversation.
Both salts are catalog items with the same 1 kg pouch and 25 kg drum, so the pack does not decide the choice. The manganese figure, the solution pH, the water result and the label name do. The manganese gluconate product page carries the gluconate specification; the manganese sulfate page carries the monohydrate specification; the grade page places both in the wider range; the COA page shows how the manganese and assay figures are reported; the compliance page covers the market file; the methods index describes the titration and the water test.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation