Ferrous gluconate, fumarate or bisglycinate: choosing an iron salt
Ferrous gluconate, ferrous fumarate and ferrous bisglycinate are three different iron sources, not three grades of one powder. They differ in elemental iron, molar mass, solubility, colour and the way the ferrous state behaves in a blend. The choice sets the fill weight and the ingredient name on the label before it sets anything else.
The salt chooses the mass per dose, the oxidation risk and the ingredient name on the label; the iron percentage is only the first number.
The salt is the specification
A grade is a variation on one material: a mesh, a granulation, a hydrate. A salt is a different molecule. Ferrous gluconate dihydrate carries 11.8–12.5% iron; ferrous fumarate about 33%; ferrous bisglycinate about 20–23% in the commercial grades. The label names the salt, and the elemental iron figure is the arithmetic that follows from it.
The ferrous state is common to all three, and it is not a detail. The label and the specification both name Fe(II), and an oxidised lot is a different material from the one that was ordered. Ferric pyrophosphate is not a stronger version of the same thing; it is a ferric salt with its own identity, its own assay and its own entry on an ingredient list.
The purchase order should name the salt, the hydrate and the mesh. “Iron 12%” describes an assay result, not a material, and two suppliers can meet it with different powders.
Six iron sources side by side
| Source | Iron form | Elemental Fe | In water | What it changes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ferrous gluconate dihydrate | Fe(II) salt | 11.8–12.5% | Soluble | Mass per dose; acidic solution |
| Ferrous fumarate | Fe(II) salt | About 32.9% | Practically insoluble | Much smaller mass; suspension |
| Ferrous sulfate heptahydrate | Fe(II) salt | About 20.1% | Very soluble | Acidic, hygroscopic, strong taste |
| Ferrous bisglycinate | Fe(II) chelate | About 20–23% | Soluble | Chelate identity; lower mass |
| Ferric pyrophosphate | Fe(III) salt | 24–26% | Insoluble | Ferric state; low reactivity in blends |
| Carbonyl iron | Elemental Fe | ≥97% | Insoluble | Very small mass; density and dispersion |
These are typical figures, and the supplier's certificate is the figure that counts. The ferrous sulfate row is the heptahydrate; the dried grade is about 32% and is a different specification. Carbonyl iron is elemental, not a salt, so its density and dispersion matter more than its solubility.
80 mesh is a number before it is a grade
The catalog grade is a powder with at least 95% passing an 80 mesh sieve, whose aperture is about 177 µm. The remaining 5% is a coarse tail, and a lot that sits at 95.1% is a different powder to handle from one at 99.9%, even though both pass the same line. Flow, dust and blend uniformity follow that tail more than they follow the headline.
The powder dissolves in water with gentle warming, and the solution is acidic: pH 3.0–5.0 at 5%. Solubility is why the salt suits sticks and drink mixes, and the acid pH is why it can react with alkaline components in the same blend. Granulated and 100 mesh versions are available on request; both are process variants, not different chemistry, and neither changes the iron figure.
Colour is part of the specification for a reason. Greyish-yellow to greenish-yellow is the catalog description; a darker, browner or reddish powder points to ferric iron, and the iron assay may still pass. Moisture makes it worse: the powder picks up water, cakes, and the surface layer oxidises first.
What the salt does to the fill
The label claim is elemental iron; the formula weighs the salt. At the catalog midpoint, 1 mg of iron needs about 8.3 mg of ferrous gluconate, about 4.8 mg of ferrous bisglycinate at 21%, and about 3.0 mg of ferrous fumarate.
| Iron claim | Gluconate 11.8–12.5% | Bisglycinate 20–23% | Fumarate 32.9% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14 mg | 112–119 mg | 61–70 mg | 43 mg |
| 18 mg | 144–153 mg | 78–90 mg | 55 mg |
| 20 mg | 160–169 mg | 87–100 mg | 61 mg |
A 500 mg capsule filled with gluconate delivers about 59–63 mg of iron, so a 100 mg claim needs two capsules or a larger fill; the same claim fits in about 435–500 mg of bisglycinate or about 304 mg of fumarate. Those are arithmetic, not fill-weight guarantees — the press trial and the certificate decide the final figure.
Tablets add compression to the question. The gluconate is soluble and compressible with a binder and a lubricant, and granulation is the usual route when the fine powder will not run; the granulating aid then has to be declared. In a stick or a drink mix, the salt's colour and acidity show through, so the flavour and the packaging have to carry both.
How to write the specification
- “Ferrous gluconate dihydrate, C₁₂H₂₂FeO₁₄·2H₂O, CAS 299-29-6.”
- “Iron 11.8–12.5% on the dried basis by cerimetric titration.”
- “Identification: ferrous reaction and infrared spectrum, conforms to reference.”
- “Loss on drying ≤8.0%; pH (5% solution) 3.0–5.0.”
- “≥95% through 80 mesh; granulated or 100 mesh on request.”
- “Pb ≤3 · As ≤2 · Cd ≤1 · Hg ≤0.1 mg/kg; micro as the catalog.”
- “No added ferric salt, iron oxide or diluent.”
If the salt changes, all seven lines change, and so does the label. A formulation qualified on gluconate cannot be switched to fumarate by adjusting the fill weight alone: the ingredient name, the identity test, the assay method and often the capsule size move with it.
When gluconate is the wrong salt
It is the wrong choice when the claim has to fit a small capsule and the mass will not: the 12% iron fraction is the lowest of the common ferrous salts. It is the wrong choice for a clear beverage where a yellow-brown shift would be visible, and for a matrix built on alkaline actives that will push the pH up and precipitate the ferrous ion. It is also the wrong choice when the label is required to name a chelate, because the gluconate is a salt and no wording makes it one.
In those cases the answer is another specification, not a workaround. Ferric pyrophosphate offers a ferric state and low solubility; carbonyl iron offers a very high iron fraction and a dense particle; ferrous bisglycinate offers a chelate with a lower mass per dose. The gluconate versus bisglycinate page takes the two-salt comparison further.
The catalog line is on the ferrous gluconate product page. The COA page shows the assay and moisture lines, the stability page covers oxidation in storage and in the blend, and the elemental assay note explains why the iron figure is not a purity percentage.
In this document
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation