06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove an acetyl-L-carnitine lot is the hydrochloride

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Acetyl-L-Carnitine

On this page
  1. The four identity layers
  2. The chloride and carnitine ratios
  3. What X-ray diffraction can and cannot tell you
  4. What adulteration looks like
  5. How to write the identity into the specification
  6. Five questions for the supplier

An acetyl-L-carnitine lot is the named material when four lines agree: the document names the hydrochloride and CAS 5080-50-2, HPLC and infrared show the acetyl ester, specific rotation and chiral HPLC assign the L configuration, and chloride and loss on drying close the mass balance. The assay alone cannot separate the ester from L-carnitine, the free base or a dilution.

In one line

Identity is four agreeing measurements: HPLC and IR say the ester, rotation says the L form, chloride says the hydrochloride, and water closes the mass balance.

The four identity layers

A certificate can name the right material and still fail to prove it. The four layers are separate questions, and each needs its own evidence. A supplier who answers only the first has described the paperwork, not the powder.

Four layers of acetyl-L-carnitine identity
LayerQuestionTestBlind spot
DocumentWhat is this lot supposed to be?Name, CAS number, lot code, specificationSays nothing about the powder
SubstanceIs it the acetyl ester?HPLC retention, infrared spectrum, assayCannot assign configuration or salt
ConfigurationIs it the L form?Specific rotation, chiral HPLCWeak on quantity
Counter-ion and waterIs it the hydrochloride, and is it dry?Chloride, loss on drying, mass balanceSilent on the enantiomer

The order matters. The assay is compatible with several failures on the list, so it is the last question to answer, not the first.

The chloride and carnitine ratios

The hydrochloride has one chloride per molecule. The theoretical chloride is 35.45 ÷ 239.70 = 14.79%. A result near 14.8%, with an assay inside 98.0–101.0%, is consistent with the hydrochloride. A low chloride points to the free base, a dilution or a different salt; a high chloride points to residual hydrochloric acid or another chloride salt.

The carnitine figure is the second ratio: 161.20 ÷ 239.70 = 67.25% of the salt is carnitine. The acetyl group adds 42.04 g/mol, about 17.5% of the salt's mass. If the label declares carnitine, that is the conversion factor; if it declares the ester, the assay is the number and the carnitine figure is supporting evidence.

Chloride by titration or ion chromatography is not a catalog release line, so it is an additional test. The same is true of free carnitine: hydrolysis is the route by which an acetyl-L-carnitine lot becomes partly L-carnitine, and an assay that measures total carnitine after hydrolysis cannot see it. Ask for the free carnitine figure when the method does not separate the two.

What X-ray diffraction can and cannot tell you

X-ray diffraction reads the crystal lattice. The hydrochloride is crystalline, so a pattern is a fingerprint of the solid form; it can distinguish the crystalline salt from an amorphous dilution or a different crystal form, and it can compare lots from two sources.

XRD cannot assign the L configuration. The two enantiomers are isostructural, so a physical mixture of L and D crystals gives the pattern of the L crystal. A racemic compound with both enantiomers in the unit cell can give a different pattern, so XRD may raise a flag; it cannot clear one. It is a fingerprint of the solid rather than a functional-group test: a match to an acetyl-L-carnitine reference supports the substance, but the assignment still rests on HPLC and infrared.

Use XRD for the solid-form question and keep it away from the configuration question. A supplier who offers a diffraction pattern as proof of the L form has offered the wrong evidence. Ask for the reference pattern and the detection limit before reading a “match” statement.

What adulteration looks like

Common acetyl-L-carnitine substitutions and the signals
AdulterantWhat it doesSignalTest
L-carnitine baseNo acetyl group and no chloride; lower molecular weightChloride low; free carnitine high; retention differsChloride, HPLC, rotation
D-acetylcarnitineSame assay response, opposite configurationRotation moves toward zeroPolarimetry, chiral HPLC
Propionyl-L-carnitineA different alkanoyl ester with similar chemistryRetention and mass differ from the referenceHPLC with a reference, HPLC-MS
DilutionLowers assay, chloride and carnitine per gramAssay and chloride low; loss on drying may shiftMass balance, chloride
HydrolysisFree carnitine and acetate appearFree carnitine high; solution pH movesFree carnitine by HPLC, loss on drying

Colour is the weakest signal. White to off-white covers many powders, including the free base and a dilution. The stronger signals are the rotation, the chloride figure and the chromatogram, and those are the lines to request when the form is disputed.

How to write the identity into the specification

  • “Acetyl-L-carnitine hydrochloride, CAS 5080-50-2, C9H18ClNO4, molecular weight 239.70.”
  • “Assay 98.0–101.0% by HPLC on the stated basis; loss on drying ≤1.0%.”
  • “Identification by HPLC retention and infrared spectrum; report the spectrum.”
  • “Specific rotation −28.0° to −30.0° at c=2 in water; D ester not more than the agreed limit by chiral HPLC.”
  • “Chloride about 14.79%, with an agreed range, where the salt form is to be proved.”
  • “Free carnitine not more than the agreed limit; particle size ≥95% through 80 mesh.”

Every test on the identity list should appear in the specification. A limit that exists only in a conversation does not survive a supplier change.

Five questions for the supplier

  1. Is the lot the hydrochloride or the free base, and which CAS number is on the certificate?
  2. What is the specific rotation, with solvent, concentration, temperature and path length?
  3. What is the chloride result, and which method produced it?
  4. What is the free carnitine result, and does the assay measure the intact ester?
  5. Can you provide the HPLC chromatogram, the infrared spectrum and the XRD reference?

Five direct answers make an identity file. A single assay percentage does not. The product page carries the catalog specification; the COA page shows where each figure sits on the certificate; the grades page compares the hydrochloride and the free base; the level-four page covers the label consequences. The parent form is on the L-carnitine page, the separation is explained under methods, and the release workflow is on the quality page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation