06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a vitamin K1 lot is phytonadione

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Vitamin K1

On this page
  1. The four identity layers
  2. The ratio that proves the material
  3. Why X-ray diffraction has no role here
  4. What adulteration looks like
  5. How to write identity into the specification
  6. Five questions for the supplier

A vitamin K1 lot is phytonadione when four measurements agree: the document names the form and the CAS number, HPLC retention and the UV spectrum match a phytonadione reference, the refractive index sits inside 1.525–1.528, and the trans share of the isomer figure is the one the specification states. The assay alone cannot separate the vitamin from a vegetable-oil blend or from a cis-rich synthetic lot.

In one line

Three agreeing figures identify this oil: HPLC retention with the UV spectrum, a refractive index inside 1.525–1.528, and the trans share of the phytonadione.

The four identity layers

Naming the right material on paper is not the same as demonstrating it in the bottle. The four layers below answer four separate questions, and each one needs its own evidence. A supplier who stops at the first has shown the label, not the oil.

Four layers of vitamin K1 identity
LayerQuestionTestWhat it shows
DocumentIs the form named?Name, CAS number and formulaOnly that the paperwork agrees
ChromatographyIs the quinone phylloquinone?HPLC retention plus the UV/DAD spectrumThe molecule itself
PhysicalIs the oil undiluted?Refractive index at a stated temperatureWhether a triglyceride has been added
IsomerWhich geometry was bought?trans and cis by HPLCThat the specified isomer is present

The ratio that proves the material

Vitamin K1 has no counter-ion, so there is no sodium-style check to fall back on. The equivalent evidence is the ratio between the trans and cis isomers, supported by the refractive index. The double bond at C2′–C3′ of the phytyl chain can take either geometry; the natural form is trans, the synthesis produces both, and the purification decides how much cis survives. A cis-rich lot has the same UV spectrum, a retention time close to the trans peak and an assay inside the window, so the isomer ratio is the figure that shows which geometry is in the bottle.

The refractive index works as a second ratio. A triglyceride carrier oil sits near 1.47, so a blend moves the measured value below 1.525 in proportion to the diluent. A value of 1.523 is not a rounding error; it is a signal that the bottle is not neat oil. Measure at a stated temperature, because the value drifts with the prism.

The mass balance closes the picture: assay plus related substances plus water should account for the whole sample, and an unexplained gap points at an unmeasured component. Ask for the peak list, not only the main peak, because the small peaks are where the history of the lot is written.

Why X-ray diffraction has no role here

X-ray diffraction needs a lattice to scatter from. Phytonadione is a liquid at room temperature, so there is no pattern to collect and no reference pattern to compare against. A certificate that reports “XRD conforms” for a vitamin K1 oil has added nothing to the file.

The technique does have a place one step away. On a carrier powder, diffraction describes the carrier: it separates a crystalline carrier from an amorphous matrix, and it says nothing about the vitamin dispersed in it. On a crystalline menaquinone it is a genuine solid-form test. For this oil the solid-state question does not exist, and an identity plan that relies on XRD has misread the material.

What adulteration looks like

Common vitamin K1 substitutions and the signals
AdulterantWhat it doesSignalTest
Vegetable-oil diluentCuts the vitamin per gram while keeping the colourRefractive index below the window; assay low; fatty acids presentRefractive index, assay, GC fatty-acid profile
Cis-rich synthetic lotSame UV and colour; wrong geometrytrans share below the agreed figureHPLC peak list
Menadione substitutionA different naphthoquinone with no phytyl chainDifferent retention; different UV fine structureHPLC/UV, mass spectrometry
Menaquinone substitutionA K2 molecule with a longer chainDifferent retention and molecular weightHPLC/UV, mass spectrometry
Water or hazePoor closure or condensationHaze in the oil; water figure elevatedAppearance, Karl Fischer

Colour is the weakest signal. A yellow to amber oil is easy to imitate, and the appearance window is wide enough to hide a blend. The stronger signals are the refractive index, the isomer ratio and the fatty-acid profile. A certificate that stops at appearance and assay has not tested the substitution most likely to occur.

How to write identity into the specification

  • “Vitamin K1 (phytonadione, phylloquinone), CAS 84-80-0, C31H46O2.”
  • “Assay 97.0–103.0% by HPLC, on the oil as received.”
  • “Identification by HPLC retention plus the UV spectrum against a phytonadione standard; chromatogram on request.”
  • “Refractive index 1.525–1.528, with the temperature of the measurement stated.”
  • “trans-isomer share stated; cis-isomer limit agreed; both reported per lot.”
  • “No triglyceride diluent; fatty-acid profile on request.”
  • “Destination market and form confirmed before the order.”

Five questions for the supplier

  1. What form is this lot, and what CAS number is printed on the certificate?
  2. Will you send the chromatogram and the UV spectrum, rather than the assay figure alone?
  3. What is the trans share, and what limit applies to the cis isomer?
  4. What refractive index was measured, and at which temperature?
  5. In a dispute, would you test the retained sample jointly with us?

Five straight answers add up to an identity file. One assay figure never will. The product hub carries the catalog specification; the COA page shows where each figure sits on the certificate; the grades page compares the oil with the carrier and blended grades; the level-four comparison covers the K2 alternative; the methods library explains the separations behind these figures.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation