02.1 D2 vs D3

Vitamin D2 vs D3: two molecules, two labels

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Vitamin D2

On this page
  1. Two molecules, two starting materials
  2. The IU arithmetic is shared
  3. What the label has to name
  4. The assay has to match the molecule
  5. Stability follows the form and the pack
  6. What changes when the form changes

Vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol) and vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) are different molecules: C28H44O at 396.65 g/mol against C27H44O at 384.64 g/mol, with different melting ranges and different starting materials. They share the labelling convention of 40 IU per microgram, not a label name. A formula switch changes the specification, the certificate, the label and the source statement.

In one line

The IU figure is shared at 40 per microgram, but the molecule, the analytical standard, the label name and the source statement are not interchangeable.

Two molecules, two starting materials

Ergocalciferol and cholecalciferol side by side
PropertyVitamin D2Vitamin D3
NameErgocalciferolCholecalciferol
Formula and massC28H44O · 396.65 g/molC27H44O · 384.64 g/mol
CAS number50-14-667-97-0
Usual starting materialErgosterol from yeast or fungi, opened by UV7-Dehydrocholesterol from lanolin, or lichen, opened by UV
Melting range115–118 °C84.5–87 °C
Ultraviolet maximumAbout 265 nmAbout 265 nm

The structural difference is in the side chain. Ergocalciferol carries a double bond between C22 and C23 and a methyl group at C24; cholecalciferol has neither. That is enough to change the molecular mass by 12.01 g/mol and the melting range by about 30 °C, and it is enough to make the two separate specification items.

The starting material is a commercial and a labelling fact, not an identity test. Ergocalciferol comes from ergosterol, usually from yeast, which is why the D2 route is generally accepted as vegan. Cholecalciferol from lanolin is not vegan; the lichen route is the vegan D3 option. The source belongs in the file because a change of source can change the carrier and the impurity profile.

The IU arithmetic is shared

Labelling assigns 40 IU to a microgram of ergocalciferol and the same 40 IU to a microgram of cholecalciferol, so the unit says nothing about which molecule is present. Ten micrograms is 400 IU, 25 µg is 1,000 IU and 100 µg is 4,000 IU, whether the carrier is D2 or D3. The conversion is an arithmetic convention, not a statement that the two molecules behave identically in every respect.

A potency figure therefore needs its form beside it. The same 40 IU per microgram applies to both, so a 25 µg capsule of either form declares 1,000 IU. Changing the form replaces the ingredient; it is not a dose rescale. Questions about the comparative effect of the two forms belong to the clinical file, not to this page.

The mass per IU is the same: 1,000 IU is 25 µg of either form. A premix can use the same arithmetic, but the assay standard, the retention time and the label name still change.

What the label has to name

How each market declares vitamin D and its form
MarketQuantity and reference valueForm in the ingredient list
EUMicrograms per portion and % of the 5 µg (200 IU) reference valueErgocalciferol or cholecalciferol, as used
USMicrograms against a 20 µg (800 IU) Daily Value; IU may be added in parentheses“Vitamin D (as ergocalciferol)”
UKMicrograms and % of the 5 µg (200 IU) reference valueErgocalciferol or cholecalciferol, as used

“Vitamin D2” is a specific name, not a synonym for vitamin D. A pack made with ergocalciferol cannot call itself D3 or cholecalciferol, and a cholecalciferol pack should not be sold as D2. The generic nutrient name may appear on the front of the pack, but the ingredient list has to name the form that is present.

The source statement sits beside the form. A vegan claim is supported by the ergosterol route for D2 or the lichen route for D3; lanolin-derived D3 does not support it. The claim is the brand's, and the supplier's source statement is the evidence behind it.

The assay has to match the molecule

Both forms are determined by HPLC with ultraviolet detection near 265 nm. Their spectra are similar, so a single “vitamin D” peak does not show which molecule was measured. A defensible method runs an ergocalciferol standard for a D2 lot and a cholecalciferol standard for a D3 lot, resolves the two peaks, and reports the result against the matching standard.

Retention time is the first discriminant; co-injection or a diode-array spectrum strengthens the assignment; mass detection separates the two when the peaks overlap. The certificate should identify the standard, column, mobile phase and wavelength, and say whether the other form was screened, with the detection limit.

A certificate written against a D3 standard does not release a D2 lot. One potency figure fits either molecule; the chromatogram and the reference standard are what separate them. Moving from D3 to D2 therefore calls for a fresh specification and certificate, not an annotation on the old one.

Stability follows the form and the pack

Both forms are sensitive to light, heat and oxygen. Ergocalciferol has the higher melting range, but that does not make it the more stable molecule in every matrix: its extra double bond is an additional site for oxidation, and acidic matrices promote isomerisation for both forms. The pack, the carrier and the matrix decide the rate.

The crystalline powder is specified at loss on drying ≤0.5% and protected by a foil pouch. An oil blend adds the carrier's oxidation to the file, and an emulsion adds light, oxygen, heat and pH at once. A stability summary written for a D3 powder does not transfer to a D2 powder, and a D2 powder summary does not transfer to a D2 oil blend.

What transfers is the method: state the pack, the condition, the time points and the tests, and report the individual results. The vitamin D2 stability page sets out that protocol.

What changes when the form changes

Switching D2 for D3 replaces the ingredient; the two are not interchangeable. The specification changes (CAS number, formula, melting range, assay standard), the certificate changes, the label changes, the source statement changes and the stability file has to be repeated for the new form and the new matrix.

The 40 IU per microgram arithmetic carries over, but the label and the regulatory citation have to point to the molecule in the pack. A D2 lot does not meet a D3 specification, and a D3 lot leaves a label naming ergocalciferol unsatisfied.

Before a form change, request a new certificate, a chromatogram against the matching standard and stability data for the new matrix. The vitamin D2 product page covers the ergocalciferol grade; the vitamin D3 product page covers the cholecalciferol grade; the D2 grades page compares the powder and oil formats; the D2 COA page explains the assay; the D2 compliance page covers the market files; the HPLC method note describes the separation; the quality page covers the release workflow.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation