02.1 Cyano vs methyl

Cyanocobalamin vs methylcobalamin: form, stability and the label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Vitamin B12

On this page
  1. Two cobalamins, one difference
  2. What the microgram figure does and does not mean
  3. Stability is where the forms separate
  4. The EU list is the decisive difference
  5. What the label has to say
  6. Choosing between them

Cyanocobalamin and methylcobalamin share the same corrin ring and the same cobalt centre; the difference is the group attached to the cobalt, a cyano group in one and a methyl group in the other. That single substitution changes the molecular weight, the light sensitivity, the permitted-form position in the EU and the word that must appear in the ingredient list. Both are declared as vitamin B12 in micrograms, so the switch is not a potency conversion, and the catalog grade is the cyano form as a 1% spray-dried powder.

In one line

The two forms differ by the group on the cobalt, and that group decides the stability, the EU permitted-form question and the label word, not the microgram figure.

Two cobalamins, one difference

Cyanocobalamin has the formula C63H88CoN14O14P and a molecular weight of about 1,355 g/mol. Methylcobalamin replaces the cyano ligand with a methyl group, giving C63H91CoN13O14P and a molecular weight of about 1,344 g/mol. Both are red, water-soluble and handled as fine powders at supplement scale; the colour comes from the corrin ring, not from the ligand.

The ligand is not decoration. The cyano group holds the cobalt in a stable configuration, which is why the cyano form is the one normally spray-dried for a 1% grade; the methyl group is more labile, and the methyl form converts more readily to hydroxocobalamin under light or in solution.

What the microgram figure does and does not mean

Both forms are declared as vitamin B12 in micrograms, and the claim is a mass of the named substance. There is no official conversion factor; the molar difference is about 0.8%, below the precision of a label claim and not applied in practice.

The arithmetic that matters is the dilution. A 1% powder of either form carries 10 mg per gram, so a 100 µg claim draws 10 mg and a 2.4 µg claim draws 0.24 mg. The form changes the assay standard and the certificate name, not the mass per microgram of claim.

A methyl certificate should be run against a methylcobalamin standard, not a cyanocobalamin standard with a borrowed response factor: the maxima and retention behaviour differ, and the wrong standard still produces a plausible number.

Stability is where the forms separate

The cyano form is the more stable of the two in the solid state and in solution, and that stability is the main reason it is the usual form in a 1% powder. The methyl form is more sensitive to light, and its degradation product is hydroxocobalamin, which shifts the visible spectrum and the colour. A methyl powder that has seen too much light looks different before the assay confirms it.

Both forms need an opaque pack, a dry carrier and a controlled process, and both are supplied as dilutions for the same handling reason. The difference is the size of the margin: a cyano 1% powder has more room for the light exposure of a normal filling room than a methyl powder does. That margin belongs in the stability protocol and in the pack specification, not in a general statement that “B12 is light-sensitive”.

In a premix the neighbours matter more than the form: ascorbic acid, iron salts and moisture move both cobalamins, and a gummy cook is harder than a capsule. The form narrows the margin; it does not remove the stability study.

The EU list is the decisive difference

Directive 2002/46/EC Annex II lists the vitamin forms permitted in food supplements in the EU, and for vitamin B12 it names cyanocobalamin and hydroxocobalamin. Cyanocobalamin therefore has a clear entry for a 1% preparation; methylcobalamin does not appear on that list. That does not make methylcobalamin a prohibited substance, but an EU food supplement cannot rely on the Annex II entry for it, and the route to market needs its own assessment. The position should be checked against the current consolidated text and against member state practice as of the review date.

The UK applies retained EU law and its own supplements regulations, so the same question arises there, while Northern Ireland follows the EU regime. The US regards both as dietary ingredients, and the label names the form. A brand selling into all three markets decides whether one label serves them or the methyl version is a separate SKU.

This is the point where the form question stops being technical. A form that is stable and easy to handle but absent from a permitted list is a harder commercial position than a form with a clear entry, and the reverse is true in a market that asks for methyl by name.

What the label has to say

The nutrition declaration states vitamin B12 in µg and as a percentage of the reference value — 2.5 µg in the EU and 2.4 µg in the US — and that figure does not change with the form. The ingredient list is where the form appears: “cyanocobalamin” or “methylcobalamin”, named as the substance used, not hidden behind “vitamin B12”. A product that contains both forms lists both.

The dilution adds a second label obligation. A 1% powder is about ninety-nine parts carrier, so starch or maltodextrin appears in the ingredient list and the nutrient figure is calculated from the assay, not from the powder weight. Describing a 1% preparation as “pure vitamin B12” is inaccurate in any market, and describing a methyl product as cyanocobalamin — or the reverse — is a mislabelling of the ingredient.

Pack copy should keep the nutrient and the form separate. “Vitamin B12” is the nutrient name in the nutrition panel; the form is an ingredient, and mixing the two is what the form name exists to prevent.

Choosing between them

Cyano and methyl compared on the points a buyer can verify
PointCyanocobalaminMethylcobalamin
Cobalt ligandCyanoMethyl
Molecular weightAbout 1,355 g/molAbout 1,344 g/mol
EU Annex IIListedNot listed
US statusDietary ingredientDietary ingredient
Light sensitivityLowerHigher
Label nameCyanocobalaminMethylcobalamin

Choose the cyano form when the product is sold in the EU or the UK, when a 1% spray-dried powder on starch or maltodextrin fits the fill, and when a longer, better-understood stability margin is worth more than a form name. Choose methyl when the customer or the market specifies it by name and the regulatory route for that market has been assessed. In both cases the dilution, the carrier and the pack are specified the same way.

The comparison continues on the grade page, which works through 1% versus 0.1%; the stability argument is on the stability page, and the permitted-form file on the compliance page. The Annex II term is defined in the glossary, the EU framework on the regulatory page, and the product specification on the vitamin B12 product page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation