06 Identity & adulteration

How to prove a pantothenic acid lot is the free acid

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Pantothenic Acid

On this page
  1. The identity layers
  2. The 0.920 ratio and the counter-ion
  3. X-ray diffraction and the solid state
  4. What adulteration looks like
  5. How to write the identity into the specification
  6. Five questions for the supplier

A pantothenic acid lot is the free acid when the document names CAS 79-83-4, the HPLC retention and IR spectrum match the reference, the 5% solution is acidic, and the moisture and assay close the mass balance. The assay alone cannot separate the free acid from the calcium salt, the sodium salt or a dilution; the pH and the counter-ion tests can.

In one line

Identity is a set of agreeing measurements: IR and retention say pantothenic acid, the acidic solution says the free acid, and the calcium or sodium figure rules out a salt.

The identity layers

A certificate can name the right material without proving that the powder is that material. The layers below answer separate questions, each with its own evidence; a supplier who answers only the first has described paperwork, not powder.

Layers of D-pantothenic acid identity
LayerQuestionTestWhat it establishes
DocumentIs the form named?Name, CAS number, formulaPaperwork only
ChromatographyIs the molecule pantothenic acid?HPLC retention with the wavelength statedThe molecule
SpectroscopyDo the functional groups match?IR against a reference spectrumThe acid and amide bands
FormIs it the free acid?pH of a 5% solution; calcium and sodium by ICP-OESThe counter-ion
Mass balanceIs it diluted?Assay, loss on drying, impuritiesConsistency of the numbers

The IR layer is the strongest single check for this molecule because it shows both the carboxyl group and the amide. The HPLC layer is weaker on its own: pantothenic acid has no strong chromophore, so a method at a poorly chosen wavelength can see very little. Ask for the wavelength and the standard, not only a retention time.

The 0.920 ratio and the counter-ion

The calcium salt contains two pantothenic acid units per calcium ion. At full assay, 476.53 g of calcium pantothenate carries 438.46 g of pantothenic acid, which is 92.0% by mass. The calcium figure at full assay is 8.41%, and the catalog range of 8.0–8.6% is set around it. Those two figures give a useful ratio: calcium percentage divided by assay percentage, on the same basis, sits near 0.084 for the pure salt.

For the free acid the check runs the other way. There is no calcium and no sodium in the molecule, so a calcium result above the method's detection limit points to the salt, a blend or a calcium-rich diluent. A sodium result does the same for sodium pantothenate. Read the counter-ion against the assay: a blend of salt and free acid can be built to land inside the assay range, but its calcium figure falls in proportion to the salt fraction.

The pH supports the same conclusion. A 5% solution of the free acid sits at pH 2.5–3.5; a pantothenate salt gives a solution nearer neutral. The pH is not a quantitative ratio, because concentration and residual acid move it, but a neutral pH on a lot sold as the free acid is a reason to test the counter-ion.

Chirality is a separate question. D- and L-pantothenic acid have the same IR spectrum and the same retention on an achiral HPLC column. If the D-form is contractual, ask for specific rotation on the dried basis; the catalog identity lines do not separate the enantiomers.

X-ray diffraction and the solid state

X-ray diffraction answers a different question: is the powder crystalline, and does its pattern match a reference? It can distinguish a crystalline solid from an amorphous one and can reveal a crystalline carrier in a blended or diluted grade. It is not a purity assay and it does not measure the counter-ion.

For a free-acid powder, the diffractogram earns its place when the solid form is contested or a second source is being qualified. Before accepting a “match”, ask which reference pattern was used and how low the method can detect a second phase. A certificate that states “XRD conforms” but attaches neither pattern nor reference has told the reader almost nothing; XRD is not a routine release test here.

What adulteration looks like

Common pantothenic acid substitutions and the signals
AdulterantWhat it doesSignalTest
Calcium pantothenateAdds calcium; raises pH toward neutralCalcium present; pH above the free-acid windowCalcium by ICP-OES, pH
Sodium pantothenateAdds sodium; raises pH toward neutralSodium present; pH shiftSodium by ICP-OES, pH
D-PanthenolA different molecule with a similar nameDifferent retention and IR; no acid pHHPLC, IR
L- or DL-pantothenic acidSame spectra and achiral retentionRotation differs from the D-formPolarimetry
Crystalline diluentLowers the assay per gramAssay low; sharp carrier peaks in XRDAssay, XRD, IR
WaterRaises loss on drying; lowers the as-is assayLOD high; anhydrous assay normalLoss on drying

Colour is the least reliable signal. White to off-white covers a wide range, and a diluent can reproduce it. The stronger signals are the IR spectrum, the acidic pH, the counter-ion figure and the mass balance. A certificate that reports appearance and assay but leaves out identity has left the most likely substitution untested.

How to write the identity into the specification

  • “D-Pantothenic acid, CAS 79-83-4, C9H17NO5.”
  • “Assay 98.0–101.0% by HPLC; state the moisture basis and the detection wavelength.”
  • “Identification by HPLC retention and IR spectrum, both against a reference.”
  • “pH 2.5–3.5 in 5% solution; loss on drying ≤5.0%.”
  • “Calcium and sodium below the stated limit, or reported with the method, where the form is to be confirmed.”
  • “Specific rotation on the dried basis where the D-form is contractual.”
  • “Destination market and form confirmed before the order.”

Five questions for the supplier

  1. Is this lot the free acid, and what CAS number does the certificate carry?
  2. Will you send the IR spectrum and HPLC chromatogram, with the wavelength and the standard used?
  3. What are the calcium and sodium results, and what method produced them?
  4. What is the pH of a 5% solution, and what is the loss on drying for this lot?
  5. If the D-form is disputed, will you provide specific rotation and accept a joint re-test on the retained sample?

Five direct answers amount to an identity file; one assay percentage does not. The product hub holds the catalog data; the COA page maps each release figure onto the certificate; the grades page puts the free acid beside the salt; the level-four comparison works through the label arithmetic; the methods library explains the HPLC and ICP-OES tests; the vitamin B5 page covers the calcium salt; and the quality page describes the release file.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation