Pantothenic acid vs calcium pantothenate: the assay, the water and the label
Pantothenic acid and calcium pantothenate are two forms of the same vitamin with different CAS numbers, molecular weights, assay bases and label positions. The salt is 92.0% pantothenic acid by mass and carries 8.4% calcium at full assay; the free acid is the reference molecule and the form supplied on this page. Switching form changes the weigh-up, the water and the ingredient list.
The salt is 92.0% pantothenic acid by mass and the free acid is all of itself; the assay basis, the water and the label have to be read on the same form.
Two forms, two identities
Pantothenic acid is an amide of pantoic acid and β-alanine. The free acid carries the carboxyl proton; calcium pantothenate replaces two of those protons with one calcium ion, so the salt contains two pantothenic acid units per calcium. That difference gives each material its own CAS number, molecular weight and label name.
| Property | D-Pantothenic acid | Calcium D-pantothenate |
|---|---|---|
| CAS number | 79-83-4 | 137-08-6 |
| Formula | C9H17NO5 | C18H32CaN2O10 |
| Molecular weight | 219.23 | 476.53 |
| Pantothenic acid content | 100% of the molecule | 92.0% by mass |
| Calcium | None | 8.4% at full assay (catalog 8.0–8.6%) |
| Appearance and mesh | White to off-white powder, 80 mesh | White powder, 40 mesh |
| pH (5% solution) | 2.5–3.5 | Near neutral |
| Label name | D-Pantothenic acid | Calcium D-pantothenate |
| EU food-supplement list | Not a separate entry as of this review | Named in Annex II |
Both columns declare pantothenic acid on the nutrition panel. The difference appears in the ingredient list, in the mass on the balance and in the market file.
The assay and the salt factor
The conversion factor is fixed by the molecular weights: 438.46 ÷ 476.53 = 0.920. One milligram of calcium pantothenate at full assay carries 0.920 mg of pantothenic acid, and one milligram of pantothenic acid needs 1.087 mg of the salt. The factor belongs to the molecule, not to the certificate.
Two worked examples show what that means at the balance. A label that declares 10 mg of pantothenic acid from the free acid needs 10 mg of the acid at full assay, before the moisture correction. The same label built on the calcium salt needs 10 × 1.087 = 10.87 mg of salt. If the salt lot assays 99.0% on the dried basis with 3.0% loss on drying, its as-is content is 0.99 × 0.97 = 96.0%, and the weigh-up becomes 10.87 ÷ 0.960 = 11.32 mg of powder. The free acid at the same assay and moisture needs 10 ÷ 0.960 = 10.41 mg.
The two corrections are separate. The salt factor changes the molecule; the moisture factor changes the mass on the balance. Applying one and not the other is the common error. The certificate also has to say whether its assay is as-is or on the dried basis, because the catalog range alone does not settle that.
The water in both forms
Both catalogs set loss on drying at ≤5.0%, and both materials are hygroscopic. The free acid is supplied here at 80 mesh, finer than the salt at 40 mesh, so it exposes more surface and takes up moisture faster from an open pack. The water raises the loss on drying, lowers the as-is assay and can cake the powder; at the balance it is the difference between 10.0 and 10.4 mg in the example above.
Moisture also changes the label arithmetic when the assay is quoted on the dried basis. The certificate should pair the assay with the measured loss on drying, and the specification should state the basis. A result close to the 5.0% limit leaves less room for pickup in a humid warehouse, and the pouch or drum has to be resealed promptly.
The free acid and the salt both need a sealed, dry pack, and the solution stability depends on pH rather than on which form was weighed. The stability page sets out the conditions.
What the label has to say
The nutrition declaration uses the nutrient name “pantothenic acid”: the EU reference intake is 6 mg under Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, and the US daily value is 5 mg in the Supplement Facts panel. “Vitamin B5” is a synonym, not the nutrient name on the panel.
The ingredient list is where the form appears. It should say D-pantothenic acid or calcium D-pantothenate, because that is what was weighed. A label that declares pantothenic acid while the ingredient list names only vitamin B5 has not identified the material, and a label built on the salt but written with the free-acid name is a mismatch that the certificate cannot repair.
In the EU, Directive 2002/46/EC lists the permitted pantothenic acid forms in Annex II; as of this review it names calcium D-pantothenate, sodium D-pantothenate, dexpanthenol and pantethine, and the free acid is not a separate entry. The buyer's regulatory team confirms the route for the destination and checks the current text. The compliance page lists the documents.
Handling, taste and the dosage form
The free acid gives an acidic 5% solution at pH 2.5–3.5. In a capsule that is invisible; in a stick pack or a drink mix it is a sharp taste that the formulator has to manage. The calcium salt gives a solution nearer neutral and may be the easier choice for a beverage, at the cost of the salt factor and the calcium contribution: 500 mg of pantothenic acid from the salt carries about 46 mg of calcium.
The physical grades differ as well. The free acid is an 80 mesh powder and the salt a 40 mesh powder, so their flow, dust and dispersion are not the same. A direct-compression tablet may prefer the coarser salt; a hard capsule can take either; a stick pack needs a powder that disperses without lumps. Granulation is available on request for the free acid, and it changes the physical lines, not the assay.
The free acid is not a drop-in for the salt: the mass, the pH, the taste and the label all change, so a switch needs a written change control, a new specification and a label review. The identity page gives the tests that separate the forms.
When to choose which
Choose the free acid when the label names it, the destination route covers it, the acidic taste fits the dosage form, and the lower mass per serving is useful. It is the form supplied here, specified at 98.0–101.0% by HPLC with loss on drying, pH and 80 mesh.
Choose calcium pantothenate when the market file or the label is written around the salt, when a near-neutral solution is needed, or when the calcium contribution is acceptable. It is a different purchase with a different assay basis and a different certificate; the calcium figure and the salt factor belong in the specification.
The product hub carries the free-acid specification; the vitamin B5 page carries the calcium salt; the grades page places both in the wider range; the methods library describes the assays; the quality page describes the release workflow.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation