02.1 Methyl vs cyano

Methylcobalamin vs cyanocobalamin: form, stability and label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Methylcobalamin

On this page
  1. The ligand is the difference
  2. Stability separates them in practice
  3. What the label has to say
  4. The assay has to match the form
  5. What changes when the form changes
  6. The route is a separate question

Methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin share the corrin ring and the cobalt centre; the group on the cobalt is a methyl in one and a cyano in the other. That ligand changes the molecular weight, the photostability, the assay standard and the ingredient name, while the nutrition label still declares vitamin B12 in micrograms. The two are separate products with separate specifications, not two strengths of one material.

In one line

One ligand separates the two: methylcobalamin is the more photolabile form, cyanocobalamin the more stable reference form, and the label must name the form even though both declare vitamin B12.

The ligand is the difference

Cyanocobalamin carries a cyano group on the cobalt; methylcobalamin carries a methyl group. The rest of the molecule, including the corrin ring that gives the red colour, is the same. The substitution moves the molecular weight by about 11 units, from roughly 1,355 g/mol for the cyano form to roughly 1,344 g/mol for the methyl form, and it changes the CAS number and the formula. Those are the fields that should be compared on a certificate before any assay figure is read.

Methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin on the identity fields
FieldMethylcobalaminCyanocobalamin
CAS number13422-55-468-19-9
FormulaC63H91CoN13O14PC63H88CoN14O14P
Molecular weightAbout 1,344 g/molAbout 1,355 g/mol
Cobalt ligandMethylCyano
UV-Vis maximaAbout 267, 342 and 522 nmAbout 361 and 550 nm
Ingredient name on the labelMethylcobalaminCyanocobalamin

The colour is not a distinguishing test. Both are dark red, and the main degradation product of the methyl form is also red. A visual comparison of two powders tells the buyer almost nothing about which ligand is present.

Stability separates them in practice

The methyl ligand is more labile than the cyano ligand. In light, and especially in aqueous solution, methylcobalamin loses the methyl group and moves toward hydroxocobalamin; the assay falls and the spectrum changes. The solid is more forgiving than the solution, but the surface still reacts, and a clear container is an exposure whatever the ambient temperature. Cyanocobalamin is the more stable of the two forms, which is why it is the usual choice for a spray-dried 1% grade and for a process with a long light exposure.

This is a margin, not a binary. Both forms need an opaque pack, a controlled process and a stability study in the finished matrix. The difference is how much room the form leaves for a normal filling room, a clear hopper or a warm hold. A methyl project should write the light-protection steps into the process description and check them on the line; a cyano project still needs the pack and the study, but it starts with a larger margin.

What the label has to say

The nutrition declaration states vitamin B12 in micrograms and as a percentage of the reference value, and that figure does not change with the form. The ingredient list is where the form appears: “methylcobalamin” or “cyanocobalamin”, named as the substance used. A product that contains both forms lists both. A label that says only “vitamin B12” in the ingredient list has left the form unnamed, and that is the point where a methyl product and a cyano product become indistinguishable on the shelf.

The dilution adds a second obligation, but only on one side. The cyanocobalamin product is a 1% spray-dried powder, so its carrier, starch or maltodextrin, is an ingredient and must be declared. The methylcobalamin product is a crystalline powder with no carrier, so its ingredient list is shorter. Neither difference changes the nutrient figure, which is calculated from the assay and the serving weight rather than from the powder weight.

The assay has to match the form

Methylcobalamin is specified at 98.0–101.0% by HPLC; the cyanocobalamin 1% grade is specified at ≥1.0% by HPLC. Those figures are not two points on one scale. The first describes the purity of a crystalline material and the second describes the active content of a dilution, so a comparison needs the basis, the carrier and the serving weight before it means anything.

The standard is the other half of the assay. A methyl sample should be run against a methylcobalamin reference standard, with the spectrum read at the methyl maxima and the ratios stated by the method. A cyanocobalamin standard read at 361 nm will produce a number for a methyl sample, but the number describes an assumption rather than the material. When two suppliers report the same percentage for the two forms, ask which standard and which wavelength produced it.

What changes when the form changes

A switch is a specification change, not a substitution at the balance. The table lists the fields that have to be rewritten; leaving one of them on the old form is how a label and a certificate stop matching.

Fields that change with the form
FieldWhat changes
SpecificationName, CAS number, formula, assay expression and identity standard
Weigh-upThe mass per serving, because the assay expression and the dilution differ
Pack and processThe light-protection margin and the storage condition
LabelThe ingredient name, and the carrier where a dilution is used
Stability fileThe data for the new form and the new pack
Market fileThe permitted-form route and the documents for the destination

The dose figure needs care. Both forms are declared as vitamin B12 in micrograms, and the two molecular weights differ by under one percent — below the precision of a label claim, so the practical arithmetic is the assay and the dilution rather than a form factor. A 1,000 µg claim from the crystalline methyl powder is about a milligram of powder; the same claim from a 1% cyano powder is about a hundred milligrams of powder, and that difference in fill weight is the one that changes the capsule.

The route is a separate question

The permitted-form position is not settled by the chemistry. In the EU, Annex II of Directive 2002/46/EC is the list to check for food supplements; in the US, the dietary-ingredient basis and the finished product's compliance are separate questions; Great Britain and Northern Ireland do not share one file. The buyer's regulatory team confirms which entry or basis covers the grade for the destination, against the current text, and records the answer with the order.

That answer belongs in writing before the label is approved. A form that is technically suitable and stable can still sit outside the file for a market, and a form with a clear route can be the wrong choice for a process that cannot protect it from light. The two questions are answered together, not in sequence.

The methylcobalamin product page carries the crystalline specification; the vitamin B12 product page covers the cyanocobalamin 1% grade; the grades page places this comparison in the wider range; the cyano versus methyl page takes the regulatory question further; the analytical methods library covers the HPLC and UV work; the quality page describes the release file.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation