Adenosylcobalamin vs methylcobalamin: form, stability and label
Adenosylcobalamin and methylcobalamin are both coenzyme forms of vitamin B12, and both are red solids that declare the same nutrient. The difference sits in the upper ligand: a 5'-deoxyadenosyl group in one, a methyl group in the other. That single substitution changes the formula, the mass, the chromatographic behaviour, the assay gate and the light margin.
One ligand separates the two coenzyme forms: the adenosyl molecule is about 235 mass units heavier, its catalog gate is wider, and both need an opaque pack and a label that names the form.
The ligand is the difference
The corrin ring and the cobalt are shared; the group above the cobalt is not. Adenosylcobalamin carries a 5'-deoxyadenosyl group and the CAS number 13870-90-1. Methylcobalamin carries a methyl group and the CAS number 13422-55-4. The table lists the fields that should match before an assay comparison means anything.
| Field | Adenosylcobalamin | Methylcobalamin |
|---|---|---|
| CAS number | 13870-90-1 | 13422-55-4 |
| Formula | C72H100CoN18O17P | C63H91CoN13O14P |
| Molecular weight | About 1,579.6 g/mol | About 1,344.4 g/mol |
| Cobalt ligand | 5'-deoxyadenosyl | Methyl |
| UV-Vis maxima | Near 260, 375 and 522 nm | Near 267, 342 and 522 nm |
| Ingredient name on the label | Adenosylcobalamin | Methylcobalamin |
A red colour and a B12 assay do not tell the two apart. The 375 nm band does, which is why the identity standard and the spectrum belong in the specification rather than in a methods footnote.
What the extra mass means
The adenosyl group adds about 235 mass units, so the molecule is roughly 17.5% heavier. Cobalt falls from about 4.4% in methylcobalamin to about 3.7% in the adenosyl form, a useful analytical check but not a label conversion.
Vitamin B12 is declared by mass, so a 1,000 µg claim remains 1,000 µg whichever form carries it. The extra mass is inside the molecule. What changes on the line is the assay and the moisture, because a 95.0% powder needs more material than a 99.0% powder for the same declared figure.
Stability: the same failure mode, a different margin
Both forms lose the upper ligand when light reaches the cobalt–carbon bond; the adenosyl bond is the weaker of the two, and the loss product is hydroxocobalamin. The solid survives longer than the solution, but the powder surface still reacts, and a clear hopper or an open tray is an exposure.
Neither form has a shelf life by itself. The pack, the storage temperature and the finished matrix set the period, and the study has to be run on the form and pack being sold. A methyl study does not release an adenosyl lot, and an adenosyl study does not release a methyl one.
The assay has to match the form
The catalog values differ: ≥95.0% for adenosylcobalamin, 98.0–101.0% for methylcobalamin. These are release gates of different widths, not grades of one product. The ≤10.0% moisture allowance belongs beside the adenosyl assay and its basis.
Each form needs its own reference standard. An adenosyl sample read against a methyl standard at 342 nm, or a cyano standard at 361 nm, can produce a number, but that number is an assumption. Ask for the standard, the wavelength and the spectrum before comparing two certificates.
What the label has to say
The nutrition panel counts vitamin B12 in micrograms; the ingredient list is the only place the form appears. Write “adenosylcobalamin” or “methylcobalamin” there, not the family name alone. If a product uses both, both are listed.
In the EU, Annex II of Directive 2002/46/EC lists 5'-deoxyadenosylcobalamin and methylcobalamin on separate lines; cite the line that matches the ingredient, as of this review. In the US, the Supplement Facts panel gives the vitamin B12 amount and the ingredient list gives the form. A dilution adds its carrier to that list; the crystalline grades do not.
Claims attach to vitamin B12 and its authorised wording, not to the ligand, and no disease-related claim is made here.
When to choose which
Pick the form the specification and the market file name, then confirm that the process can protect it. If the label and the file say adenosylcobalamin, supply that form; if they say methylcobalamin, do not substitute on the basis of a higher assay.
A switch requires a new specification, a new standard, a new stability file and a label review. The weigh-up, the pack and the process light controls move with it. Handle the change as a new product introduction, not a purchasing swap.
The adenosylcobalamin product page carries the catalog specification; the methylcobalamin product page covers the other form; the grades page places this comparison in the wider range; the methods library covers the HPLC and UV work; the quality page describes the release file.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation