PQQ disodium vs free acid: solubility, dose and the label
The disodium salt and the free acid differ by two sodium ions and about 44 mass units: 374.17 versus 330.21 g/mol. The disodium salt is the usual form in supplements and the form named in the EU novel-food entry; the free acid is the parent molecule and a different label ingredient. Switching form changes the assay conversion, the water solubility and the regulatory citation.
Two sodium ions change the molecular weight by 13%, the water solubility and the name that must appear on the label.
Two forms, two identities
PQQ is a tricarboxylic acid. The free acid carries the acid protons; the disodium salt replaces two of them with sodium ions. That is the whole structural difference, and it is enough to make the two materials separate specification items with separate CAS numbers.
| Property | Disodium salt | Free acid |
|---|---|---|
| CAS number | 122628-50-6 | 72909-34-3 |
| Formula | C14H4N2Na2O8 | C14H6N2O8 |
| Molecular weight | 374.17 | 330.21 |
| Sodium content | About 12.3% by mass | None |
| Appearance | Reddish-brown to dark red powder | Red to reddish-brown solid |
| Water solubility | Soluble; reddish-brown solution | Sparingly soluble |
| Label name | Pyrroloquinoline quinone disodium salt | Pyrroloquinoline quinone |
| EU novel-food entry | The form named in the entry | Not the form named in the entry |
The conversion between the forms
The conversion factor is the ratio of molecular weights: 330.21 ÷ 374.17 = 0.8825. Multiply a disodium result by 0.8825 to express it as free-acid equivalent; divide a free-acid figure by 0.8825 to get the disodium mass. The factor is fixed by the formula, not by the assay.
Two worked examples make the label dose arithmetic concrete. A formula that declares 20 mg of PQQ as free acid needs 20 ÷ 0.8825 = 22.66 mg of the disodium salt. A formula that declares 20 mg of PQQ disodium salt delivers 17.65 mg of free-acid equivalent. Neither figure is a recommendation; they are the arithmetic that keeps the label and the weigh-up in agreement.
The assay basis is a separate conversion. A 99.0% result on the anhydrous basis is not 99.0% of the powder as weighed. Convert to the as-is basis with the loss on drying, then apply the salt factor if the label uses the other form; leaving either step out is the usual error.
Solubility and the solution
The disodium salt dissolves in water and gives a reddish-brown solution. It is the practical form for capsules, stick packs and aqueous systems because the powder disperses without a solvent. Solubility is still finite, and a concentrated stock may need pH adjustment, warming or sonication. The free acid is much less soluble in water and is normally handled in organic solvent or as a fine suspension.
Solubility is not stability. The disodium solution is light-sensitive, and a clear bottle on a bench is the wrong container for a hold. The free acid has a different solution pH, so a formula built on one form cannot be switched to the other without rechecking the appearance, the pH and the hold time.
For a beverage or a stick pack, the salt is the easier starting point. For a non-aqueous system, the free acid may be the only one that dissolves. The choice belongs to the formulation, and it should be made before the label is written.
Stability follows the form and the pack
Both forms are solids that need protection from light and moisture. The disodium salt is specified here at loss on drying ≤5.0%, and it picks up moisture when the pouch is left open. The free acid has its own moisture profile, but it is not automatically the more stable form; the handling and the pack still decide.
The disodium salt in solution is the least stable format. Light, oxygen, heat and pH act together, and a hot-fill step adds a heat load that the powder never sees. The free acid in organic solvent has a different set of risks, including solvent residue and flammability. Neither form should be described as stable without the pack, the matrix and the time.
The practical rules are the same on both sides: keep the solid sealed and dark, keep the solution protected and validated, and assign the retest period from data for the exact pack. The stability page sets out the protocol.
What the label has to say
In the EU, the novel-food designation is “Pyrroloquinoline quinone disodium salt”. The entry covers food supplements for adults excluding pregnant and lactating women, at a maximum of 20 mg/day, and it is tied to a defined specification. A free-acid ingredient is not covered by that entry, even if the assay is higher and the colour matches.
In the United States, the Supplement Facts panel names the dietary ingredient. “PQQ” alone is ambiguous; the salt form should be written out in the panel. In Great Britain, the GB register has its own conditions and must be checked separately; Northern Ireland follows the EU list. The label must match the form that the market file covers, not the form that was ordered.
When to choose which
Choose the disodium salt for supplements, for aqueous systems, and for any market where the disodium entry is the one that applies. It is the form with the commercial specification, the sodium figure that proves it, and the label name used in the EU entry. This is the form we supply.
Choose the free acid only when the formula or the label calls for it and the market file covers it. It is not a drop-in for the salt: the mass changes, the solubility changes and the regulatory citation changes. A switch in either direction needs a written change control, a new specification and a label check.
The product hub carries the catalog specification; the grades page places this comparison in the wider range; the compliance page covers the market entries; the identity page gives the tests that separate the forms; the COA page shows how the form is reported.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation