06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a creatine lot is the hydrochloride

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Creatine HCl

On this page
  1. The four identity layers
  2. The creatine-to-chloride ratio
  3. X-ray diffraction and the solid state
  4. What substitution looks like
  5. How to write the identity into the specification
  6. Five questions for the supplier

Four independent checks make a creatine hydrochloride lot: HPLC and IR show the creatine molecule, titration measures chloride, the creatine content should land between 74.0% and 78.0%, and loss on drying should stay at or below 1.0%. A salt assay by itself cannot distinguish the hydrochloride from the monohydrate or from free creatine. Chloride and the acidic solution are what make the form visible.

In one line

A creatine HCl lot is proved by the chloride and the acidic solution as much as by the creatine peak: HPLC and IR name the molecule, titration names the counter-ion.

The four identity layers

Every test answers a separate question and leaves a separate blind spot. A certificate can name the right product and still say nothing about the powder in the drum; the layers below only work when read together.

Four layers of creatine hydrochloride identity
LayerQuestionTestWhat it proves
DocumentAre the form, CAS and pack named?Name, CAS 17050-09-8, formula, lot codeTraceability only
MolecularIs the molecule creatine?HPLC retention plus IR against a referenceThe creatine skeleton, not the salt
Counter-ionIs chloride the counter-ion?Chloride titration and pH of a defined solutionThe hydrochloride form
Mass balanceIs the powder diluted or partly another form?Creatine content, LOD, chloride ratioWhether the numbers agree

Paperwork is the first layer, and it is the easiest to get wrong: a valid certificate can belong to a different drum or grade. The lot code should be identical on the certificate, the pouch, the drum and the retained sample.

The creatine-to-chloride ratio

The 1:1 salt has fixed arithmetic. Creatine hydrochloride is 167.59 g/mol; creatine contributes 131.13 g, or 78.2%, and chloride about 21.2%. That gives a creatine-to-chloride mass ratio near 3.70:1. A chloride result close to 21.2% alongside a creatine content near 78% is what a single salt should produce.

The paired numbers catch more than either one alone. Low chloride with high creatine suggests free creatine or monohydrate, since both carry more creatine and no chloride. High chloride with a low assay suggests sodium chloride or another chloride source. A correct chloride figure with creatine outside the window suggests a measurement problem, a blend or a different salt.

Loss on drying settles the hydrate question. This salt is not a hydrate and is released at ≤1.0%; the monohydrate contains about 12% water of crystallisation and is released at ≤12.0%. No chloride, a high LOD and a creatine content near 88% describe the monohydrate, not a damp hydrochloride. Read the three lines together.

X-ray diffraction and the solid state

X-ray diffraction tests the solid state: is the powder crystalline, and does the pattern match a reference? The hydrochloride, monohydrate and free creatine can differ in pattern, so a match can support the form when titration alone cannot separate a single salt from a physical mixture. It can also distinguish a crystal from an amorphous dilution.

Diffraction is not a purity assay and says nothing about the counter-ion. Before accepting a match, ask for the reference pattern and the method's detection limit. On a disputed lot, XRD alongside chloride and HPLC is stronger than either test alone. This is not a routine release test for the salt, and “XRD conforms” without the pattern tells the reader almost nothing.

What substitution looks like

Creatine forms and diluents that can pass a creatine assay
MaterialWhat changesSignalTest
Creatine monohydrateNo chloride; about 12% water; creatine near 88%Low chloride; LOD above 1.0%; pH nearer neutralChloride, LOD, pH, IR
Free creatineNo chloride; creatine near 100%Low chloride; higher pH; high creatineChloride, pH, IR, XRD
Creatine nitrateDifferent counter-ion; nitrate loadLittle or no chloride; nitrate peak; acidic pHIon chromatography, chloride, IR
Sodium chlorideSalt raises chloride and ash; active assay dropsChloride high; sodium detectedChloride, sodium by ICP-OES, assay
Diluent or waterAssay and creatine fall; LOD may riseLow creatine; mass balance does not closeHPLC, LOD, IR

Creatine nitrate and the monohydrate are legitimate when declared and labelled. The problem is a form that was not declared, not the existence of an alternative. Colour proves very little: the white-to-off-white window is broad, and a blend can reproduce it. Chloride, loss on drying and creatine content are the stronger signals.

How to write the identity into the specification

  • “Creatine hydrochloride, CAS 17050-09-8, C4H9N3O2·HCl; one salt, no monohydrate or diluent.”
  • “Assay 99.0–101.0% as the salt by HPLC; creatine content 74.0–78.0%.”
  • “HPLC retention and IR against a reference; spectra available on request.”
  • “Chloride about 21.2% by titration, where the form needs analytical confirmation.”
  • “Loss on drying ≤1.0%; pH of a defined solution reported.”
  • “Heavy metals and microbiology as catalogued; ≥95% through 80 mesh.”
  • “No other creatine form or diluent above the agreed limit.”

Five questions for the supplier

  1. Which form is this lot, and what CAS number appears on the certificate?
  2. May we see the HPLC chromatogram and the IR spectrum, not just the assay?
  3. What chloride result did titration give, and what is the pH of a defined solution?
  4. What are the creatine content and LOD, and how were both calculated?
  5. If a result is challenged, would you share a re-test of the retained sample?

Together those answers form an identity file; a single assay figure does not. Catalog figures are on the creatine HCl product page; the COA page shows where each figure sits; the grades page covers the physical choices; the level-four comparison sets the salt against the monohydrate. The monohydrate page shows the other form, the methods section explains the titration and HPLC, and the quality page describes release.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation