The regulatory file for creatine HCl
Creatine hydrochloride is a separate salt, not a variant name for creatine monohydrate. Its CAS number, counter-ion and creatine fraction differ, and the monohydrate's novel-food consultation and US history cannot simply be carried across. The destination route belongs to the buyer's regulatory team; this page sets out the evidence and checks that support it.
The hydrochloride is a separate salt with its own CAS number, counter-ion and regulatory file; the monohydrate's history does not automatically travel with it.
Four layers, one folder
A hydrochloride folder has four parts: the agreed specification, the lot release certificate, the destination's limits and labelling rules, and a change record for source, process and pack. The COA describes the lot, the technical data sheet carries the specification, and the SDS addresses handling. None of those settles the market route, which is recorded separately.
“Permitted” is not “approved”. Food-supplement ingredients do not receive a medicine-style pre-market authorisation in any of the markets below; the brand owner remains responsible for the finished product, and the supplier supplies evidence rather than permission. The notes reflect this review, and the current legal text governs.
European Union: the salt needs its own route
Directive 2002/46/EC sets the EU food-supplement framework, but Annexes I and II list vitamins, minerals and permitted forms; creatine is outside both. It therefore follows the national “other substance” route, where a member state may permit it under general food law and notification rules. The hydrochloride is a distinct salt, so the route must be checked for the form and the country. The UK is not one file either: Great Britain has its own supplement rules and claims register, while Northern Ireland applies the EU regime; the delivery address decides.
The Commission's novel-food consultation records the monohydrate as consumed before 15 May 1997, so that form is not novel. The conclusion belongs to the monohydrate, not to every creatine salt. Because the hydrochloride has a different CAS number and counter-ion, the EU novel-food catalogue must be searched for that exact form; if no entry covers it, the buyer's team must establish the route before launch.
Four instruments surround the route: Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 (general food law), Regulation (EU) 2023/915 (contaminants), Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 (food information) and Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 (claims). The annexes and the claims register are amended, so use the current consolidated text.
United States: a dietary supplement with a form question
Under DSHEA, creatine hydrochloride is sold as a dietary supplement. Manufacturing is subject to the cGMP regulation in 21 CFR 111, and the Supplement Facts panel declares the amount per serving with the other ingredients. Write the form out as creatine hydrochloride rather than “creatine”; the salt and the monohydrate are different label ingredients.
The monohydrate's long US marketing history does not settle the hydrochloride's position. A different form, source or process can raise a new-dietary-ingredient question, and a GRAS conclusion for the monohydrate covers that substance only. The supplier names the basis and its supporting document; the buyer checks that both reach the finished product and the claim.
Structure/function wording is allowed when it is truthful, not misleading and carries the disclaimer. Disease statements are outside that route. FDA does not clear the supplement or its label before sale; the firm that markets it does.
Contaminants, moisture and the counter-ion
The figures below are catalog release limits, not a replacement for the destination's legal limits. Where both exist, the lower one governs; where the law is silent, the specification supplies the number. The lot COA should give a result and a method for every line, not simply “conforms”.
| Line | Catalog gate | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Lead | ≤3 mg/kg | Measured per element on the lot COA |
| Arsenic | ≤2 mg/kg | No harmonised EU maximum; the catalog figure governs |
| Cadmium | ≤1 mg/kg | Measured per element on the lot COA |
| Mercury | ≤0.1 mg/kg | Measured per element on the lot COA |
| Loss on drying | ≤1.0% | Hygroscopic salt; release line and storage indicator |
| Microbial load | Aerobic plate count ≤1,000 cfu/g; yeast and mould ≤100 cfu/g; E. coli and Salmonella absent | Counts plus absence statements |
Chloride is not a contaminant here: it is the counter-ion, expected at about 21.2% for the 1:1 salt, and belongs with identity. Sodium is not part of the salt, so a sodium limit written for a sodium salt does not apply. The label arithmetic applies: a declared creatine mass is not the hydrochloride mass.
What the pack may say
The ingredient name is not a claim. “Creatine hydrochloride” describes the material; “more soluble” describes a physical property. “Absorbs better” or “works at a lower dose” is a claim and needs its own evidence and review. Solubility in a beaker does not establish absorption in a person.
In the EU and the UK, a claim must be authorised and used under its conditions, or it is unauthorised. For the US, structure/function wording requires substantiation and the DSHEA disclaimer; disease-related wording is not an option. No health claim is made on this page; the content is specification and documentation guidance.
Documents for the hydrochloride file
The folder should contain the records in the table. Each one should be in date and scoped to this product; a monohydrate certificate or a certificate for another grade cannot support the lot.
| Record | Evidence it carries | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Lot COA | Hydrochloride identity, salt and creatine figures, chloride, moisture, mesh, metals and micro | QC laboratory |
| Technical data sheet | Catalog limits, solubility, uses and pack | Supplier |
| Safety data sheet | Hazard, handling and transport information | Supplier |
| Agreed specification | Release limits and methods signed by both sides | Supplier and buyer |
| Allergen declaration | Allergen status and the basis for it | Manufacturer |
| GMO and BSE/TSE declarations | Raw-material and process status | Manufacturer |
| Origin and process flow | Site, route and lot traceability | Manufacturer |
| Audit and certification pack | Scope of the food-safety system | Certifier |
A collection of logos is not a document pack. Every record should be current, cover the site and name this product.
Six checks before the file is signed
- Does the specification name creatine hydrochloride, CAS 17050-09-8 and C4H9N3O2·HCl, and does the COA report the salt assay, creatine content, chloride, LOD and mesh?
- Are the contaminant results inside the destination's current limits, with methods stated?
- Does the file identify the manufacturing site, country of origin and process route?
- Are all certificates current and in scope, and does the label declare the hydrochloride with the creatine mass derived from the salt mass?
- Is every claim permitted for the destination and used within its terms, or a structure/function statement carrying the disclaimer?
- Does a retained sample exist, and is there a written procedure for a lot that fails?
Catalog figures are on the creatine HCl product page. The monohydrate's own file appears on its product page and compliance page. For the analytical work, see the methods section; for release, the quality page; for framework references, the EU regulatory notes.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation