02.1 Sodium vs calcium

Sodium caseinate vs calcium caseinate: the mineral load and the label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Sodium Caseinate

On this page
  1. One protein, two salts
  2. The mineral load side by side
  3. The protein figure does not separate them
  4. Solubility is the visible difference
  5. What the label has to say
  6. When to choose which

Sodium caseinate and calcium caseinate are the same casein neutralised with a different base. The protein is the same, at least 90.0% on a dry basis, but the cation changes the ash, the solubility, the behaviour in acid and heat, and the mineral the label has to declare. The switch is a formulation and label decision, not a like-for-like substitution.

In one line

Sodium and calcium caseinate carry the same casein with a different cation, so the switch moves the mineral load, the solubility and the label declaration together.

One protein, two salts

Both products start with acid casein. Skim milk is acidified to about pH 4.6, where the casein precipitates; the curd is washed and dried to acid casein. That intermediate is then neutralised — with sodium hydroxide for sodium caseinate, calcium hydroxide for calcium caseinate — and spray-dried. The cation used in the neutralisation is the cation that stays in the powder.

The two are separate materials with separate CAS numbers: sodium caseinate 9005-46-3 and calcium caseinate 9005-43-0. A certificate that says only “caseinate” has not named the salt, and a purchase order that says only “caseinate” has not specified one. The process is the ingredient name, and the label has to follow it.

The mineral load side by side

Sodium caseinate and calcium caseinate · what the cation changes
PointSodium caseinateCalcium caseinate
CAS number9005-46-39005-43-0
Neutralising baseSodium hydroxideCalcium hydroxide
Protein (dry basis)≥90.0%≥90.0%
Cation in the powderSodium 1.0–1.5%Calcium 1.0–1.5%
Ash≤4.0%≤4.0%
In waterFreely soluble; slightly turbidDispersible; opaque, slightly viscous
Label contributionSodium, then salt in the EUCalcium

The ash ceilings are the same, but the composition behind them differs. The cation is the part that moves the nutrition panel, and it is the first line to check when a form is in doubt. The two salts are compared from the specification side on the grades page.

The protein figure does not separate them

Both salts are specified at 90.0% protein on a dry basis by Kjeldahl with N × 6.38. At the 6.0% moisture ceiling, that is about 84.6% protein as weighed, and a 20 g serving supplies about 16.9 g of protein. The cation does not change the protein calculation; it changes the ash and the mineral line beside it.

The mass balance makes the point. A 20 g serving of sodium caseinate at 1.2% sodium carries about 240 mg of sodium; the same serving of calcium caseinate at 1.2% calcium carries about 240 mg of calcium. The protein is identical, the mineral is not. A buyer who compares only the protein percentage is comparing the part that the two products share.

Nor is calcium caseinate a calcium supplement. At 1.0–1.5% calcium, a 20 g serving supplies 200–300 mg, which is 15–23% of the US Daily Value of 1,300 mg. That is a real contribution to the label and to the formula, but it is not a stand-alone mineral dose and should not be presented as one.

Solubility is the visible difference

Sodium caseinate dissolves in water and gives a slightly turbid solution. It is the salt to start with when the formula needs a high solids load in a neutral drink, when the protein has to hydrate without a long hold, or when the caseinate is acting as an emulsifier. The solution is not clear, so a transparent drink still needs a trial rather than an assumption.

Calcium caseinate disperses rather than dissolving. The dispersion is opaque and slightly viscous, and it behaves differently from the sodium salt in a mixer and in a heat process. It is used where a colloidal body is wanted, where the calcium contribution is useful, or where the sodium load has to come down. The two are not interchangeable at the same solids load without a trial.

Both salts are casein, and both aggregate near pH 4.6, the isoelectric point. An acidified drink needs a stabiliser and a trial whichever salt is used. The cation changes the rate and the texture, not the fundamental pH behaviour. The methods section explains the dispersion and mineral tests that separate the two in a dispute.

What the label has to say

The ingredient declaration names the salt: sodium caseinate or calcium caseinate. The two names are not interchangeable, and a pack cannot use one while the drum contains the other. Milk has to be emphasised as the allergen in the EU and the UK and declared as a major allergen in the US, whichever salt is used; the cation does not change the milk status.

The mineral declaration is where the switch shows. In the EU, the mandatory nutrient is salt, calculated as sodium × 2.5: a 20 g serving at 1.0–1.5% sodium carries 500–750 mg of salt. In the US, sodium appears in mg and as a percentage of the 2,300 mg Daily Value, which is 9–13% for that serving. Calcium caseinate shifts the contribution to calcium: 200–300 mg per 20 g, or 15–23% of the 1,300 mg Daily Value.

“Dairy-free” is not available for either salt, because both are milk protein. A low lactose figure does not change that. Protein claims are assessed on the finished product: in the EU, “source of protein” needs 12% of the energy from protein and “high protein” 20%; in the US, the thresholds are 10% and 20% of the Daily Value. The compliance page sets out the market rules.

When to choose which

Choose sodium caseinate when solubility and a high solids load matter, when the formula can carry the sodium, and when the label names the sodium salt. Choose calcium caseinate when the calcium contribution is useful, when the sodium load has to come down, or when a colloidal dispersion suits the texture. Neither choice should be made on the protein percentage, because that line is the same.

A switch needs four checks before the order: the specification and CAS number, the mineral line, the trial in the real matrix, and the label artwork. The powder form, the particle size and the allergen statement should be confirmed at the same time. The catalogue specification for this salt is on the sodium caseinate product page; the other salt is on the calcium caseinate page; the release tests are on the COA page; the identity tests are on the identity page; and the quality page describes release.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation