06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a calcium caseinate lot is the calcium salt

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-20 · Calcium Caseinate

On this page
  1. Four layers of evidence
  2. The calcium-to-protein ratio
  3. What XRD can and cannot prove
  4. Where substitutions show up
  5. Specification lines for identity
  6. Five questions to ask

A calcium caseinate lot is the calcium salt when four lines agree: the document names the form and CAS number, the protein figure fits casein, the calcium figure is in range with sodium low, and the solid state and dispersion match the process. Protein alone cannot separate calcium caseinate from sodium caseinate or from micellar casein, because all three are milk proteins with a similar protein figure.

In one line

No single number proves the calcium salt: the protein figure, the calcium and sodium panel and the process record have to agree.

Four layers of evidence

Naming the right material on a certificate is not the same as proving it. Each layer below asks a separate question and needs its own evidence. An answer that stops at the first layer describes the paperwork, not the drum.

Four layers of calcium caseinate identity
LayerQuestionTestWhat it proves
DocumentIs the form and salt named?Name, CAS number, process statementPaperwork only
ProteinIs it casein?Kjeldahl with N × 6.38, protein profileThe protein family
CationIs it the calcium salt?Calcium and sodium by ICP-OESThe salt form
Solid state and performanceIs it a caseinate or a blend?XRD, FTIR, ash, dispersionConsistency of the powder

The layers are cumulative. A protein figure near 90% on a dry basis is consistent with either caseinate; the calcium and sodium figures decide which one. The process statement explains why the cation is there, and the solid-state work catches a powder that was blended rather than neutralised.

The calcium-to-protein ratio

Calcium caseinate is a neutralised polymer, not a molecule with a fixed formula. The calcium load depends on the neutralisation and the washing, so there is no theoretical percentage to calculate from a molecular weight, the way there is for a simple salt. The catalogue sets the calcium at 1.0–1.5% and the protein at ≥90.0% on a dry basis, which puts the calcium-to-protein ratio at roughly 12–18 mg of calcium per gram of protein.

That ratio is a consistency check, not an identity proof. A lot that reads 90% protein and 0.3% calcium is not the calcium salt at the declared load; a lot that reads 1.3% calcium and 75% protein has been diluted or carries extra calcium salt. Sodium is the second half of the check: a sodium figure near 1.0–1.5% beside a low calcium figure points to sodium caseinate, and a calcium figure with a higher ash and a native phosphorus level points toward a micellar grade.

Read the figures on the same basis. Protein is on a dry basis; ash and calcium are usually reported on the powder as weighed. At 6.0% moisture, 90.0% dry-basis protein is 84.6% as-is, so the calcium-to-protein ratio calculated from an as-is protein figure will be higher than the ratio calculated from the dry-basis figure. The certificate should state both bases, or the comparison is out by the moisture.

What XRD can and cannot prove

X-ray diffraction asks whether the solid is crystalline and whether its pattern matches a reference. Spray-dried calcium caseinate is amorphous, so its diffractogram is a broad halo rather than a set of sharp peaks. That is useful, because a crystalline calcium salt added to lift the calcium figure — calcium carbonate, calcium citrate or a crystalline calcium phosphate — produces sharp lines that the protein does not.

XRD neither assays purity nor measures the counter-ion. It cannot separate calcium caseinate from sodium caseinate, and it cannot quantify the protein. Ask for the reference pattern and the detection limit before reading a “match” statement, and read the result beside the calcium and sodium figures rather than instead of them. FTIR adds the protein amide bands and can show the difference between a protein powder and an inorganic blend; neither technique is a routine release test for this product.

Where substitutions show up

Common calcium caseinate substitutions and the signals
AdulterantWhat it doesSignalTest
Sodium caseinateSame protein, different cationSodium 1.0–1.5%; calcium lowCalcium and sodium by ICP-OES
Micellar caseinLower protein, native mineralsProtein near 80%; ash higherProtein, ash, calcium and phosphorus
Calcium carbonate or citrateLifts calcium without proteinSharp XRD lines; ash high; carbonate effervesces with acidXRD, ash, acid test
Whey proteinCheaper milk proteinProtein profile differs; amino acid pattern shiftsSDS-PAGE, amino acid profile
Starch or maltodextrinDilutes protein and calciumProtein low; carbohydrate by differenceProtein, mass balance, iodine for starch
Melamine or other non-protein nitrogenLifts Kjeldahl without proteinProtein high; amino acid profile lowLC-MS/MS screen, amino acid profile

Appearance is the weakest signal. The colour window is wide, and a blend can be made to match it. The stronger signals are the calcium and sodium figures, the ash, the XRD pattern and the amino acid profile. A certificate that reports appearance and protein but not the cation has left the most likely substitution untested.

Specification lines for identity

  • “Calcium caseinate, CAS 9005-43-0, produced by neutralising acid casein with calcium hydroxide and spray-drying.”
  • “Protein ≥90.0% on a dry basis by Kjeldahl with N × 6.38; state the factor and the basis.”
  • “Calcium 1.0–1.5% as elemental calcium by ICP-OES or titration; report the method.”
  • “Sodium by ICP-OES as an identity check; agree a limit if the salt form is disputed.”
  • “Moisture ≤6.0%, ash ≤4.0%, fat ≤1.5%; ≥95% through 80 mesh or the instantized equivalent.”
  • “No crystalline calcium salt above the agreed limit; milk allergen declared.”

Five questions to ask

  1. Which salt is this lot, and which CAS number is on the certificate?
  2. What are the protein result, the nitrogen factor and the basis?
  3. What are the calcium and sodium results, and which method produced them?
  4. Was the lot made from acid casein neutralised with calcium hydroxide, and can the process record be shown?
  5. If the lot is disputed, will you accept a joint re-test on the retained sample, including XRD and the mineral panel?

Those five answers, taken together, make an identity file. A protein percentage alone does not. The product hub carries the catalogue specification; the COA page shows where each figure sits on the certificate; the grades page compares the three casein forms; the calcium versus micellar page covers the label consequences; the sodium caseinate page gives the other salt; the micellar casein page gives the native-micelle alternative; the methods section explains the techniques, and the quality page describes release.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation