06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a zinc lot is zinc malate

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Zinc Malate

On this page
  1. The four identity layers
  2. The 1:1 ratio and the mass balance
  3. X-ray diffraction and the phase question
  4. What substitution looks like
  5. How to write identity into the specification
  6. Five questions for a supplier

A zinc malate lot is the malate only when the anion and the element agree. Infrared and HPLC identify the malate, complexometric titration gives 32.0–34.0% zinc, and the 1:1 ratio closes the mass balance. The zinc figure alone cannot prove the salt: zinc citrate carries almost the same percentage of zinc, and a blend can be built to land inside the range.

In one line

Zinc malate is proved by the malate anion and the zinc figure together; the element alone cannot separate the salt from a citrate or a blend.

The four identity layers

Identity is not one test. A certificate can carry the correct name and still say nothing about the powder. Each question below needs its own evidence, and the four layers read in order.

Four layers of zinc malate identity
LayerQuestionTestWhat it proves
DocumentIs the salt named?Name, CAS 2847-05-4, formulaPaperwork only
AnionIs the anion malate?Infrared spectrum and HPLC retentionThe malate, not the metal
ElementHow much zinc is present?Complexometric EDTA titrationThe zinc figure, from any source
Mass balanceDo the numbers describe one salt?Assay, zinc, loss on dryingConsistency of the results

Layer four is the one buyers skip. A zinc result inside 32.0–34.0% and an assay inside 98.0–102.0% look like a pass, but they can come from different powders if the ratio between them is wrong. It costs nothing to run on the certificate.

The 1:1 ratio and the mass balance

Zinc malate is a 1:1 salt of the divalent zinc ion and the divalent malate ion, C4H4O5Zn, with a formula weight of about 197.45. Zinc is 65.38 of that mass, or 33.1%; the malate is the remaining 66.9%. The mass ratio of malate to zinc is therefore about 2.02 to 1.

The check runs two ways. Divide the zinc result by the assay and compare it with 0.331: a lot at 99.0% assay should carry about 32.8% zinc. Or divide zinc by malate and compare with 0.495. A zinc figure above the ratio points to a denser zinc source, and zinc oxide at 78.0–80.0% is the obvious one. A figure below the ratio points to a carrier, to a zinc salt with a lower fraction such as the gluconate, or to excess malic acid that raises the assay without adding zinc. None of those conclusions replaces the anion test; the ratio tells the reviewer where to look next.

The loss on drying closes the balance. At ≤2.0% the moisture allowance is small, so the as-is and dried-basis figures sit close together. If the hydrate state is declared, it changes the formula weight and the expected zinc figure, and the specification has to carry it. Do not compare a zinc result from a hydrate with a ratio calculated for the anhydrous formula.

X-ray diffraction and the phase question

X-ray diffraction answers a different question from the assay: which crystalline phases are present in the solid. For zinc malate it detects crystalline zinc oxide, which is the most likely high-zinc contaminant, and it can compare the salt's pattern with a reference from another source. It does not measure purity, and it does not measure the counter-ion. A “match” statement without the reference pattern and the detection limit has added little to the file.

XRD is not a routine release test here. Order it for a new source, a suspected second zinc source, a solid-state dispute or a form claim that the certificate does not prove. Ask for the sample preparation, the reference used and the limit of detection for crystalline oxide, because a “not detected” line without that limit describes the method rather than the drum.

Infrared is the routine anion check and XRD is the phase check; they are complementary. A lot can show the malate bands by infrared and still contain a crystalline oxide phase that the infrared does not resolve at low concentration.

What substitution looks like

Zinc malate substitutions and the signals that expose them
Substitution routeWhat shiftsTest that catches it
Zinc oxide addedZinc climbs toward 78–80%; assay slips; pH movesZinc-to-assay ratio; XRD for crystalline oxide
Zinc citrate substitutedZinc stays near 32%; the anion changesInfrared and HPLC malate identity
Zinc gluconate blended inZinc drops toward 14%; solubility changesZinc figure; infrared; HPLC
Excess malic acidAssay rises; zinc falls; ratio drops; pH fallsRatio; pH; quantitative malate
Carrier dilutionAssay and zinc fall togetherMass balance; loss on drying; residue
MoistureAs-is assay falls; loss on drying risesLoss on drying; dried-basis calculation

The citrate route is the one that catches buyers out. Zinc citrate dihydrate is specified at 31.0–32.5% zinc on the dried basis, so a citrate lot can sit inside the zinc range of a malate specification. The element does not distinguish them. The malate bands in the infrared spectrum and the malate retention in the HPLC method do; the anion test is therefore not optional.

Zinc oxide is the opposite case: it is easy to see in the zinc figure because it is so concentrated, and easy to confirm by diffraction. The blend route is the quiet one, because a formulator can dilute the salt with a carrier and keep both the assay and the zinc figure inside the range if the carrier is chosen carefully.

How to write identity into the specification

  • “Zinc malate, CAS 2847-05-4, C4H4O5Zn; hydrate state named if one is declared.”
  • “Assay 98.0–102.0% by HPLC; zinc 32.0–34.0% by complexometric titration; basis and method stated.”
  • “Identification by infrared spectrum and HPLC retention against a named reference.”
  • “Loss on drying ≤2.0%; the as-is and dried-basis results both reported.”
  • “No added zinc oxide, zinc citrate, zinc gluconate, malic acid or undeclared carrier.”
  • “Lot number, manufacturing site and specification version on the certificate.”

The prohibitions carry as much weight as the positive ranges. A zinc range does not exclude a second zinc source, and a supplier cannot be held to a restriction the specification never states. Name the reference in the specification; “conforms” against an unnamed reference cannot be repeated.

Five questions for a supplier

  1. Can you provide the infrared spectrum and the HPLC chromatogram, not only the assay percentage?
  2. What zinc result and basis belong to this lot, and which titration method was used?
  3. Do the assay, zinc and loss on drying close the 1:1 mass balance, and what is the calculated zinc-to-malate ratio?
  4. Does the lot contain anything beyond the salt — oxide, citrate, gluconate, malic acid or a carrier?
  5. Will you supply an XRD screen for crystalline zinc oxide and a retained sample if the lot is disputed?

Five specific answers amount to an identity file; one assay percentage does not. Start at the zinc malate hub for the catalog line, then use the COA page to see where each figure sits on the certificate and the grades page for the physical variants. The malate versus citrate comparison explains why the zinc figure alone cannot separate the two salts; the FTIR and XRD notes describe the methods.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation