02.1 Malate vs citrate

Zinc malate vs zinc citrate: elemental zinc, solubility and the fill

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Zinc Malate

On this page
  1. Two salts, two identities
  2. Elemental zinc and the fill
  3. Water, acid and the taste
  4. Moisture, flow and the dry blend
  5. What the label and the market file have to say
  6. When to choose which

Zinc malate and zinc citrate deliver nearly the same zinc per gram: about 33.1% theoretical for the malate, against a catalog range of 31.0–32.5% for the citrate dihydrate on the dried basis. A 10 mg zinc claim therefore needs about 30 mg of either salt, so the fill moves by a milligram or two, not by a reformulation. The differences that decide the choice are the moisture limit, the behaviour in an acidic matrix, the taste and the salt name the destination file covers.

In one line

The two salts deliver about 33% and 32% zinc, so the fill moves by a few milligrams; what really differs is moisture, acid solubility and the label.

Two salts, two identities

Both are zinc salts of a food acid and both are white powders at 40 mesh. They are not interchangeable: the anion is most of the mass and carries the chemistry, the taste and the label name. Zinc malate is the 1:1 salt with malic acid; zinc citrate is the 3:2 salt with citric acid, supplied as the dihydrate.

Zinc malate and zinc citrate dihydrate · the catalog figures
PropertyZinc malateZinc citrate dihydrate
CAS number2847-05-45990-32-9
FormulaC4H4O5ZnZn3(C6H5O7)2·2H2O
Formula weightAbout 197.45About 610
Zinc, theoretical33.1%About 32% on the dihydrate
Zinc, catalog32.0–34.0%31.0–32.5% on the dried basis
Loss on drying≤2.0%≤6.0%
Water solubilitySlightly soluble; more soluble in acidSlightly soluble; buffered suspension
pH of a 5% systemMeasured for the lot; no catalog range5.0–7.0 for a 5% suspension
Particle size≥95% through 40 mesh≥95% through 40 mesh

The zinc lines are close enough that the salt name, not the percentage, separates them.

Elemental zinc and the fill

The label declares the element, and the capsule holds the salt. At the catalog midpoints — 33.0% for the malate and 31.75% for the citrate — the arithmetic is short. The fill table below uses those midpoints and rounds to one decimal place; a real lot uses its own certificate result.

Salt mass needed for a zinc claim · malate at 33.0%, citrate at 31.75%
Zinc claimZinc malateZinc citrate dihydrateDifference
5 mg15.2 mg15.7 mg0.5 mg
10 mg30.3 mg31.5 mg1.2 mg
15 mg45.5 mg47.2 mg1.8 mg
25 mg75.8 mg78.7 mg3.0 mg
50 mg151.5 mg157.5 mg6.0 mg

Six milligrams on a 50 mg claim is about 4% of the salt mass — real in a full tablet or a fixed-weight stick pack, but not a reason to choose a salt in an ordinary 10–15 mg capsule, where both fills fit.

The basis has to match before the table is used. The citrate figure is stated on the dried basis; the malate catalog line does not state a basis, so the certificate has to. On an as-is basis the citrate loses more to its two waters of crystallisation, which sit inside the ≤6.0% drying limit, so the as-is gap is wider than the dried-basis gap. Convert first, then compare, then weigh.

Water, acid and the taste

Both salts are described as slightly soluble in water, which is a statement about a concentrated system, not about a drink. At a 10 mg zinc serving the salt mass is about 30 mg; in 250 mL that is dilute, and the practical question is the pH and the taste rather than the saturation point. The malate dissolves more readily as the matrix becomes more acidic. The citrate is also more soluble in acid, but it brings a citrate buffer that resists the pH change the acidulant is trying to make.

That difference shows up in an acidic stick pack or a fruit drink. Malic acid is the sharper acidulant, and the malate adds to the sour rather than buffering it; the citrate softens the profile and holds the pH steadier.

In a neutral, clear drink neither salt is the natural answer: the gluconate is the freely soluble option, at about twice the mass per milligram of zinc. In an opaque suspension the citrate's buffered dispersion is easier to keep uniform. A bench trial at the real pH settles it faster than a solubility table.

Moisture, flow and the dry blend

The drying limits look far apart, ≤2.0% for the malate and ≤6.0% for the citrate, but they measure different things. Most of the citrate allowance is its two waters of crystallisation, about 5.9% of the dihydrate; the malate line is free moisture. Compare free-moisture headroom and the release result, not the headline.

Free moisture decides flow, caking and blend stability. A powder released near its limit has little room for plant humidity, and the malate's lower free-moisture allowance is a useful margin in a humid plant or a long hold. It is not a licence to leave the pouch open.

What the label and the market file have to say

The label names the salt and the elemental zinc. A US Supplement Facts panel declares the dietary ingredient by name, so “zinc” alone does not say which salt was weighed. In the European Union the permitted supplement forms are listed by form, so an entry for one zinc salt does not cover another; the buyer's team confirms the route, and the file has to match the salt on the pack. Great Britain and Northern Ireland are checked separately.

The market file is attached to the salt, not to the element. A formula qualified on zinc citrate cannot switch to zinc malate and keep the same label, notification or supporting document without a review. The label zinc figure, the salt name and the specification have to agree, and the COA has to describe the lot shipped.

When to choose which

Choose the malate for a capsule or tablet that wants a moderate zinc figure, a low free-moisture allowance and an anion that behaves well in an acidic matrix. It is also the simpler choice when the label already names zinc malate and the market file has been built around it. Choose the citrate when the formula is built on a citrate buffer, when the existing qualification and stability data belong to the citrate, or when the taste profile calls for a softer acid.

Choose neither for a clear, neutral drink at a meaningful zinc dose; the gluconate is the soluble option there. Choose the oxide only when the tablet is short of mass and the formulator accepts that it is practically insoluble. A switch in either direction is a change control: a new specification, a new certificate review, a matrix trial and a label check. The zinc malate hub carries the catalog line; the zinc citrate page gives the other salt; the magnesium malate page shows the same anion with a different element; the methods library covers the assays; the quality page describes release.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation