Tricalcium phosphate vs dicalcium phosphate: the Ca/P ratio and the label
Tricalcium phosphate and dicalcium phosphate differ in the calcium-to-phosphorus ratio before anything else: 1.5 mol Ca per mol P against 1.0, and 1.94 against 1.29 by mass. That ratio sets how much calcium and phosphorus arrives per gram, how large the tablet or capsule has to be, and which name and E-number the label carries. The two are separate salts with separate specifications, not two grades of one product.
The molar calcium-to-phosphorus ratio is 1.5 for tricalcium phosphate and 1.0 for dicalcium phosphate, and that difference sets the elemental calcium, the phosphorus load and the name on the label.
Two formulas, two ratios
The formula sets the ratio; the supplier and the certificate only report it. One mole of Ca₃(PO₄)₂ carries three moles of calcium and two of phosphorus, which is 1.5 to one. One mole of CaHPO₄ carries one of each, which is 1.0 to one. Expressed by mass the figures are 1.94 and 1.29, because calcium and phosphorus have different atomic weights.
The theoretical contents follow from the same arithmetic. Tricalcium phosphate is 38.76% calcium and 19.97% phosphorus; dicalcium phosphate is 29.46% calcium and 22.76% phosphorus. The catalog windows sit around those figures: 34.0–40.0% calcium and 18.0–20.0% phosphorus for tricalcium phosphate, and 29.0–30.0% calcium and 22.0–23.5% phosphorus for the anhydrous dicalcium salt.
The ratio is the fastest check on a certificate. The tricalcium window is wide, and its independent lines allow a molar ratio anywhere from about 1.31 to about 1.72; a stoichiometric lot sits at 1.50. The dicalcium window is narrow, and its ratio stays at about 1.0. A certificate that reports 38% calcium and 15% phosphorus has put the calcium of one salt against the phosphorus of another.
The salts behind the names
Tricalcium phosphate is CAS 7758-87-4, Ca₃(PO₄)₂, molecular weight 310.18. Dicalcium phosphate is CAS 7757-93-9, CaHPO₄, molecular weight 136.06. The dicalcium salt also exists as a dihydrate, CAS 7789-77-7, which carries about 21% water and drops to 23.29% calcium and 18.00% phosphorus per gram; its molar ratio is still 1.0. A label that says only “dicalcium phosphate” leaves the hydrate, and therefore the calcium per gram, unspecified.
The generic name “calcium phosphate” is ambiguous in both markets. In the EU the additive entries are split into E 341(i) monocalcium, E 341(ii) dicalcium and E 341(iii) tricalcium phosphate. In the US, 21 CFR 182.1217 lists calcium phosphate for the mono-, di- and tribasic forms as one GRAS family, so the ingredient statement still has to name the salt in the pack.
What the ratio does to the dose
| Measure | Tricalcium phosphate | Dicalcium phosphate |
|---|---|---|
| Calcium per gram | About 388 mg | About 295 mg |
| Phosphorus per gram | About 200 mg | About 228 mg |
| Ca : P by mass | 1.94 | 1.29 |
| Ca : P by mole | 1.5 | 1.0 |
| Powder for 600 mg calcium | About 1.55 g | About 2.04 g |
| Phosphorus at that dose | About 309 mg | About 463 mg |
The calcium figure is what the label declares, so the compactness argument belongs to tricalcium phosphate. A 600 mg calcium claim needs about 1.55 g of it, against about 2.04 g of the dicalcium salt, which is roughly a quarter less powder for the same element. At 1.55 g the fill is two or three large capsules or one large tablet; at 2.04 g it is three or four capsules.
The phosphorus moves the other way. For the same calcium claim, tricalcium phosphate brings about two-thirds of the phosphorus that dicalcium phosphate brings. If the formula already carries phosphorus from another source, or if the panel declares a phosphorus figure, that gap is a formulation constraint and not a rounding difference.
What the label has to say
| Label question | Tricalcium phosphate | Dicalcium phosphate |
|---|---|---|
| EU additive entry | E 341(iii) | E 341(ii) |
| US ingredient statement | Tricalcium phosphate | Dicalcium phosphate, hydrate stated |
| Salt for 600 mg calcium | About 1.55 g | About 2.04 g |
| Phosphorus at 600 mg calcium | About 309 mg: 44% EU NRV, 25% US DV | About 463 mg: 66% EU NRV, 37% US DV |
| Calcium declaration | Elemental calcium | Elemental calcium |
The panel declares elemental calcium, not the weight of the salt; the ingredient statement names the salt. Confusing the two is a large error, because the salt-to-element factor is about 2.58 for tricalcium phosphate and about 3.39 for the anhydrous dicalcium salt. The reference figures behind the percentages are 800 mg calcium and 700 mg phosphorus in the EU, and 1,300 mg calcium and 1,250 mg phosphorus in the US.
The salt name is also the market entry. The EU additive specification for E 341(iii) describes a variable mixture of calcium phosphates, and the E 341(ii) entry is a separate specification; the two are not interchangeable on a label or in a customer's file. In the US, the GRAS family listing covers the forms, but the specific ingredient name is still what the reviewer and the consumer read.
What changes when the salt changes
A switch is not a gram-for-gram substitution. To keep a 600 mg calcium claim, replace about 2.04 g of dicalcium phosphate with about 1.55 g of tricalcium phosphate. The phosphorus falls from about 463 mg to about 309 mg, the tablet or capsule count falls, the acid solubility and the mouthfeel change, and the ingredient statement and the E-number change with them.
Three documents reopen at the same time: the specification, because the calcium and phosphorus lines and the ratio window are different; the label, because the ingredient name and possibly the phosphorus declaration change; and the stability file, because the tablet hardness, the disintegration and the taste are properties of the new salt. A formula that has already been through a press trial should not be switched on a certificate alone.
When to choose which
Choose tricalcium phosphate when the claim needs more calcium per gram, when the phosphorus load has to be lower for the same calcium, or when the powder is also acting as a diluent in a compact tablet. Choose dicalcium phosphate when the formula wants a 1 : 1 calcium-to-phosphorus ratio, a direct-compression diluent, or a salt that reacts more readily in an acidic matrix, and when the label already names it.
Choose neither for a clear solution: both are practically insoluble in water and dissolve only by reacting with acid. Calcium citrate or calcium lactate is the practical starting point for a clear drink, and calcium carbonate is the compact alternative when its acid reaction is acceptable.
The tricalcium phosphate product page carries the catalog figures; the dicalcium phosphate page carries the neighbouring salt; the tricalcium grade page covers the phase and the particle form; the methods index describes the assays; the quality page sets out the release workflow.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation