02.1 Dicalcium vs tricalcium

Dicalcium phosphate vs tricalcium phosphate: the Ca : P ratio and the fill

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Dicalcium Phosphate

On this page
  1. Two formulas, two ratios
  2. Solubility and the acid reaction
  3. Which one fills the tablet
  4. The dose arithmetic
  5. What the label names
  6. When to choose each

Dicalcium phosphate (CaHPO₄) carries one calcium per phosphorus: 29.46% calcium and 22.76% phosphorus by formula, a mass ratio of 1.29 : 1. Tricalcium phosphate (Ca₃(PO₄)₂) carries three calcium per two phosphorus: 38.76% calcium and 19.97% phosphorus, a mass ratio of 1.94 : 1. The ratio changes the tablet weight, the phosphorus that arrives with each milligram of calcium, and the name on the label.

In one line

The two salts differ by the Ca : P ratio before they differ by anything else: dicalcium phosphate is 1.29 : 1 by mass, tricalcium phosphate 1.94 : 1, and the difference sets the dose and the fill.

Two formulas, two ratios

The ratio is fixed by the formula, not by the supplier. One mole of dicalcium phosphate contains one mole of calcium and one mole of phosphorus; one mole of tricalcium phosphate contains three moles of calcium and two of phosphorus. Expressed as mass, the first is 1.29 parts calcium to one part phosphorus and the second is 1.94 to one. That is the whole difference in chemistry, and it drives every practical consequence below.

Dicalcium and tricalcium phosphate by formula
PropertyDicalcium phosphateTricalcium phosphate
FormulaCaHPO₄Ca₃(PO₄)₂
CAS number7757-93-9, anhydrous7758-87-4
Calcium29.46%38.76%
Phosphorus22.76%19.97%
Ca : P by mass1.29 : 11.94 : 1
Ca : P by mole1 : 11.5 : 1
Phosphorus per 1,000 mg calciumAbout 773 mgAbout 515 mg

The catalog figures follow the formula. Dicalcium phosphate is specified at 29.0–30.0% calcium and 22.0–23.5% phosphorus; a tricalcium phosphate specification sits near 38–40% calcium and 19–20% phosphorus. A certificate that reports 38% calcium against a dicalcium specification has not passed the wrong test — it has described a different salt.

Solubility and the acid reaction

Both salts are practically insoluble in water, so neither will give a clear drink at neutral pH. Both dissolve in dilute acid, but dicalcium phosphate is the more acid-soluble of the two and reacts at a lower acid strength. In an acidic matrix, such as a ready-to-drink with a low pH or an effervescent granule, the dicalcium salt goes into solution more readily; the tricalcium salt leaves more of the powder undissolved and more grit in the mouth.

Solubility is not the same as absorbability, and this page makes no claim about either. The point is physical: a formula that must be clear, or must react quickly with an acid, is asking for a salt that dissolves, and neither of these is a good choice for a clear solution. The alternative is a soluble salt such as calcium citrate or calcium lactate, and the acid reaction of calcium carbonate is the other reference point.

Which one fills the tablet

Dicalcium phosphate is a standard direct-compression diluent. It flows, it compacts and it carries a calcium figure at the same time, which is why it appears in tablets that need bulk as well as a mineral. The anhydrous grade is the better base for a moisture-sensitive tablet; the dihydrate carries water that heat can release.

Tricalcium phosphate carries more calcium per gram, so a tablet that has to deliver a high calcium dose in a small unit needs less of it. It is also used as a filler and an anti-caking aid in its own right. The choice between them is therefore a balance of three numbers: the calcium claim, the phosphorus that comes with it, and the mass the tablet can carry. A formulator who picks on calcium content alone will discover the phosphorus figure after the label is written.

The dose arithmetic

A 500 mg calcium dose needs 1.70 g of dicalcium phosphate or 1.29 g of tricalcium phosphate. The first brings about 386 mg of phosphorus; the second brings about 258 mg. At a 1,000 mg calcium dose the masses are 3.39 g and 2.58 g, and the phosphorus figures are about 773 mg and 515 mg. The gap is 258 mg of phosphorus at the same calcium claim, which is large enough to matter when the rest of the diet is counted.

Salt mass and phosphorus at three calcium doses
Calcium doseDicalcium phosphatePhosphorus from itTricalcium phosphatePhosphorus from it
250 mg0.85 g193 mg0.65 g129 mg
500 mg1.70 g386 mg1.29 g258 mg
1,000 mg3.39 g773 mg2.58 g515 mg

For context, the US Institute of Medicine set a tolerable upper intake level for phosphorus of 4,000 mg per day for adults aged 19–70. A 1,000 mg calcium dose from dicalcium phosphate supplies about 19% of that figure; the same dose from tricalcium phosphate supplies about 13%. The phosphorus is not a reason to avoid either salt, but it is a reason to declare the salt and to count the whole formula.

What the label names

In the European Union the two salts have separate additive entries: E 341(ii) for dicalcium phosphate and E 341(iii) for tricalcium phosphate. The additive specification for the dicalcium entry sets the assay at 98–102% of CaHPO₄ after drying at 200 °C for three hours, and the two entries are not interchangeable on a label.

In the United States, 21 CFR 182.1217 covers calcium phosphate as the mono-, di- and tribasic forms under one GRAS listing, but the ingredient statement still has to name the salt that is in the product. “Calcium phosphate” alone leaves the reader, and the reviewer, unable to tell which ratio was used. The nutrient panel declares elemental calcium; phosphorus is a separate figure and should be declared when the formula supplies a meaningful amount.

The hydrate belongs on the label too. Anhydrous and dihydrate dicalcium phosphate give different calcium per gram, and the ingredient name that does not name the hydrate is incomplete for a dosage calculation.

When to choose each

Choose dicalcium phosphate when the formula wants a calcium-to-phosphorus ratio near 1.3 : 1, a direct-compression filler that also carries a mineral, or a calcium salt that dissolves more readily in an acidic matrix. Choose tricalcium phosphate when the claim needs more calcium per gram, when the phosphorus load has to be lower for the same calcium figure, or when a granulation with a higher calcium load per gram is needed for a small tablet.

Choose neither when the product must be a clear solution, and choose neither on the assumption that the two can be swapped gram for gram: they cannot, because the calcium and phosphorus figures move together in opposite directions. The dicalcium phosphate product page carries the catalog specification; the grade page covers the hydrate choice; the COA page shows how the two elemental lines are reported; the compliance page covers the market file; the calcium carbonate page and the calcium citrate page are the other two calcium references; the methods index describes the assays.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation