01 COA & batch testing

Reading a calcium malate COA: calcium, malate and water

Technical document 01 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Calcium Malate

On this page
  1. The certificate as a test report
  2. Calcium, malate and the water in the balance
  3. Release limit versus batch result
  4. What moves between batches
  5. When to order an outside test
  6. What to compare between suppliers

A calcium malate certificate reports appearance, identification by infrared spectrum and HPLC, assay by HPLC at 98.0–102.0%, calcium by complexometric titration at 22.0–24.0%, loss on drying at not more than 2.0%, the heavy-metal panel, microbiology and particle size. The calcium and malate results are two views of the same salt, and the pair is the quickest check that the lot is the neutral salt rather than a blend. The limits below are the catalog specification; the batch COA is the document that confirms a particular pack.

In one line

The calcium figure and the malate figure have to agree: a titration near 23% calcium and an HPLC malate result are two views of one salt, and the moisture line explains the difference.

The certificate as a test report

A certificate can be audited when each row carries three things: the parameter, the method that produced the number, and the limit the lot was released against. “Conforms” is a conclusion, and it is the right answer only where the test is comparative. Calcium, malate, moisture and particle size are measured against windows, so each needs a number and a method.

Release tests for calcium malate
ParameterMethodRelease limit
AppearanceVisualWhite to off-white powder
IdentificationInfrared spectrum and HPLC retentionConforms to the reference
Assay (calcium malate)HPLC98.0–102.0%
Calcium (Ca)Complexometric titration22.0–24.0%
Loss on dryingGravimetric≤2.0%
Heavy metalsICP-MSPb ≤3 · As ≤2 · Cd ≤1 · Hg ≤0.1 mg/kg
MicrobiologyPlate count and absence testsAPC ≤1,000 cfu/g; yeast and mould ≤100 cfu/g; E. coli and Salmonella absent
Particle sizeSieve analysis≥95% through 40 mesh

Calcium, malate and the water in the balance

The neutral salt has the formula C4H4CaO5 and a formula weight of 172.15. Calcium is 40.08 ÷ 172.15 = 23.28% of that mass, and the malate dianion is the other 76.72%. The catalog calcium window of 22.0–24.0% brackets the theoretical figure, which is what a buyer should expect from a neutral calcium malate and not from a carbonate, a citrate or a dilution.

The two windows overlap but do not coincide. An assay of 98.0% corresponds to 22.8% calcium, and 102.0% corresponds to 23.75%. A certificate that reports 22.0% calcium beside 102% assay is describing two different powders, or a calculation error. Read the pair as a ratio check before accepting either figure on its own.

Basis is the second arithmetic. A result reported on the dried basis is higher than the as-is result by the moisture factor: at 1.0% loss on drying, 99.0% as-is becomes 100.0% on the dried basis. The certificate should say which basis the assay uses, and the loss on drying should sit beside it as a measured figure. A range printed without a basis is not a specification a laboratory can reproduce.

Name the HPLC column, mobile phase, detection mode and standard, and the titration indicator. A method described only as “HPLC” or “titration” cannot be compared between laboratories.

Release limit versus batch result

The release limit is the acceptance boundary. The batch result is what the laboratory measured on the lot. Both belong on the certificate in separate columns, with the method and the basis next to them. A result column filled with the specification range is a copy of the gate, not evidence about the powder.

What the result column should contain
ParameterRelease limitResult column
Assay98.0–102.0%A measured percentage, with the basis and the HPLC method
Calcium22.0–24.0%A measured percentage, with the titration method
Loss on drying≤2.0%A measured percentage and the drying condition
Heavy metalsPer elementA figure in mg/kg for each element
MicrobiologyCounts and absenceThe count and the absence statement for the lot

“Passes specification” is a conclusion the reader should be able to reach from the numbers. For microbiology the evidence is a count plus an absence statement; for heavy metals it is a figure per element, not a single total. A certificate that reports a sum of heavy metals has hidden the element that matters.

Read calcium against assay one more time before release. Calcium high with assay low points to a calcium-rich impurity such as carbonate or oxide; calcium low with assay normal points to water or a carrier. Either pattern is a question for the supplier, not a marginal pass.

What moves between batches

The salt is made by neutralising malic acid with a calcium source, then crystallising, drying and milling. The calcium source moves residual acidity and colour; crystallisation and drying move loss on drying; milling and sieving move the particle-size result, which is a finishing specification.

Calcium and loss on drying move in opposite directions when drying changes: a harder-dried lot loses surface water, so as-is calcium rises while the dried-basis assay barely moves. Show both figures so the reader can tell a moisture change from a potency change.

Colour is the least quantitative line: white to off-white covers a wide window, and a cream tint can follow the calcium source while the assay passes. A trend across lots says more than one result near an edge.

When to order an outside test

Order an independent test for a new source, a first shipment into a regulated market, a disputed salt form, or a certificate whose calcium and assay figures do not reconcile. The useful panel is targeted: calcium by complexometric titration, malate by HPLC, loss on drying, ICP-MS for the heavy-metal panel, and an acid test or X-ray diffraction if a carbonate is suspected.

The acid test is simple and revealing. A few milligrams of powder in dilute acid give bubbles if a carbonate is present and no bubbles if the powder is calcium malate. It is a screening test, not a replacement for the anion assay, but it catches the simplest substitution quickly.

Ask for the detection limit behind each screen; “not detected” without a limit describes the method, not the sample. The sample tested should be the retained sample, and the report should identify the lot.

What to compare between suppliers

Put six lines side by side: name, formula and CAS number; calcium result and method; assay result and basis; loss on drying; identification method; and the contaminant and microbiology panel. Two quotations that agree on calcium but differ on formula or basis are not describing the same powder.

Traceability is the second layer: the certificate should name the manufacturer, the lot and the pack, and the lot code should match the pouch, the drum and the retained sample.

The catalog figures are on the calcium malate product page. The tests that separate the salt from a blend are on the identity page; the grade and mesh choices are on the grade page; the destination rules are on the compliance page. The titration itself is described in the complexometric method note, and the release workflow is on the quality page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation