06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a calcium citrate lot is the citrate

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-18 · Calcium Citrate

On this page
  1. Four layers of proof
  2. The calcium-to-citrate ratio
  3. IR, XRD and the crystalline form
  4. The three common adulterants
  5. How to write the specification
  6. Five questions for the supplier

Four tests stand between a drum and the claim that it is calcium citrate: appearance and solubility, calcium by complexometric EDTA, citrate identity by reaction and infrared spectrum, and water of crystallisation by loss on drying. A calcium result near 21% is necessary but not sufficient, because calcium carbonate at about 40% and calcium oxide at about 71% would also titrate. The citrate and water results are what separate the salt from the other calcium powders.

In one line

Calcium proves the element, not the salt; citrate identity, water of crystallisation and a contaminant screen prove the material.

Four layers of proof

The four identity layers for calcium citrate
LayerTestWhat it showsWhat it misses
Appearance and solubilityVisual; water and dilute acidWhite powder, sparingly soluble in water, soluble in acidSays little about the anion
CalciumComplexometric EDTA21.0–22.0% CaAny calcium salt titrates
Citrate identityReaction and infrared spectrumCitrate present; spectrum matches referenceReaction alone is a screen
WaterLoss on drying at 150 °C10–13% for the tetrahydrateCovers surface moisture too

Run the four in that order. The calcium figure tells you which family of salts is plausible; the citrate test tells you whether the anion is there; the water figure tells you whether the hydrate is the one on the label. A contaminant screen sits beside them: ICP-MS for the heavy metals and XRD for crystalline carbonate or oxide.

The calcium-to-citrate ratio

The tetrahydrate has a fixed 3:2 calcium-to-citrate ratio. Three calcium ions balance two citrate anions, and the formula is C12H10Ca3O14·4H2O. On a mass basis that is about 21.1% calcium and 66.3% citrate ion, with 12.6% water. The molar ratio, 1.5 calcium per citrate, is the arithmetic that ties the two assays together.

If a lot reports 21.5% calcium and 66.3% citrate, convert both to moles per 100 g: calcium 21.5 ÷ 40.078 = 0.537 mol, citrate 66.3 ÷ 189.1 = 0.351 mol, ratio 1.53. A ratio near 1.5 is consistent with the salt. A high calcium with low citrate points to carbonate or oxide; a low calcium with high citrate points to added citric acid. A ratio below 1.5 with normal calcium points to added citrate; a ratio above 1.5 with normal calcium points to a calcium salt that is not citrate.

The citrate figure is not always on a routine certificate, which reports identification rather than a quantitative citrate assay. If the ratio is part of the purchase decision, ask for citrate by HPLC or titration and state the method. Without it, the identity rests on the reaction and the IR, which prove presence but not proportion.

IR, XRD and the crystalline form

Infrared spectroscopy reads the functional groups. A citrate spectrum shows carboxylate stretching in the 1,600–1,400 cm⁻¹ region and the O–H envelope of the hydrate, and the lot spectrum is compared with a reference standard. The comparison is the confirmatory step; a visual match on a printout is not enough.

X-ray diffraction reads the crystal. The tetrahydrate has its own pattern, and the scan can also show crystalline calcium carbonate as calcite or calcium oxide as lime. Calcite has a strong reflection near 29.4° two-theta, and lime has its own set; both are distinguishable from the citrate pattern. Ask for the detection limit with any “not detected” statement, because a scan without a limit says nothing about a small addition.

Loss on drying is the practical hydrate test. The specification limit is 13.0%, and a result between about 10% and 13% is the tetrahydrate. An anhydrous citrate would report a much lower loss and a calcium figure near 24%. The two results, calcium and loss on drying, are enough to separate the hydrate from the anhydrous salt in most cases; the XRD note explains when a crystal scan adds to them.

The three common adulterants

Calcium carbonate is the first. It carries about 40% calcium, has no citrate, holds no water of crystallisation, and effervesces in acid. A blend of citrate and carbonate can be tuned to land inside the 21.0–22.0% calcium window, so the calcium figure alone will not catch it. The citrate assay, the loss on drying and an XRD scan for calcite do.

Calcium oxide is the second. It carries about 71% calcium, reacts with water to form the hydroxide, and gives a strongly alkaline slurry. A small addition lifts the calcium figure and the pH at the same time. Lime has its own XRD reflections, and a pH check on the slurry is a quick screen.

Citric acid is the third. It raises the citrate result without adding calcium, so the calcium-to-citrate ratio falls below 1.5. It also lowers the pH of a slurry and adds a sharp acid taste. A citrate assay interpreted without the calcium figure can miss it, which is why the ratio belongs beside both.

Phosphate and sulfate are less common and are caught by a phosphate or sulfate test if the supplier's specification does not already exclude them. The point of the list is not to test for everything; it is to test for the additions that the calcium figure cannot see.

How to write the specification

  • “Calcium citrate tetrahydrate, C12H10Ca3O14·4H2O, CAS 813-94-5.”
  • “Calcium 21.0–22.0% by complexometric EDTA; assay not less than 97.5% on the dried basis.”
  • “Loss on drying not more than 13.0% (150 °C, 4 hours), consistent with the tetrahydrate.”
  • “Citrate identification by reaction and IR, conforms to reference; citrate content by HPLC on request.”
  • “XRD screen: no crystalline calcium carbonate or calcium oxide detected; detection limit reported.”
  • “No added calcium carbonate, calcium oxide or citric acid.”

A specification that names only calcium and mesh is a specification for a calcium powder, not for calcium citrate. The hydrate, the citrate identity and the adulterant clause are what make it specific.

Five questions for the supplier

  1. Which hydrate is this lot, and what loss on drying does it report?
  2. What is the calcium result and method, and on what basis is it calculated?
  3. Is citrate identity by reaction and IR on the certificate, and can you supply a citrate assay?
  4. Is there an XRD screen for calcite and lime, and what detection limit does it state?
  5. Is any carbonate, oxide or citric acid added at any stage, and what evidence supports the answer?

Five direct answers amount to a specification; a calcium percentage does not. Each figure is tied to a certificate line on the COA page, the salt choice is set out on the grade page, the substitution risk is covered on the citrate versus carbonate page, and the catalog limits sit on the product hub. The FTIR note explains what the spectrum comparison can and cannot show.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation