02.1 PC vs lecithin

Phosphatidylcholine vs lecithin: the isolate and the mixture

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Phosphatidylcholine

On this page
  1. What each headline percentage counts
  2. What the other 10% is
  3. Dose arithmetic on the declared figure
  4. The soy declaration follows the source
  5. Emulsifier, dose ingredient or both
  6. Which one the formula needs

Lecithin is the mixture; phosphatidylcholine is one phospholipid class within it, and a PC 90 grade is that class concentrated. The two are not two strengths of one ingredient: lecithin is standardised on the total phosphatide fraction, while a PC grade is standardised on a single class measured by HPLC. The 90% and 60% figures count different things, and the dose, the label and the allergen statement follow the name on the certificate.

In one line

A 90% PC grade and a 60% lecithin are not the same number in different units: one counts a single phospholipid class and the other counts the whole phosphatide fraction.

What each headline percentage counts

Three numbers appear on lecithin and PC certificates, and they are not interchangeable: acetone-insoluble matter, total phospholipids and PC. Acetone-insoluble matter is a residue after acetone extraction; total phospholipids is a phosphorus calculation; PC is a class-specific HPLC result. A lecithin grade is usually standardised on the first or the second, while a PC grade is standardised on the third.

That is why a 60% lecithin and a 90% PC grade cannot be compared by their headline figures. The first says that about 60% of the material resists acetone; the second says that about 90% of the material is one phospholipid class. Both percentages are read against the powder; what changes is the numerator, which is the total phosphatide fraction in one case and a single class in the other.

What the headline figure on a certificate counts
FigureMethodWhat it counts
Acetone-insoluble matterGravimetric acetone extractionMaterial that resists acetone, phosphatides plus any other insoluble residue
Total phospholipidsPhosphorus multiplied by a stated factorThe phosphatide fraction across all classes
PhosphatidylcholineHPLC class separationOne class, measured against a PC standard
OilDifference or extractionNeutral lipid left in the material

A certificate that prints one figure and calls it “purity” has hidden which question it answered. Name the method and the quantity the percentage refers to before comparing two materials.

What the other 10% is

A lecithin carries PC, PE, PI and PA, and often oil, sterols and glycolipids. A 90% PC grade has had most of the oil removed and most of the other classes reduced, but the remaining 10% is still a mixture: residual PE, PI and PA, some lyso-PC, a little neutral oil and moisture. The PC figure describes the class, not the whole powder.

The residual profile is a specification line, not a rounding error. A grade with 90% PC and 6% PE is a different material from one with 90% PC and 1% PE, even when the headline agrees. Ask for the class profile beside the PC figure, and read the two together.

The fatty acid profile adds a second dimension. Soy PC is linoleic-dominant with a measurable alpha-linolenic fraction; sunflower PC has a different pattern; egg PC differs again. The PC figure can agree while the source differs, which is why identity is a profile question and not a single assay.

Dose arithmetic on the declared figure

Dose arithmetic uses the figure the label declares. For 250 mg PC, a 90% grade needs 278 mg, while a lecithin carrying 20% PC needs 1,250 mg. For 300 mg total phospholipids, a 60% lecithin needs 500 mg, while a 90% PC grade is not the right input unless the label is rewritten to a PC claim.

If the label declares choline, the divisor is the choline figure. Soy PC carries about 13% choline by mass, so 250 mg PC is roughly 32.5 mg choline. The exact value depends on the PC figure and the fatty acid composition, and it belongs on the certificate rather than in a conversion applied at the balance.

These are arithmetic illustrations, not a dose recommendation. The point is that the two materials need different weights for the same label number, and a switch between them changes the capsule or the stick weight and the specification behind it.

The soy declaration follows the source

When both are soy-derived, both carry the soy allergen declaration. In the EU, soy is listed in Annex II of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, and the exemption for fully refined soybean oil does not extend to phospholipids. In the US, soy is a major food allergen under FALCPA. A soy-derived PC is not exempt because it is purified.

A sunflower-derived PC removes the soy declaration but changes the source statement; an egg-derived PC brings egg into the file. The source is part of the identity, and a change of source is a change control. The allergen statement should name the source, not only the product name.

A GMO statement is separate from the allergen statement. A soy source can raise a labelling question under Regulation (EC) No 1829/2003 in the EU, and the buyer's regulatory team confirms the route for the destination.

Emulsifier, dose ingredient or both

Lecithin is used as an emulsifier and as a mixed phospholipid source. Its value comes from the mixture: the classes sit at an oil-water interface together and stabilise a dispersion. A PC grade is used where the formula or the label calls for a declared PC figure, and its surface behaviour is different because the other classes have been reduced.

A PC grade is not a drop-in emulsifier for lecithin, and lecithin is not a short route to a PC claim. A formulator who replaces one with the other has changed the ingredient, the mass and the interface behaviour at the same time.

None of this makes them interchangeable. They are different purchases, and the specification should say which question the material is there to answer.

Which one the formula needs

Choose lecithin when the function is emulsification, when the label names lecithin, or when a mixed phosphatide source is wanted. Choose the PC grade when the label declares PC, when the formula is built around that class, or when the residual oil and the other classes are a problem for the dose.

Choose neither for a soy-free claim; change the source. Choose a hydrogenated or lyso-PC grade only when that modified material is the specification, not as a way to raise the PC figure.

The catalog specification is on the phosphatidylcholine product page; the lecithin product page is the separate mixture. The grades page places this comparison in the PC range, the COA page shows how the class figure is reported, the methods library explains the HPLC separation and the quality page covers release.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation