06 Identity & adulteration

How we prove a borage oil lot is borage oil

Technical document 06 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Borage Oil

On this page
  1. The evidence has to agree
  2. The GLA/linoleic ratio and the minor acids
  3. What XRD can and cannot show for an oil
  4. The routes that matter
  5. What the identity specification should say
  6. Five questions for a supplier

A borage oil lot is identified by its full fatty-acid profile, not by a single GLA number. Genuine borage carries 18–25% GLA with 30–40% linoleic, 15–25% oleic and small amounts of erucic and nervonic acid; evening primrose oil carries 8–11% GLA with 70–75% linoleic. A blend can be built to hit a GLA figure, so the profile, minor acids, sterol pattern and paper trail are the evidence.

In one line

Identity is the full fatty-acid profile together with the minor acids and the paper trail, because a GLA figure on its own can be blended to order.

The evidence has to agree

Identity is built from agreeing evidence, not from one test. Start with the paper: species, plant part, where the seed came from, where it was pressed or refined, and the lot code. Then look at the oil: appearance, colour, odour and clarity can separate fresh from aged but cannot name the species. The chemical layer is the GC fatty-acid profile, the minor acids and, if the source is disputed, the sterol and tocopherol patterns. The last layer is oxidation: peroxide and p-anisidine values, because a genuine oil that has oxidised is still failing.

Agreement is the point. A certificate may name the right species while describing a different oil; a blend can reproduce a GC profile; a pale, clear oil can be oxidised. The layers must point the same way and belong to one lot, so the lot code on the certificate, the drum and the retained sample has to line up.

The GLA/linoleic ratio and the minor acids

Borage oil is not simply a stronger evening primrose oil: its GLA is roughly twice as concentrated, but its linoleic acid is roughly half and it carries erucic and nervonic acids that evening primrose does not. The ratio of GLA to linoleic acid is therefore a more useful marker than GLA alone: borage sits around 0.45–0.83, evening primrose around 0.11–0.16.

Typical fatty-acid markers that separate borage from other GLA oils
MarkerBorageEvening primroseBlackcurrant
GLA (C18:3 n-6)18–25%8–11%14–19%
Linoleic (C18:2 n-6)30–40%70–75%40–45%
Oleic (C18:1 n-9)15–25%8–12%10–13%
Erucic (C22:1)About 1–3%TraceTrace
Nervonic (C24:1)About 1–2%TraceTrace
GLA : linoleicAbout 0.45–0.83About 0.11–0.16About 0.31–0.48

The ranges are typical, not specifications. The certificate reports the measured profile of the lot, and the erucic and nervonic figures are worth reporting even when they are not release limits, because a dilution or substitution is most likely to disturb them. If the customer buys against a pharmacopoeial monograph, put the erucic and nervonic caps in the specification; the catalog range does not set them.

What XRD can and cannot show for an oil

X-ray diffraction identifies crystalline phases. Borage oil is a liquid triglyceride at room temperature and has no crystal lattice to diffract, so an XRD pattern of the neat oil is not an identity test for the species. The technique becomes relevant when the oil is carried on a powder: the carrier, usually a starch or a modified starch, is crystalline enough to give a pattern, and XRD can show which carrier phase is present or whether a crystalline foreign phase has appeared.

Read an “XRD identity” line on a powder certificate as a carrier check. It does not prove that the oil is borage oil, and a pattern that matches a starch reference says nothing about the fatty-acid profile. The oil identity belongs to the GC section and to the sterol data where a source is disputed. A supplier offering a spectral fingerprint as the whole identity argument should be asked which phase it measures and which reference it uses.

For a starch carrier, XRD is well suited; for the oil itself, it is the wrong instrument. The certificate should say what each method measures, and the buyer should match the method to the question.

The routes that matter

The first route is dilution: a lower-cost oil with little or no GLA can be blended with a GLA concentrate to reach 18–25%, and the GLA figure alone will pass. Dilution shifts the linoleic and oleic values, while the erucic and nervonic acids fall or disappear; that is why the full profile is the check. The second route is substitution with evening primrose oil: the GLA figure falls short of borage, so it is usually combined with a concentrate, and the high linoleic figure is the tell.

The third route is a low-GLA borage oil sold against a high-GLA specification. The species and profile shape are right, but the concentration is at the bottom of the range; the lot is genuine and still the wrong grade for the label. The fourth route is oxidation: the profile stays correct while peroxide and p-anisidine values climb, and the oil is no longer the material the specification describes. The fifth is the alkaloid question: a lot can be genuine borage oil and still carry a PA load that fails the destination limit.

The checks follow the routes: full fatty-acid profile with the chromatogram, erucic and nervonic figures, sterol and tocopherol patterns where a blend is suspected, peroxide and p-anisidine values, and a PA screen by LC-MS/MS. No single GLA result covers those five routes, and a certificate that reports only GLA and peroxide leaves the adulteration question open.

What the identity specification should say

Name the species and the plant part, not just the common name: “borage (Borago officinalis) seed oil”. Add the process — cold-pressed or refined — the GLA range and its basis, the full fatty-acid profile with linoleic, oleic, erucic and nervonic, the sterol profile if the customer requires it, and the oxidation limits. State how identity is measured: methyl esters separated by GC-FID, peaks matched to a certified standard, and a column that separates GLA from alpha-linolenic acid.

A specification that says “borage oil 20%” or “GLA oil” does not give the laboratory a way to check the source or the grade. A specification that gives the species, the process and the profile does. The certificate should repeat those lines and carry the lot code that matches the pack and the retained sample; a certificate that cannot be tied to the drum is a document, not a trace.

Five questions for a supplier

  1. Which species and which plant part is the oil from, and is the lot single-source or a blend?
  2. What are the GLA, linoleic, oleic, erucic and nervonic figures on the same lot, with the chromatogram?
  3. Is the grade cold-pressed or refined, and which process steps were applied?
  4. What are the peroxide and p-anisidine values, with methods, and what is the storage history?
  5. What is the PA result, the method and the limit of quantification, and can you send the COA for the lot that will ship?

The catalog limits are on the borage oil product page. Release tests are listed on the COA page, the alternative source is covered on the evening primrose oil powder page, analytical methods are indexed under methods, and retained samples are described on the quality page.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation