Serratiopeptidase vs nattokinase: two proteases, two units
Serratiopeptidase and nattokinase are both protease powders sold by activity, and that is where the similarity ends. One is a zinc metalloprotease from Serratia marcescens, measured in casein units; the other is a serine protease from Bacillus subtilis natto, measured in fibrin units. The numbers, the assays, the molecular masses and the regulatory files are different, so neither powder substitutes for the other on a label or in a blend.
Serratiopeptidase is a zinc metalloprotease measured in casein units and nattokinase a serine protease measured in fibrin units, so the two numbers are not two spellings of one potency.
Two enzyme classes, two mechanisms
Serratiopeptidase, also called serrapeptase, is EC 3.4.24.40 and belongs to the M10B metallopeptidase family. Its catalytic site depends on zinc, and calcium contributes to the stability of the folded protein. Its molecular mass is reported broadly between 45 and 51 kDa.
Nattokinase is a serine protease of the subtilisin type, produced by Bacillus subtilis natto. It does not depend on a zinc centre in the same way, and its molecular mass is close to 28 kDa.
| Property | Serratiopeptidase | Nattokinase |
|---|---|---|
| Enzyme class | Zinc metalloprotease, family M10B | Serine protease, subtilisin type |
| Source organism | Serratia marcescens | Bacillus subtilis natto |
| Molecular mass | About 45–51 kDa | About 28 kDa |
| Metal dependence | Zinc in the active site; calcium for stability | No zinc centre; serine catalytic triad |
| Assay substrate | Casein | Fibrin |
| Usual activity unit | U/g on casein | FU/g on fibrin |
U/g on casein and FU/g on fibrin
A serratiopeptidase unit is defined by the casein Folin assay: the enzyme acts on casein, the soluble peptides are coloured, and the colour is read against a tyrosine standard. One unit is the amount of enzyme that releases 1 µg of tyrosine per minute under the conditions the method names. The pH and temperature are part of the definition, which is why two method sheets can produce different figures for the same powder.
A nattokinase FU is defined on fibrin. The common trade definition is an absorbance change at 275 nm of 0.01 per minute, and some method sheets define one FU as 1 µg of tyrosine released per minute or as a defined lysis area on a fibrin plate. The substrate and the detection principle are different from the casein assay, so the two units are separate scales.
| Unit | Substrate | Detection | What it describes |
|---|---|---|---|
| U/g (serratiopeptidase) | Casein | Folin-Ciocalteu colour, tyrosine standard | Casein-hydrolysing rate |
| FU/g (nattokinase) | Fibrin | Absorbance at 275 nm, tyrosine colour or lysis area | Fibrin-directed rate |
| IU (nattokinase) | Synthetic chromogenic peptide | Absorbance at 405 nm | Peptide-cleavage rate |
A figure written as “20,000 units per gram” without the substrate is not a specification.
Why the figures do not convert
A conversion factor would require the ratio between the two assays to be constant across every preparation, and it is not. Fermentation, recovery and standardisation change the protein mixture, and the two substrates respond differently to that mixture.
What does convert is arithmetic inside one unit system. One kilogram at 20,000 U/g carries 20 million U, and two kilograms at 10,000 U/g carry the same total. That calculation is useful for ordering and blending, and it says nothing about how casein units relate to fibrin units.
When a customer needs a figure in a unit the supplier does not report, the answer is an assay, not a multiplication. Ask for the lot to be tested in the required unit, with the method and the raw result stated.
Telling them apart in the laboratory
SDS-PAGE is the quickest separation. Serratiopeptidase gives a band in the 45–51 kDa region, and nattokinase a band near 28 kDa. A band at an unexpected mass, or two bands, needs a declaration before use.
The activity assays add a second dimension. A lot that is active on casein but not on fibrin is not nattokinase, and a lot that is active on both substrates may be a blend. The specific activity, the inhibitor pattern and the IR spectrum complete the file. XRD is not the tool here: both powders are largely amorphous, and a crystalline pattern would point to a carrier or a salt rather than to the enzyme.
The serratiopeptidase identity page sets out the layers in full.
Formulation and handling differences
The metalloprotease is sensitive to chelators. EDTA and other strong chelating agents can remove the zinc the enzyme depends on, and a mineral premix can present metal ions in a form that interferes with the preparation. Calcium contributes to stability, so a formulation that strips divalent ions is a compatibility question for this enzyme in a way that it is not for a serine protease.
Both enzymes are proteins and both lose activity with heat and moisture, so both need a sealed, dry pack and a process that does not overheat them. Enteric-coated capsules and granules are common for both, and the coating step adds solvent, heat and mechanical stress; the activity after coating is the number that belongs in the specification.
A wet granulation can dilute the activity per gram while leaving the protein pattern intact, and the casein assay will show it. A blend with bromelain or papain, both cysteine proteases, will raise the casein activity and change the protein pattern; the bromelain page describes that material on its own terms. The methods page covers the assay side of the comparison.
The label and the regulatory file
The two names are not interchangeable on a label. Serratiopeptidase is declared as serratiopeptidase, with its activity and unit; nattokinase is declared as nattokinase or as the preparation that the market file names.
The regulatory files are also separate. As of this review, a nattokinase-containing fermented soybean extract has an EU novel-food entry that names the preparation and an activity range in FU/g; that entry does not cover serratiopeptidase. Serratiopeptidase has its own route question, and the destination decides whether a food-supplement file is available. The serratiopeptidase compliance page and the nattokinase product page set out the two files.
A switch from one to the other is a new specification, a new label and a new market check. It is not a substitution that can be managed by adjusting the number on the artwork.
What to specify when either could fit
Start with the market file, not with the activity figure. If the destination covers one preparation and not the other, the choice is made. If both are available, choose the unit the buyer's laboratory can run and the supplier's certificate can support, then check the dose mass and the dosage form against the activity per gram.
When two quotations are compared, put the enzyme name, the source, the activity, the substrate and the method side by side. Ask each supplier for the assay method, the protein result and the protein pattern, and handle a blend as a separate product with its own specification.
The serratiopeptidase hub carries the catalog figures, the nattokinase hub carries the other specification, and the quality page describes how each lot is released against its own method.
Related documents
Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.
Request a quotation