02.1 Alkaline vs neutral

Alkaline vs neutral protease: pH, substrate and the label

Technical document 02.1 · Reviewed 2026-11-19 · Alkaline Protease

On this page
  1. Two activities, two mechanisms
  2. The pH window is the working difference
  3. Substrate, unit and why the two figures do not compare
  4. Stability follows the mechanism
  5. What the label and the specification must say
  6. Choosing between them

Alkaline protease and neutral protease are both endopeptidases produced by Bacillus, and they are not interchangeable. Alkaline protease from B. licheniformis is a subtilisin-type serine protease, EC 3.4.21.62, specified at pH 8.0–10.0 and ≥200,000 U/g. Neutral protease from B. subtilis is a zinc metalloprotease, EC 3.4.24.28, specified at pH 6.5–7.5 and ≥50,000 U/g. The pH window, the assay and the enzyme name on the label all change when one replaces the other.

In one line

The two powders are not interchangeable: the pH of the assay, the pH of the blend and the enzyme name on the label all change together.

Two activities, two mechanisms

Alkaline protease is a serine endopeptidase of the subtilisin family, with a catalytic triad and no metal cofactor. Neutral protease is a metalloendopeptidase that carries a zinc ion in its active site, and that single difference explains most of the practical behaviour: the alkaline enzyme keeps working in alkaline solution, and the neutral one does not.

Both are sold as food enzyme preparations and both hydrolyse peptide bonds, but they are separate entries in an enzyme file, with separate production organisms, separate CAS numbers and separate specifications. A blend that carries both has two enzymes in it, and the certificate has to describe each one on its own terms.

The pH window is the working difference

Alkaline and neutral protease compared on the lines that decide a blend
LineAlkaline proteaseNeutral protease
Production organismBacillus licheniformisBacillus subtilis
Enzyme classSerine endopeptidase, EC 3.4.21.62Metalloendopeptidase, EC 3.4.24.28
CAS number9014-01-19025-39-2
Catalog activity≥200,000 U/g≥50,000 U/g
pH, 1% solution8.0–10.06.5–7.5
Assay pH in trade useAbout 10.0About 7.0
Inhibitor that mattersPhenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride (PMSF) and similar reagentsEDTA and other chelators

The catalog pH is measured on a 1% solution, so it describes the powder rather than the blend. It is still the clearest signal of where each enzyme was built to work, and a formulator should read it as the middle of the range, not as the edge.

Substrate, unit and why the two figures do not compare

Both assays commonly use casein as the substrate and a colorimetric detection of the products, but they run at different pH values, and that alone makes the two unit scales incomparable. A neutral protease assayed at pH 7 and an alkaline protease assayed at pH 10 are measuring different rates of two different catalysts; there is no factor that converts 50,000 U/g of one into a figure for the other.

Even within one enzyme, the substrate choice moves the number. Casein, haemoglobin and synthetic peptides present different cleavage sites, and a preparation rich in one activity can read high on one substrate and modest on another. The unit definition — micrograms or micromoles of tyrosine equivalent, the incubation time and the detection chemistry — belongs in the specification, and the U versus AU note for the neutral enzyme sets out how far apart two protease unit systems can sit.

The practical rule is that each enzyme is dosed against its own assay. A blend needing a target number of units of each is calculated twice, from two certificates, and the totals are never added into a single “protease activity” figure.

Stability follows the mechanism

The alkaline enzyme tolerates alkaline solution and loses activity when the pH falls below its window; the neutral one is comfortable near pH 7 and loses activity outside it. Both lose activity to heat and water, and both are respiratory sensitisers as powders, so the safety data sheet and the dust controls apply to either.

The chelator line is the one that catches formulators. A neutral metalloprotease loses its zinc and its activity in the presence of EDTA or a similar chelating agent, and a blend that contains one can inactivate the neutral enzyme without touching the alkaline one. The reverse risk runs through acidic actives: a vitamin C or citric acid component can pull the local pH below 7, where the alkaline enzyme sits outside its window. Check the blend pH at the start and after storage, as the stability page sets out.

What the label and the specification must say

Each enzyme is declared by its own name, with the activity and its unit, and with the carrier. “Protease” alone is not enough when the label or the specification is meant to identify which of the two is present, and a blend carrying both lists both. The activity figure carries the unit definition, because 200,000 U/g and 50,000 U/g describe two assays rather than two strengths.

Regulatory status is also preparation-specific. The alkaline enzyme from B. licheniformis and the neutral enzyme from B. subtilis sit under different entries in an enzyme file and, in the United States, under different bases, so a compliance statement written for one does not transfer to the other; the compliance page covers the alkaline side.

Choosing between them

Start with the pH the enzyme will actually see. A blend that is neutral to slightly acidic points to the neutral enzyme, unless it carries a chelator, which rules that enzyme out. A blend that is alkaline, or a process step that runs at pH 9–10, points to the alkaline one. If the process moves through a pH range, both may have a place, and each is dosed against its own assay rather than against a combined figure.

Then check the physical form and the dose. The alkaline grade is a 40 mesh powder at ≥200,000 U/g, so it is weighed in small amounts; the neutral grade at ≥50,000 U/g is weighed in larger ones for the same number of units. A line that cannot weigh small charges accurately may prefer the lower-activity grade, and the grades page explains what changes with a dilution. Neither choice is a statement about the finished product; it is a statement about which catalyst fits the process, and the catalog entries are on the alkaline protease and neutral protease product pages.

Send the specification you intend to use — grade, quantity and destination market — and we will reply with the batch COA, the technical data sheet and a quotation.

Request a quotation